I'll generate a complete, self-contained HTML slide deck on "Duty of Care" for the Bar Exam following the exact design system. ```html Duty of Care — Bar Exam
01 / 20

Duty of Care
Does a Duty Exist?

The first element of negligence. Before fault can attach, you must determine whether the defendant owed the plaintiff a legal duty to act with reasonable care.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Where Duty Fits in Negligence

A negligence claim has four elements. A plaintiff must prove every one. Duty comes first — without it, the claim fails before liability is even reached.

Duty Element 1 Breach Element 2 Causation Element 3 Damages Element 4

Defining Duty of Care

A duty of care is a legal obligation to conform one's conduct to a standard of reasonable care for the protection of others against unreasonable risks of harm.

Who Owes It?
The defendant whose conduct created a foreseeable risk.
To Whom?
Foreseeable plaintiffs in the zone of danger.
What Standard?
The reasonably prudent person under the circumstances.

The Foreseeable Plaintiff

A duty is owed only to those within the foreseeable zone of danger — plaintiffs a reasonable person would anticipate being harmed by the conduct (the Cardozo / majority view).

Zone of Danger D P1 owed duty P2 P3 no duty (unforeseeable)

The General Rule

1
Affirmative act: The defendant did something (drove, built, manufactured) that created risk.
2
Foreseeable plaintiff: The injured party was within the zone of danger created by that act.
3
Standard of care: The conduct is measured against the reasonably prudent person.

The No-Duty-to-Act Rule

There is generally no duty to rescue or affirmatively aid a stranger. A bystander may watch someone drown and owe no legal duty — unless an exception applies.

Special Relationship
Common carrier–passenger, innkeeper–guest, employer–employee, parent–child.
Defendant Created Peril
If D caused the danger (even innocently), a duty to assist arises.
Assumed Duty
Once you begin to rescue, you must act with reasonable care.

Cardozo vs. Andrews

The two competing views on to whom a duty is owed — the bar tests both. Know which is the majority rule.

Cardozo (Majority) Andrews (Minority)
Who is owed a duty?Only foreseeable plaintiffsEveryone (duty to all)
Key questionWas P in the zone of danger?Was P harmed by D's act?
Foreseeability matters atDuty stageProximate cause stage
Bar defaultUse this viewNote as minority

How to Analyze Duty

1
Identify the conduct. Did D act affirmatively, or merely fail to act?
2
If a failure to act, check for an exception (special relationship, created peril, assumed duty).
3
Identify the plaintiff. Was P a foreseeable victim within the zone of danger?
4
State the standard. Apply the reasonably prudent person, adjusting for special standards.
5
Conclude. If yes to all, a duty exists and the analysis proceeds to breach.

Special Standards of Care

The default is the reasonable person, but certain defendants are held to modified standards. The duty still exists — only the measuring stick changes.

Professionals
Care of an average member of that profession in good standing.
Children
A child of like age, intelligence, and experience.
Landowners
Duty varies by entrant: invitee, licensee, or trespasser.

Worked Example One

A driver runs a red light and strikes a pedestrian crossing legally. Does the driver owe a duty?

Driver (D) affirmative act creates risk Pedestrian (P) foreseeable victim ✓ Duty

Worked Example Two

A man walking by a lake sees a stranger drowning. He does nothing. The stranger dies. Did the man owe a duty to rescue?

Bystander mere inaction no act Stranger no relationship ✕ No Duty

Worked Example Three

A railroad guard shoves a passenger to help him board. A package falls, hidden fireworks explode, and the blast topples scales onto a distant woman. Does the railroad owe her a duty?

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping the foreseeability check
Assuming any injured person is owed a duty. Under Cardozo, only foreseeable plaintiffs are.
✕ Confusing duty with breach
Duty asks whether care is owed; breach asks whether it was met. Keep them separate.
✕ Forgetting nonfeasance
Failing to act usually creates no duty unless an exception applies.
✕ Treating duty as a jury question
Duty is a question of law for the judge, not a fact for the jury.

Duty Quick Reference

Scenario Duty? Why
Affirmative act, foreseeable PYesGeneral rule
Affirmative act, unforeseeable PNoOutside zone (Cardozo)
Failure to act, strangerNoNo duty to rescue
Failure to act, special relationshipYesException applies
D created the perilYesDuty to assist

Question 1 of 5

Duty of care is best characterized as a question of:

Question 2 of 5

Under the majority (Cardozo) view, a duty of care is owed to:

Question 3 of 5

A passerby watches a stranger drowning and does nothing, though rescue would be easy. The passerby most likely:

Question 4 of 5

Which of the following would create an affirmative duty to act where one would otherwise not exist?

Question 5 of 5

Under the majority view, the railroad most likely owed the woman:

You Can Now Determine Duty