01 / 20

Duty Breach
Analysis

Learn to evaluate breaches of the duty of care and the duty of loyalty in negligence and fiduciary settings.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Duty?

A duty is a legal obligation requiring a person to conform to a standard of conduct for the protection of others. When the law imposes a duty and the defendant fails to meet it, a breach occurs.

Two Core Duties

Duty of Care
The obligation to act as a reasonably prudent person would under similar circumstances. Central to negligence.
Duty of Loyalty
A fiduciary must act in the principal's best interest, avoiding self-dealing and conflicts of interest.

Why Breach Analysis Matters

Duty Breach Causation Damages The pivotal element you must prove

The Reasonable Person Standard

The duty of care is measured against an objective standard: what a reasonably prudent person would do under the circumstances. A breach occurs when conduct falls below this standard.

The Hand Formula

Judge Learned Hand reduced breach to a cost-benefit test. A defendant breaches the duty of care when the burden of precaution is less than the probability of harm multiplied by its severity:

If the cost of preventing harm \( (B) \) was small relative to the expected harm \( (P \times L) \), failing to take that precaution is unreasonable, and a breach exists.

The Duty of Loyalty Rule

Fiduciary (trustee) Principal (beneficiary) owes loyalty grants trust / authority

Care vs. Loyalty: A Key Distinction

Duty of Care
Focuses on competence and diligence. Breach = carelessness measured objectively against a reasonable standard.
Duty of Loyalty
Focuses on good faith and self-interest. Breach = putting personal gain ahead of the principal, regardless of skill.

How to Analyze a Breach

1
Identify the applicable standard. Reasonable person, professional, or fiduciary duty?
2
State the defendant's actual conduct. What did they do or fail to do?
3
Compare conduct to the standard. For care, apply the Hand Formula \( B < P \times L \).
4
Conclude. If conduct falls below the standard, a breach exists.

Worked Example: Care

A store owner ignored a spilled liquid for two hours. A mop costs almost nothing \( (B \approx 0) \). The chance of a slip was high \( (P) \) and a fall could cause serious injury \( (L) \).

Worked Example: Loyalty

A corporate director learns of a profitable contract intended for the company. Instead, the director secretly diverts the deal to a business they personally own, without disclosure.

Worked Example: Both Duties

A trustee invests trust funds skillfully and earns strong returns, but routes all trades through a brokerage they secretly co-own, collecting hidden commissions.

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping the Standard
Concluding breach without first stating the applicable standard of care or loyalty.
✕ Merging Duties
Treating care and loyalty as one. A defendant can breach one without the other.
✕ Good Faith Defense
Assuming a self-dealing fiduciary escapes liability just because they earned good results.

Summary Comparison

Duty of Care Duty of Loyalty
StandardReasonable personBest interest of principal
FocusCompetenceSelf-interest
Test\( B < P \times L \)Self-dealing / conflict
ContextNegligence (broad)Fiduciary relationships
DefenseActed reasonablyFull disclosure + consent

Quick Recap

1
Duty of care is breached when conduct falls below the reasonable person standard.
2
Hand Formula: breach exists when \( B < P \times L \).
3
Duty of loyalty is breached by self-dealing or conflicts of interest, even with good results.
4
Always analyze each duty separately against its own standard.

Question 1 of 5

Under the Hand Formula, a defendant breaches the duty of care when:

Question 2 of 5

The duty of care is measured against which standard?

Question 3 of 5

Which duty has the trust company most clearly breached?

Question 4 of 5

A fiduciary can avoid a duty-of-loyalty breach when engaging in self-interested dealing by:

Question 5 of 5

When analyzing a breach, the first step is to: