01 / 20

Defamation
Libel & Slander

Master the elements of defamation, the role of fault and truth, and how the rules shift for public versus private plaintiffs.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Defamation?

Defamation is a tort that protects a person's reputation. It occurs when one person communicates a false statement of fact about another that injures the second person's reputation in the eyes of the community.

Two Forms of Defamation

Libel
Defamation in a permanent or written form — print, video, recordings. Damages are generally presumed.
Slander
Defamation in a spoken or transitory form. Plaintiff must usually prove special damages unless slander per se applies.

Why It Matters

Defamation sits at the intersection of tort law and the First Amendment. Courts balance an individual's interest in reputation against society's interest in free and open speech.

The Prima Facie Elements

1
Defamatory language — a statement tending to harm reputation.
2
Of or concerning the plaintiff — a reasonable person would understand it refers to the plaintiff.
3
Publication — communicated to at least one third person.
4
Damages — harm to reputation (presumed in libel and slander per se).

Constitutional Add-Ons

When the statement involves a matter of public concern, the plaintiff must additionally prove two constitutional elements:

Common-Law Elements Defamatory · Of/Concerning · Publication · Damages Falsity Plaintiff proves the statement is false Fault Negligence or actual malice Required only for matters of public concern

The Actual Malice Standard

For public officials and public figures, New York Times v. Sullivan requires proof of actual malice: that the defendant made the statement with

Public vs. Private Plaintiffs

Public Figure / Official Private Figure
Fault requiredActual maliceAt least negligence
Presumed damagesOnly with actual maliceOnly with actual malice
Punitive damagesOnly with actual maliceOnly with actual malice
Standard originNYT v. SullivanGertz v. Welch

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the form. Is it libel (written/permanent) or slander (spoken)?
2
Run the four common-law elements — defamatory, of/concerning, publication, damages.
3
Ask if the matter is of public concern. If yes, add falsity and fault.
4
Classify the plaintiff. Public figure → actual malice; private → negligence.
5
Consider defenses. Truth, consent, and absolute or qualified privilege.

Worked Example One

A newspaper prints a false article stating that a local restaurant owner (a private figure) failed a health inspection. Diners stop coming and the owner loses business. The paper was careless in checking the facts.

Worked Example Two

A blogger writes that a sitting U.S. Senator took a bribe. The statement is false, but the blogger genuinely believed a source and had no reason to doubt it. The Senator sues.

Worked Example Three

During a courtroom trial, a witness testifies — truthfully or not — that the defendant embezzled funds. The defendant later sues the witness for defamation based on that testimony.

Common Mistakes

✕ Malice = Ill Will
Actual malice is about knowledge/reckless disregard of falsity — not spite or hatred.
✕ Skipping Publication
Telling the statement only to the plaintiff is not publication. A third person must hear it.
✕ Opinion Confusion
Pure opinion that implies no false facts is not actionable — only false statements of fact.

Defenses Summary

Defense Effect
TruthComplete defense at common law
ConsentPlaintiff agreed to publication
Absolute privilegeJudicial, legislative, spousal — cannot be lost
Qualified privilegeLost if abused or made with malice

Question 1 of 5

Which element requires the defamatory statement to be communicated to at least one third person?

Question 2 of 5

A public official sues for defamation over a false statement of public concern. What fault must the official prove?

Question 3 of 5

Which of the following is generally considered slander per se, requiring no proof of special damages?

Question 4 of 5

Can the owner recover actual damages?

Question 5 of 5

A witness gives false testimony during a trial. The defamation claim against the witness will most likely be:

Key Takeaways

1
Four common-law elements: defamatory language, of/concerning the plaintiff, publication, and damages.
2
Public-concern matters add falsity and fault to the plaintiff's case.
3
Public figures need actual malice; private figures need at least negligence.
4
Defenses: truth, consent, and absolute or qualified privilege.