Discovery Tools
Choosing the Right Method
Master the five core discovery devices under the Federal Rules and learn to select the appropriate tool for each evidentiary goal.
What Is Discovery?
Discovery is the pretrial process by which parties obtain evidence from each other and from third parties. Its purpose is to prevent surprise at trial, narrow the issues, and promote fair settlement.
The Five Core Discovery Tools
Parties vs. Non-Parties
The Core Rule: Scope of Discovery
Relevance for discovery is broader than relevance for admissibility. Information need not be admissible at trial to be discoverable — it need only be reasonably calculated to lead to admissible evidence.
The Proportionality Factors
Courts weigh several factors to decide whether a request is proportional. Conceptually, proportionality compares the value of the discovery against its burden:
Depositions vs. Interrogatories
| Deposition | Interrogatory | |
|---|---|---|
| Who may answer | Parties & non-parties | Parties only |
| Form | Live oral testimony | Written questions |
| Follow-up | Spontaneous follow-ups | No live follow-ups |
| Cost | High (court reporter) | Low |
| Best for | Probing, observing demeanor | Background facts, identities |
Default Numerical Limits
The Federal Rules cap certain tools absent stipulation or court order. Memorize these defaults:
How to Select a Tool
Example 1: Naming Witnesses
Scenario: Plaintiff's lawyer needs to learn the names and addresses of every employee the opposing party believes witnessed the workplace accident.
Example 2: Records From a Bank
Scenario: Defendant needs financial records held by a non-party bank to trace fraudulent transfers.
Example 3: Injury in Controversy
Scenario: Plaintiff claims permanent back injury. Defendant wants an independent physician to verify the extent of the disability.
Common Mistakes
Tool Selection Summary
| Tool | Reaches | Best Goal |
|---|---|---|
| Deposition (30) | Parties & non-parties | Probe key witness |
| Interrogatory (33) | Parties only | Cheap factual basics |
| Production (34) | Parties (45 for others) | Documents/things |
| Exam (35) | Parties (court order) | Condition in controversy |
| Admission (36) | Parties only | Lock in / narrow facts |
Check Your Understanding
You will now answer five multiple-choice questions. For each fact pattern, identify the most appropriate discovery tool using the rules you just learned.
Question 1 of 5
An attorney wants a sworn written list of all insurance policies held by the opposing party. Which tool is most efficient?
Question 2 of 5
A party needs documents held by a non-party hospital. Which device is required?
Question 3 of 5
A plaintiff alleges a disabling knee injury. The defendant wants a doctor to verify it. What must the defendant do?
Question 4 of 5
An attorney wants to lock in the opponent's concession that a contract was signed on a certain date to narrow trial issues. Best tool?
Question 5 of 5
Absent court order or stipulation, what is the default maximum number of interrogatories a party may serve?