01 / 20

Discovery Scope
Civil Procedure

Learn to determine what information is discoverable under the relevance and proportionality standard.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Discovery?

Discovery is the pre-trial phase where parties exchange information about the claims and defenses in a lawsuit. It lets each side learn the facts before trial, narrow the issues, and avoid surprise.

The Two-Part Standard

Relevant to a claim or defense Proportional to the needs of the case + Within Scope = Discoverable

Prong 1: Relevance

Information is relevant if it relates to any party's claim or defense. The standard is broad and does not require admissibility at trial.

Prong 2: Proportionality

1
Importance of issues at stake in the action.
2
Amount in controversy relative to the request.
3
Parties' relative access to relevant information.
4
Parties' resources available to produce.
5
Importance of discovery in resolving the issues.
6
Burden or expense vs. likely benefit.

The Core Rule

We can express the test as a logical conjunction. Discoverability \( D \) holds only when all three conditions are true:

$$ D = (\text{Nonprivileged}) \land (\text{Relevant}) \land (\text{Proportional}) $$

The Privilege Filter

Even relevant, proportional information is off-limits if privileged. The most common privileges and protections include:

Attorney-Client
Confidential communications for legal advice.
Work Product
Materials prepared in anticipation of litigation.
Other Privileges
Spousal, doctor-patient, Fifth Amendment, etc.

Relevant vs. Admissible

Students often confuse the discovery standard with the trial standard. These are two different bars.

Discovery (Relevant)Trial (Admissible)
StandardBroadStrict
Hearsay barred?NoYes
Governed byFRCP 26(b)Rules of Evidence
PhasePre-trialAt trial

How to Apply the Test

1
Identify the request. What exactly is being sought?
2
Check relevance. Does it relate to a claim or defense?
3
Weigh proportionality. Apply the six factors.
4
Screen for privilege. Is the material protected?
5
Conclude. Discoverable only if all checks pass.

Example 1: Basic Relevance

In a car-accident negligence suit, plaintiff requests the defendant's cell phone records from the time of the crash.

Example 2: Proportionality Limit

In a $5,000 small contract dispute, plaintiff demands ten years of the defendant company's emails from every department.

Example 3: Privilege Bar

Defendant seeks copies of emails between the plaintiff and her attorney discussing trial strategy.

Common Mistakes

✕ Requiring Admissibility
Relevant info is discoverable even if it would be inadmissible at trial.
✕ Ignoring Proportionality
Relevance alone is not enough since 2015. Both prongs are required.
✕ Forgetting Privilege
Relevant, proportional material is still barred if privileged.

Scope Summary

ElementTestResult if Fails
RelevanceRelates to claim/defenseNot discoverable
ProportionalitySix-factor balanceLimited or denied
PrivilegeProtected material?Barred entirely
AdmissibilityNot requiredIrrelevant here

Question 1 of 5

Under FRCP 26(b)(1), discoverable information must be relevant and what else?

Question 2 of 5

A party requests relevant documents that would be inadmissible hearsay at trial. Are they discoverable?

Question 3 of 5

Which of the following is NOT a proportionality factor under Rule 26(b)(1)?

Question 4 of 5

In a $4,000 dispute, a party demands every email a large company sent over 15 years. The likely ruling is that the request:

Question 5 of 5

Emails between a party and her lawyer about case strategy are relevant and proportional. Are they discoverable?

You've Mastered Discovery Scope

$$ D = (\text{Nonprivileged}) \land (\text{Relevant}) \land (\text{Proportional}) $$