Damages Limitations
How the law caps and trims a plaintiff's recovery: foreseeability, certainty, mitigation, and the rules that keep damages within fair bounds.
What Are Damages?
Damages are the money awarded to make an injured party whole. In contract law, the goal is to put the plaintiff in the position they would have been in had the contract been performed (the expectation interest).
Why Limits Exist
Limitations exist to keep awards fair and predictable. They protect defendants from speculative, surprise, or self-inflicted losses while ensuring plaintiffs recover their genuine, provable harm.
The Four Core Limits
The Foreseeability Rule
Under Hadley v. Baxendale, recoverable damages are limited to those that:
The Recovery Formula
Where \( L_{loss} \) is the direct loss in value, \( I_{incidental} \) and \( C_{consequential} \) are added (if foreseeable), and we subtract avoidable losses \( M_{avoidable} \) plus any costs saved \( S_{saved} \) by not performing.
General vs. Consequential
How to Apply the Limits
Example 1: Mitigation
A landlord's tenant breaches a 12-month lease at $2,000/month after month 4. The landlord re-rents the unit two months later for the same rent.
Example 2: Foreseeability
Example 3: Certainty
A brand-new restaurant sues a supplier for breach, claiming $200,000 in lost profits. It has no operating history and cannot prove any past earnings.
Common Mistakes
Limitation Summary
| What it Tests | Effect | |
|---|---|---|
| Foreseeability | Contemplated at formation? | Bars unforeseen losses |
| Certainty | Provable amount? | Bars speculative losses |
| Causation | Breach caused loss? | Bars remote losses |
| Mitigation | Avoidable harm? | Reduces recovery |
Check Your Understanding
The next five questions test your ability to apply each damage limitation to a fact pattern. Read each set of facts carefully and choose the best answer.
Question 1 of 5
Which case established that recoverable damages are limited to those foreseeable at the time of contracting?
Question 2 of 5
A breaching buyer leaves a seller with goods. The seller resells them and earns a profit. What does the duty to mitigate require?
Question 3 of 5
A brand-new business sues for $500,000 in lost profits but has no track record. Which limitation most likely bars this claim?
Question 4 of 5
A landlord re-rents after a tenant breaches a lease, with 6 vacant months at $1,500/month before re-rental. What is the recoverable amount, applying mitigation?
Question 5 of 5
Lost profits that flow indirectly from a breach and require notice of special circumstances at formation are best classified as: