DUI Offenses
& Vehicular Crimes
Master the elements, defenses, and grading of driving under the influence and related vehicular offenses tested on the bar.
What Is a DUI?
A DUI (driving under the influence), sometimes labeled DWI or OUI, criminalizes operating a vehicle while impaired by alcohol or drugs. Most jurisdictions punish it through two distinct theories:
The Per Se Threshold
Under the per se theory, guilt turns on a single number. The standard legal limit for an ordinary adult driver is:
The Core Elements
"Actual Physical Control"
A defendant need not be driving to be convicted. Many states impose liability where the impaired person could readily set the vehicle in motion. Courts weigh totality-of-the-circumstances factors:
Distinguishing Vehicular Crimes
| Offense | Mental State | Result Required |
|---|---|---|
| DUI (simple) | General / strict | None — driving impaired is enough |
| Vehicular assault | Recklessness | Serious bodily injury |
| Vehicular manslaughter | Recklessness or gross negligence | Death |
| DUI murder (depraved heart) | Extreme recklessness | Death + prior knowledge of danger |
When DUI Becomes Murder
A drunk-driving death is usually manslaughter. But it can rise to second-degree (depraved-heart) murder when the driver acted with an extreme indifference to human life.
Implied Consent & Testing
By driving on public roads, motorists are deemed to have impliedly consented to chemical testing (breath, blood, or urine) if lawfully arrested for DUI.
How to Analyze a DUI Question
Worked Example 1
Step 1 — Control: Engine running + keys in ignition + driver's seat ⟶ actual physical control is satisfied.
Step 2 — Theory: BAC of \( 0.11 \geq 0.08 \) establishes a per se violation; no proof of swerving needed.
Worked Example 2
Step 1 — Base offense: BAC \( \geq 0.08 \) = simple DUI is established.
Step 2 — Harm: Serious bodily injury occurred, and impaired red-light running supports recklessness.
Worked Example 3
Step 1 — Death + impairment: At minimum, vehicular manslaughter (recklessness causing death).
Step 2 — Malice escalation: Prior convictions + warnings + wrong-way at high speed show extreme indifference to human life.
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Concept | Rule |
|---|---|
| Per se limit (adult) | BAC \( \geq 0.08 \) |
| Commercial driver | BAC \( \geq 0.04 \) |
| Under 21 | Zero tolerance \( 0.01\text{–}0.02 \) |
| Mental state | General intent / strict liability |
| Control | Operation or actual physical control |
| Causing death | Manslaughter (or murder if malice) |
Question 1 of 5
An adult driver registers a BAC of \( 0.08 \). Under the per se theory, this is:
Question 2 of 5
An intoxicated person sleeps in the driver's seat, engine running, keys in the ignition. The best basis for a DUI conviction is:
Question 3 of 5
An impaired driver recklessly causes a crash that seriously injures a cyclist (no death). The most fitting charge is:
Question 4 of 5
A driver with two prior DUI convictions, having been warned of the danger, drives the wrong way at high speed while drunk and kills someone. This best supports:
Question 5 of 5
Regarding chemical testing after a lawful DUI arrest, which statement is most accurate?