Defeasible
Estates
Present estates that can be cut short or terminated upon the happening of a stated event. Learn to distinguish the three core types and their matching future interests.
What Is a Defeasible Estate?
A fee simple absolute is the largest estate the law recognizes: ownership that lasts forever with no strings attached. A defeasible estate is also potentially infinite, but it carries a condition. If the stated event happens, the estate may end and ownership shifts to someone else.
The Three Defeasible Estates
How an Estate Shifts
Fee Simple Determinable
Durational language signals a determinable estate: "so long as," "while," "during," "until." The estate ends automatically the instant the condition occurs.
Subject to Condition Subsequent
Conditional language plus a reentry clause signals this estate: "but if," "provided that," "on condition that," "however." The estate does not end automatically: the grantor must affirmatively act to retake.
Subject to Executory Limitation
Here the condition cuts the estate short and ownership passes automatically to a third party, not back to the grantor. The third party's interest is an executory interest.
Key Distinction: Automatic vs. Optional
| Determinable | Condition Subsequent | Executory Limitation | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ends how? | Automatically | Grantor must reenter | Automatically |
| Who takes? | Grantor | Grantor | Third party |
| Future interest | Poss. of reverter | Right of reentry | Executory interest |
| Key words | so long as, until | but if, provided | but if ... then to |
How to Apply It
When the Language Is Ambiguous
Courts disfavor forfeiture. When grant language is unclear between determinable and condition subsequent, the modern preference is to construe it as a fee simple subject to condition subsequent, because it does not cut off the estate automatically.
Worked Example 1
Grant: "O to A and her heirs so long as the premises are used as a library."
Worked Example 2
Grant: "O to A and his heirs, but if alcohol is ever served, O may reenter and retake."
Worked Example 3
Grant: "O to A and her heirs, but if A ever sells liquor, then to B and his heirs."
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference Summary
| Present Estate | Trigger Words | Future Interest |
|---|---|---|
| Fee simple determinable | so long as, while, until | Possibility of reverter |
| Subject to condition subsequent | but if, provided + reentry | Right of reentry |
| Subject to executory limitation | but if ... then to B | Executory interest |
Question 1 of 5
"O to A and her heirs so long as the land is used for farming." What estate does A hold?
Question 2 of 5
A fee simple subject to condition subsequent is followed by which future interest?
Question 3 of 5
"O to A, but if A stops residing on the land, then to B." Which describes A's estate?
Question 4 of 5
Which feature is unique to a fee simple determinable compared to a fee simple subject to condition subsequent?
Question 5 of 5
When the grant language is ambiguous between determinable and condition subsequent, modern courts prefer to construe it as which estate, and why?