01 / 20

Disclosure
Obligations

How the prosecution must turn over favorable evidence to the defense under the Brady rule.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Disclosure Obligation?

In a criminal case, the prosecution holds enormous power and resources. To keep trials fair, the Constitution imposes a duty on prosecutors to share certain evidence with the defense.

Three Key Terms

Exculpatory
Evidence that tends to clear the defendant or reduce guilt.
Impeachment
Evidence undermining the credibility of a prosecution witness.
Material
Evidence likely to change the trial's outcome if disclosed.

Why It Matters

Hidden evidence can convict an innocent person. The Brady rule protects the defendant's right to due process under the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.

Prosecution holds evidence Defense receives evidence disclose Fair Trial Due Process

The Brady Rule

The rule has three elements, all of which must be met for a Brady violation to exist.

The Three Elements of a Brady Violation

1
Favorable. The evidence is exculpatory or useful for impeachment.
2
Suppressed. The evidence was withheld by the state, willfully or inadvertently.
3
Material. Prejudice resulted: there is a reasonable probability the outcome would have been different.

Brady vs. Giglio

Brady Material
Directly exculpatory evidence pointing toward innocence or a lesser sentence.
Giglio Material
A subset of Brady: impeachment evidence, like a witness's plea deal or prior lies.

How to Apply the Brady Rule

1
Identify the evidence. Is it favorable: exculpatory or impeachment?
2
Check suppression. Did the state fail to disclose it, intentionally or not?
3
Test materiality. Is there a reasonable probability the result would differ?
4
Conclude. If all three hold, a Brady violation has occurred.

Worked Example: The Hidden Witness

A prosecutor learns of an eyewitness who told police the defendant was not the shooter. The prosecutor never tells the defense, and the defendant is convicted.

Worked Example: The Plea Deal

The key prosecution witness received a secret deal for reduced charges in exchange for testimony. The defense is never told. The jury convicts based largely on that testimony.

Worked Example: No Violation

The prosecution forgot to disclose a minor lab report. However, five other witnesses and a confession independently prove guilt beyond any doubt.

The Materiality Threshold

Materiality is measured by a reasonable probability standard, not certainty. Express it as: \( P(\text{different outcome}) \geq \text{reasonable probability} \).

No effect Certain Threshold Material zone Not material

Common Mistakes

✕ Bad Faith Required
Brady applies even when suppression was accidental. Intent does not matter.
✕ Must Be Requested
Disclosure is owed even if the defense never asks for the evidence.
✕ Ignoring Materiality
Not every withheld item is a violation. The evidence must be material.

Summary Table

Brady Giglio
Type of evidenceExculpatoryImpeachment
RelationshipGeneral ruleSubset of Brady
Good faith excuse?NoNo
Request required?NoNo
Must be material?YesYes

Quick Recap

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is NOT one of the three elements of a Brady violation?

Question 2 of 5

A witness's secret plea deal withheld from the defense is best categorized as which type of evidence?

Question 3 of 5

The materiality standard requires a reasonable probability that the result would differ. This means the defense must show:

Question 4 of 5

Has a Brady violation likely occurred?

Question 5 of 5

A prosecutor withholds a trivial document, but overwhelming independent evidence still proves guilt. Why is there no Brady violation?