01 / 20

Duress and
Undue Influence

When agreement is forced or unfairly persuaded, the law lets the victim escape. Learn to identify contracts tainted by improper pressure.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Problem of Unfree Consent

A valid contract requires genuine assent. But what if a party "agreed" only because they were threatened, or because a trusted person exploited their relationship?

Defining Duress

Duress is an improper threat that leaves the victim with no reasonable alternative but to assent to the contract.

1
An improper threat. Physical harm, criminal prosecution, or a wrongful threat to breach an existing contract.
2
No reasonable alternative. The victim had no practical way out except to agree.
3
The threat induced assent. It actually caused the victim to enter the contract.

Defining Undue Influence

Undue influence is unfair persuasion of a party who is under the domination of, or specially reliant upon, the persuader.

Two Paths to Unfree Assent

DURESS Improper Threat No Reasonable Alternative "Fear" UNDUE INFLUENCE Relationship of Trust Excessive Persuasion "Vulnerability" Result: Voidable (or Void) Result: Voidable

Two Flavors of Duress

Physical Duress
A threat of physical force compels the signature. The contract is void, not merely voidable: there is no assent at all.
Economic Duress
A wrongful threat (e.g., to breach unless paid more) leaves no reasonable alternative. The contract is voidable.

Elements of Undue Influence

1
Susceptible party. Someone dependent, weakened, or in a relationship of trust with the persuader.
2
Opportunity to exert influence. The persuader had access and standing to apply pressure.
3
Improper or excessive persuasion. Pressure that overcomes the victim's free and competent judgment.
4
Resulting unfair transaction. Terms that strongly favor the persuader.

Duress vs. Undue Influence

Duress Undue Influence
Core wrongImproper threatUnfair persuasion
Victim's stateFear / no alternativeDependency / trust
RelationshipNot requiredUsually required
Threat needed?YesNo
EffectVoidable (or void)Voidable

How to Analyze a Fact Pattern

1
Spot the pressure. Was there a threat (duress) or a trusting relationship being exploited (undue influence)?
2
Check the threat's character. Was it improper, or just a hard bargain or lawful warning?
3
Test for free will. Did the victim have a reasonable alternative or independent advice?
4
State the remedy. Conclude the contract is voidable (or void) at the victim's election.

Example 1: Economic Duress

A contractor halfway through building a custom machine suddenly refuses to finish unless the buyer pays double. The buyer needs the machine to fill a deadline and has no time to find a replacement, so they agree.

Example 2: Undue Influence

An elderly, ailing woman relies entirely on her live-in caregiver. The caregiver repeatedly insists, in moments of confusion, that she sell him her home far below market value. She signs the deed.

Example 3: No Defense

A supplier tells a buyer: "If you don't pay the overdue invoice, I will file a lawsuit to collect." Feeling pressured, the buyer signs a payment plan.

Common Mistakes

✕ "Void" vs "Voidable"
Most duress and all undue influence make a contract voidable, not automatically void. Only physical-force duress is void.
✕ Hard Bargain = Duress
Driving a tough deal or lawful pressure is not duress. The threat must be improper or wrongful.
✕ Forgetting the Relationship
Undue influence requires dependency or trust. Pressure between strangers points to duress, not undue influence.

Quick Reference

Signal in the Facts Likely Doctrine
Threat of physical harmDuress (void)
Wrongful threat to breachEconomic duress (voidable)
Caregiver, family, fiduciaryUndue influence
Threat of valid lawsuitNo defense
Tough but lawful negotiationNo defense

Question 1 of 5

A contract entered into under undue influence is generally:

Question 2 of 5

Which element distinguishes undue influence from duress?

Question 3 of 5

The general contractor's best argument to avoid the modification is:

Question 4 of 5

A creditor tells a debtor, "Pay your overdue bill by Friday or I will file a valid lawsuit." The debtor reluctantly signs a payment plan. Is this duress?

Question 5 of 5

Which scenario most likely involves a contract that is void rather than merely voidable?

Key Takeaways

1
Duress = improper threat + no reasonable alternative + induced assent.
2
Undue influence = unfair persuasion of a dependent or trusting party.
3
Most tainted contracts are voidable: only physical-force duress is void.
4
A threat to exercise a lawful right is generally not duress.