01 / 20

Discovery
Drafting

Draft and revise discovery documents that are consistent with the facts, the governing rules, and the client's goals.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Discovery?

Discovery is the pre-trial phase where each party gathers facts, documents, and testimony from the other side. The goal is to eliminate surprise at trial and to let both sides evaluate the strength of their claims.

The Main Discovery Devices

Interrogatories
Written questions answered under oath by a party.
Requests for Production
Demands to produce documents and tangible things.
Requests for Admission
Statements the other party must admit or deny.
Depositions
Oral testimony recorded under oath, often by notice.

Why Good Drafting Matters

Facts + Client Goals Drafted Request Admissible Evidence Drafting is the bridge from what you know to what you can prove

The Governing Rule: Scope

Under the federal standard (FRCP 26(b)(1)), parties may obtain discovery regarding any nonprivileged matter that is relevant to a claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case.

1
Relevant. Tied to a claim or defense actually pleaded.
2
Nonprivileged. Not attorney-client, work product, or otherwise protected.
3
Proportional. Weighing importance, amount in controversy, burden, and access.

Weighing Proportionality

A request is proportional when the value of the information outweighs the burden of producing it. Conceptually:

When the ratio drops below \( 1 \), a court may limit or deny the request. A well-drafted request keeps the numerator high (clearly relevant) and the denominator low (narrowly tailored).

Requests vs. Responses

Drafting a Request Drafting a Response
GoalObtain specific factsAnswer or limit exposure
FocusPrecision & relevanceAccuracy & valid objections
Risk if vagueObjection & no answerWaiver of objection
Key dutyReasonable scopeTruthful, complete, timely

How to Draft Step by Step

1
Map to the elements. Identify each fact you must prove for every claim or defense.
2
Define terms. Specify "document," "you," and the relevant time period to avoid ambiguity.
3
Narrow the scope. Tie each request to a date range, custodian, or subject matter.
4
Check the rules. Confirm numerical limits and required formalities are met.
5
Align with client goals. Avoid requests that invite costly reciprocal demands.

Example 1: Narrowing a Request

The revision adds custodians, a subject, and a date range — keeping the request relevant and proportional.

Example 2: Responding Properly

Opposing counsel asks: "Identify every communication you ever had about the project." Your client only has communications from 2023.

Example 3: Privilege & Logging

Responsive Produce it Privileged Withhold + log Privilege Log Describe without revealing content

Common Mistakes

✕ Overbroad Requests
"All documents" with no limits invites objection and yields nothing.
✕ Boilerplate Objections
Generic "overbroad and burdensome" without specifics can be deemed waived.
✕ Missing Deadlines
Late responses can waive objections and trigger sanctions.
✕ No Privilege Log
Withholding without a log risks waiving the privilege entirely.

Summary Checklist

Good Practice Avoid
ScopeTied to claims/defenses"All documents"
TermsDefined preciselyAmbiguous language
ObjectionsSpecific & explainedBoilerplate only
TimingWithin the rulesMissed deadlines
PrivilegeLog withheld itemsSilent withholding

Question 1 of 5

Which discovery request is most likely to survive an objection?

Question 2 of 5

Under FRCP 26(b)(1), discovery must be relevant, nonprivileged, and:

Question 3 of 5

A client has only 2023 communications. The request asks for "every communication ever." The best response is to:

Question 4 of 5

When a party withholds a privileged document, the rules generally require the party to:

Question 5 of 5

Filing discovery responses late can most directly cause a party to:

Key Takeaways

1
Tie everything to claims. Map each request to a fact you must prove.
2
Stay proportional. Keep relevance high and burden low.
3
Object then answer. Preserve objections, but still respond in good faith.
4
Log privileged items. Never withhold silently.

You're Ready to Draft

Precise, proportional, rule-compliant, and aligned with your client's goals — that's the formula for effective discovery drafting.