Discovery
Disputes
How courts resolve objections to discovery requests under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
What Is Discovery?
Discovery is the pretrial process where parties exchange information about the case. The goal is to prevent "trial by surprise" and let each side build its case from the facts.
The Tools of Discovery
When a Dispute Arises
A dispute arises when the responding party objects to a request. The objecting party must state the objection with specificity, and the requesting party may move to compel.
The Core Rule: Scope Under 26(b)(1)
The Privilege Exception
Even relevant, proportional matter is not discoverable if it is privileged or protected work product.
Key Distinction: Relevance vs. Proportionality
| Relevance | Proportionality | |
|---|---|---|
| Question | Does it relate to a claim/defense? | Is the burden worth the benefit? |
| Focus | Subject matter | Cost, scope, importance |
| Burden | Requesting party shows relevance | Objecting party shows disproportion |
| Result if fails | Irrelevant — not discoverable | Overbroad — narrowed or denied |
How to Resolve an Objection
Worked Example: Overbroad Request
Facts: In a slip-and-fall suit at one store, plaintiff requests "all incident reports from every store nationwide for 10 years." Defendant objects.
Worked Example: Privilege Claim
Facts: Plaintiff requests emails between defendant and its attorney discussing legal strategy. Defendant withholds them and logs them.
Worked Example: Work Product
Facts: Plaintiff requests a witness statement that defense counsel obtained while preparing for litigation. Plaintiff cannot get the witness now.
Common Mistakes
Objection Summary Table
| Objection | Test | Likely Result |
|---|---|---|
| Irrelevant | No tie to claim/defense | Denied |
| Overbroad | Disproportional burden | Narrowed |
| Privileged | Attorney-client comm. | Protected |
| Work product | Prepared for litigation | Protected (unless need) |
Quick Recap
Question 1 of 5
Under FRCP 26(b)(1), discoverable matter must be nonprivileged, relevant, and:
Question 2 of 5
A defendant withholds privileged emails but produces no privilege log. What is the most likely consequence?
Question 3 of 5
In a $50,000 contract dispute over one transaction, the plaintiff demands every internal email the defendant company sent during the past 15 years, across all departments.
The defendant objects, arguing the request is far too broad given the modest stakes and limited issues.
The court will most likely:
Question 4 of 5
Ordinary work product (e.g., a witness statement) may still be discovered when the requesting party shows:
Question 5 of 5
Before filing a motion to compel discovery, the moving party must:
You've Got the Framework
Identify the objection, test scope and protections, confer in good faith, then let the court compel, narrow, or protect.