Duty Breach
Analysis
Learn to evaluate breaches of the duty of care and the duty of loyalty in negligence and fiduciary settings.
What Is a Duty?
A duty is a legal obligation requiring a person to conform to a standard of conduct for the protection of others. When the law imposes a duty and the defendant fails to meet it, a breach occurs.
Two Core Duties
Why Breach Analysis Matters
The Reasonable Person Standard
The duty of care is measured against an objective standard: what a reasonably prudent person would do under the circumstances. A breach occurs when conduct falls below this standard.
The Hand Formula
Judge Learned Hand reduced breach to a cost-benefit test. A defendant breaches the duty of care when the burden of precaution is less than the probability of harm multiplied by its severity:
If the cost of preventing harm \( (B) \) was small relative to the expected harm \( (P \times L) \), failing to take that precaution is unreasonable, and a breach exists.
The Duty of Loyalty Rule
Care vs. Loyalty: A Key Distinction
How to Analyze a Breach
Worked Example: Care
A store owner ignored a spilled liquid for two hours. A mop costs almost nothing \( (B \approx 0) \). The chance of a slip was high \( (P) \) and a fall could cause serious injury \( (L) \).
Worked Example: Loyalty
A corporate director learns of a profitable contract intended for the company. Instead, the director secretly diverts the deal to a business they personally own, without disclosure.
Worked Example: Both Duties
A trustee invests trust funds skillfully and earns strong returns, but routes all trades through a brokerage they secretly co-own, collecting hidden commissions.
Common Mistakes
Summary Comparison
| Duty of Care | Duty of Loyalty | |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | Reasonable person | Best interest of principal |
| Focus | Competence | Self-interest |
| Test | \( B < P \times L \) | Self-dealing / conflict |
| Context | Negligence (broad) | Fiduciary relationships |
| Defense | Acted reasonably | Full disclosure + consent |
Quick Recap
Question 1 of 5
Under the Hand Formula, a defendant breaches the duty of care when:
Question 2 of 5
The duty of care is measured against which standard?
Question 3 of 5
A trust company manages a client's portfolio with skill, earning above-market returns. However, it routes every trade through a brokerage it secretly co-owns, pocketing undisclosed commissions on each transaction.
Which duty has the trust company most clearly breached?
Question 4 of 5
A fiduciary can avoid a duty-of-loyalty breach when engaging in self-interested dealing by:
Question 5 of 5
When analyzing a breach, the first step is to: