01 / 20

Defeasible
Estates

Present estates that can be cut short or terminated upon the happening of a stated event. Learn to distinguish the three core types and their matching future interests.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Defeasible Estate?

A fee simple absolute is the largest estate the law recognizes: ownership that lasts forever with no strings attached. A defeasible estate is also potentially infinite, but it carries a condition. If the stated event happens, the estate may end and ownership shifts to someone else.

The Three Defeasible Estates

Fee Simple Determinable
Ends automatically when the condition occurs. Durational language.
Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent
Grantor may reenter and end it. Conditional language.
Fee Simple Subject to Executory Limitation
Ends automatically and passes to a third party.

How an Estate Shifts

Present Estate Grantee holds now condition occurs Future Interest Grantor or 3rd party The condition is the trigger Who takes next depends on the estate type

Fee Simple Determinable

Durational language signals a determinable estate: "so long as," "while," "during," "until." The estate ends automatically the instant the condition occurs.

Subject to Condition Subsequent

Conditional language plus a reentry clause signals this estate: "but if," "provided that," "on condition that," "however." The estate does not end automatically: the grantor must affirmatively act to retake.

Subject to Executory Limitation

Here the condition cuts the estate short and ownership passes automatically to a third party, not back to the grantor. The third party's interest is an executory interest.

Key Distinction: Automatic vs. Optional

Determinable Condition Subsequent Executory Limitation
Ends how? Automatically Grantor must reenter Automatically
Who takes? Grantor Grantor Third party
Future interest Poss. of reverter Right of reentry Executory interest
Key words so long as, until but if, provided but if ... then to

How to Apply It

1
Find the condition. Identify the event that could cut the estate short.
2
Read the language. Durational words mean determinable; conditional words mean condition subsequent.
3
Ask who takes. If a named third party takes, it is subject to an executory limitation.
4
Name both interests. The present estate AND its matching future interest.

When the Language Is Ambiguous

Courts disfavor forfeiture. When grant language is unclear between determinable and condition subsequent, the modern preference is to construe it as a fee simple subject to condition subsequent, because it does not cut off the estate automatically.

Worked Example 1

Grant: "O to A and her heirs so long as the premises are used as a library."

Worked Example 2

Grant: "O to A and his heirs, but if alcohol is ever served, O may reenter and retake."

Worked Example 3

Grant: "O to A and her heirs, but if A ever sells liquor, then to B and his heirs."

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the triggers
"So long as" is automatic; "but if" requires reentry. Mixing them up swaps the entire estate type.
✕ Wrong future interest
Reverter follows determinable; right of reentry follows condition subsequent. Pair them correctly.
✕ Missing the third party
If interest goes to someone other than the grantor, it is an executory limitation, not a reverter.

Quick Reference Summary

Present Estate Trigger Words Future Interest
Fee simple determinable so long as, while, until Possibility of reverter
Subject to condition subsequent but if, provided + reentry Right of reentry
Subject to executory limitation but if ... then to B Executory interest

Question 1 of 5

"O to A and her heirs so long as the land is used for farming." What estate does A hold?

Question 2 of 5

A fee simple subject to condition subsequent is followed by which future interest?

Question 3 of 5

"O to A, but if A stops residing on the land, then to B." Which describes A's estate?

Question 4 of 5

Which feature is unique to a fee simple determinable compared to a fee simple subject to condition subsequent?

Question 5 of 5

When the grant language is ambiguous between determinable and condition subsequent, modern courts prefer to construe it as which estate, and why?