Duty of Care
Does a Duty Exist?
The first element of negligence. Before fault can attach, you must determine whether the defendant owed the plaintiff a legal duty to act with reasonable care.
Where Duty Fits in Negligence
A negligence claim has four elements. A plaintiff must prove every one. Duty comes first — without it, the claim fails before liability is even reached.
Defining Duty of Care
A duty of care is a legal obligation to conform one's conduct to a standard of reasonable care for the protection of others against unreasonable risks of harm.
The Foreseeable Plaintiff
A duty is owed only to those within the foreseeable zone of danger — plaintiffs a reasonable person would anticipate being harmed by the conduct (the Cardozo / majority view).
The General Rule
The No-Duty-to-Act Rule
There is generally no duty to rescue or affirmatively aid a stranger. A bystander may watch someone drown and owe no legal duty — unless an exception applies.
Cardozo vs. Andrews
The two competing views on to whom a duty is owed — the bar tests both. Know which is the majority rule.
| Cardozo (Majority) | Andrews (Minority) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who is owed a duty? | Only foreseeable plaintiffs | Everyone (duty to all) |
| Key question | Was P in the zone of danger? | Was P harmed by D's act? |
| Foreseeability matters at | Duty stage | Proximate cause stage |
| Bar default | Use this view | Note as minority |
How to Analyze Duty
Special Standards of Care
The default is the reasonable person, but certain defendants are held to modified standards. The duty still exists — only the measuring stick changes.
Worked Example One
A driver runs a red light and strikes a pedestrian crossing legally. Does the driver owe a duty?
Worked Example Two
A man walking by a lake sees a stranger drowning. He does nothing. The stranger dies. Did the man owe a duty to rescue?
Worked Example Three
A railroad guard shoves a passenger to help him board. A package falls, hidden fireworks explode, and the blast topples scales onto a distant woman. Does the railroad owe her a duty?
Common Mistakes
Duty Quick Reference
| Scenario | Duty? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Affirmative act, foreseeable P | Yes | General rule |
| Affirmative act, unforeseeable P | No | Outside zone (Cardozo) |
| Failure to act, stranger | No | No duty to rescue |
| Failure to act, special relationship | Yes | Exception applies |
| D created the peril | Yes | Duty to assist |
Question 1 of 5
Duty of care is best characterized as a question of:
Question 2 of 5
Under the majority (Cardozo) view, a duty of care is owed to:
Question 3 of 5
A passerby watches a stranger drowning and does nothing, though rescue would be easy. The passerby most likely:
Question 4 of 5
Which of the following would create an affirmative duty to act where one would otherwise not exist?
Question 5 of 5
A railroad employee, trying to help a late passenger board a moving train, pushes him aboard. The passenger drops a plain, unmarked package, which actually contains fireworks. The package explodes on the tracks. The shock allegedly causes scales at the far end of the platform to fall, injuring a woman standing many feet away.
The woman sues the railroad for negligence.
Under the majority view, the railroad most likely owed the woman: