01 / 20

Damage
Limitations

Apply the three great limits on contract damages: mitigation, foreseeability, and certainty.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Why Damages Are Capped

Contract law aims to put the injured party in the position they would have occupied had the contract been performed. But the law does not let a plaintiff recover everything they claim.

The Three Limiting Doctrines

Mitigation
The non-breaching party cannot recover losses they could have reasonably avoided.
Foreseeability
Damages must have been foreseeable at the time the contract was formed.
Certainty
Damages must be proven with reasonable certainty, not speculation.

Filtering the Claim

Claimed Losses Mitigation avoidable? cut Foreseeable? at formation Certain? provable Recoverable Damages

The Mitigation Rule

Recoverable damages equal total losses minus losses the plaintiff could reasonably have avoided:

$$ D_{\text{recoverable}} = L_{\text{total}} - L_{\text{avoidable}} $$

The Foreseeability Rule

Under Hadley v. Baxendale, damages are recoverable only if they were foreseeable at the time of contracting. Two categories qualify:

1
General (direct) damages: losses arising naturally from the breach in the ordinary course.
2
Special (consequential) damages: recoverable only if the breaching party had reason to know of the special circumstances.

The Certainty Rule

This doctrine most often defeats claims for lost profits of new businesses, where there is no track record to estimate profit:

$$ \text{Profit} = \text{Revenue} - \text{Costs} \;\Rightarrow\; \text{must be provable} $$

General vs. Special Damages

GeneralSpecial
Also calledDirectConsequential
Arise fromOrdinary courseSpecial circumstances
Foreseeable becauseNaturally flowDefendant knew or had reason to know
Notice neededNoYes

How to Analyze a Claim

1
Identify the loss claimed and tie it to the breach (causation).
2
Mitigation: ask whether reasonable steps could have reduced the loss. Subtract avoidable losses.
3
Foreseeability: was the loss foreseeable at formation? If special, did the defendant have notice?
4
Certainty: can the amount be proven without speculation?

Example 1: Mitigation

An employer breaches an employment contract and fires Worker (annual salary $60,000). Worker could have found a comparable job paying $45,000 but refused to look.

$$ D = \$60{,}000 - \$45{,}000 = \$15{,}000 $$

Example 2: Foreseeability

A courier delays delivering a mill's broken shaft. Because of the delay, the mill stays shut and loses $2,000 in profits. The courier was never told the mill could not operate without the shaft.

Example 3: Certainty

A landlord breaches a lease for a space where Owner planned to open a brand-new restaurant. Owner sues for $500,000 in projected first-year profits.

Common Mistakes

✕ Treating mitigation as a duty
There is no affirmative duty — losses that could have been avoided are simply not recoverable.
✕ Wrong foreseeability time
Foreseeability is judged at contract formation, not at the time of breach.
✕ Confusing certainty with foreseeability
Certainty is about proving the amount; foreseeability is about the type of loss.

Summary Table

DoctrineAsksEffect
MitigationCould the loss be reasonably avoided?Subtract avoidable losses
ForeseeabilityWas the loss foreseeable at formation?Bar unforeseeable special losses
CertaintyCan the amount be proven?Bar speculative losses

Question 1 of 5

An employee is wrongfully fired (salary $50,000) but unreasonably refuses a comparable $40,000 job. What can the employee recover?

Question 2 of 5

When is foreseeability of damages measured?

Question 3 of 5

A new business sues for $1 million in projected lost profits with no operating history. Which doctrine most likely bars recovery?

Question 4 of 5

Special (consequential) damages are recoverable only if the breaching party:

Question 5 of 5

What is the factory's likely recovery?

Putting It Together

Mitigate
Subtract losses that could reasonably have been avoided.
Foresee
Loss must be foreseeable at formation; special losses need notice.
Prove
Amount must be shown with reasonable certainty.