01 / 19

DUI Offenses
& Vehicular Crimes

Master the elements, defenses, and grading of driving under the influence and related vehicular offenses tested on the bar.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a DUI?

A DUI (driving under the influence), sometimes labeled DWI or OUI, criminalizes operating a vehicle while impaired by alcohol or drugs. Most jurisdictions punish it through two distinct theories:

Impairment Theory
The driver's faculties were actually impaired by alcohol or drugs to a measurable degree.
Per Se Theory
The driver's blood alcohol concentration met or exceeded the legal limit, regardless of actual impairment.

The Per Se Threshold

Under the per se theory, guilt turns on a single number. The standard legal limit for an ordinary adult driver is:

Per Se Limit Legal range Per se violation
\( 0.00 \)
\( 0.16+ \)
\( 0.08 \)

The Core Elements

1
Operation or control. The defendant operated, drove, or was in actual physical control of a vehicle.
2
On a covered roadway. Many statutes require a public road or place of public access (this varies by jurisdiction).
3
Under the influence OR per se. Either actual impairment of faculties or BAC \( \geq 0.08 \).

"Actual Physical Control"

A defendant need not be driving to be convicted. Many states impose liability where the impaired person could readily set the vehicle in motion. Courts weigh totality-of-the-circumstances factors:

Location of keys
Keys in the ignition or within easy reach weigh toward control.
Engine status
A running engine (even for heat) strongly suggests control.
Seat position
Sitting behind the wheel weighs against a "sleeping it off" defense.

Distinguishing Vehicular Crimes

Offense Mental State Result Required
DUI (simple)General / strictNone — driving impaired is enough
Vehicular assaultRecklessnessSerious bodily injury
Vehicular manslaughterRecklessness or gross negligenceDeath
DUI murder (depraved heart)Extreme recklessnessDeath + prior knowledge of danger

When DUI Becomes Murder

A drunk-driving death is usually manslaughter. But it can rise to second-degree (depraved-heart) murder when the driver acted with an extreme indifference to human life.

DUI no harm Manslaughter recklessness + death Murder depraved heart

Implied Consent & Testing

By driving on public roads, motorists are deemed to have impliedly consented to chemical testing (breath, blood, or urine) if lawfully arrested for DUI.

Breath test
Generally permitted incident to a lawful DUI arrest without a warrant.
Blood test
More intrusive — usually requires a warrant or valid consent absent exigency.

How to Analyze a DUI Question

1
Operation/control? Identify whether the defendant drove or was in actual physical control.
2
Theory of liability. Is there evidence of actual impairment, a per se BAC \( \geq 0.08 \), or both?
3
Resulting harm? If injury or death occurred, escalate to vehicular assault, manslaughter, or murder.
4
Procedural defenses. Check the stop, the arrest, and the validity of any chemical test.

Worked Example 1

Step 1 — Control: Engine running + keys in ignition + driver's seat ⟶ actual physical control is satisfied.

Step 2 — Theory: BAC of \( 0.11 \geq 0.08 \) establishes a per se violation; no proof of swerving needed.

Worked Example 2

Step 1 — Base offense: BAC \( \geq 0.08 \) = simple DUI is established.

Step 2 — Harm: Serious bodily injury occurred, and impaired red-light running supports recklessness.

Worked Example 3

Step 1 — Death + impairment: At minimum, vehicular manslaughter (recklessness causing death).

Step 2 — Malice escalation: Prior convictions + warnings + wrong-way at high speed show extreme indifference to human life.

Common Mistakes

✕ Requiring intent
DUI is general intent or strict liability — the prosecution need not prove the driver meant to get drunk.
✕ Demanding actual driving
"Actual physical control" is enough; a sleeping driver with keys and a running engine can be guilty.
✕ Confusing harm levels
Injury ⟶ assault; death ⟶ manslaughter; extreme indifference ⟶ murder. Match the result to the grade.

Quick Reference

Concept Rule
Per se limit (adult)BAC \( \geq 0.08 \)
Commercial driverBAC \( \geq 0.04 \)
Under 21Zero tolerance \( 0.01\text{–}0.02 \)
Mental stateGeneral intent / strict liability
ControlOperation or actual physical control
Causing deathManslaughter (or murder if malice)

Question 1 of 5

An adult driver registers a BAC of \( 0.08 \). Under the per se theory, this is:

Question 2 of 5

An intoxicated person sleeps in the driver's seat, engine running, keys in the ignition. The best basis for a DUI conviction is:

Question 3 of 5

An impaired driver recklessly causes a crash that seriously injures a cyclist (no death). The most fitting charge is:

Question 4 of 5

A driver with two prior DUI convictions, having been warned of the danger, drives the wrong way at high speed while drunk and kills someone. This best supports:

Question 5 of 5

Regarding chemical testing after a lawful DUI arrest, which statement is most accurate?