Damage
Limitations
Apply the three great limits on contract damages: mitigation, foreseeability, and certainty.
Why Damages Are Capped
Contract law aims to put the injured party in the position they would have occupied had the contract been performed. But the law does not let a plaintiff recover everything they claim.
The Three Limiting Doctrines
Filtering the Claim
The Mitigation Rule
Recoverable damages equal total losses minus losses the plaintiff could reasonably have avoided:
$$ D_{\text{recoverable}} = L_{\text{total}} - L_{\text{avoidable}} $$The Foreseeability Rule
Under Hadley v. Baxendale, damages are recoverable only if they were foreseeable at the time of contracting. Two categories qualify:
The Certainty Rule
This doctrine most often defeats claims for lost profits of new businesses, where there is no track record to estimate profit:
$$ \text{Profit} = \text{Revenue} - \text{Costs} \;\Rightarrow\; \text{must be provable} $$General vs. Special Damages
| General | Special | |
|---|---|---|
| Also called | Direct | Consequential |
| Arise from | Ordinary course | Special circumstances |
| Foreseeable because | Naturally flow | Defendant knew or had reason to know |
| Notice needed | No | Yes |
How to Analyze a Claim
Example 1: Mitigation
An employer breaches an employment contract and fires Worker (annual salary $60,000). Worker could have found a comparable job paying $45,000 but refused to look.
$$ D = \$60{,}000 - \$45{,}000 = \$15{,}000 $$Example 2: Foreseeability
A courier delays delivering a mill's broken shaft. Because of the delay, the mill stays shut and loses $2,000 in profits. The courier was never told the mill could not operate without the shaft.
Example 3: Certainty
A landlord breaches a lease for a space where Owner planned to open a brand-new restaurant. Owner sues for $500,000 in projected first-year profits.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Doctrine | Asks | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Mitigation | Could the loss be reasonably avoided? | Subtract avoidable losses |
| Foreseeability | Was the loss foreseeable at formation? | Bar unforeseeable special losses |
| Certainty | Can the amount be proven? | Bar speculative losses |
Question 1 of 5
An employee is wrongfully fired (salary $50,000) but unreasonably refuses a comparable $40,000 job. What can the employee recover?
Question 2 of 5
When is foreseeability of damages measured?
Question 3 of 5
A new business sues for $1 million in projected lost profits with no operating history. Which doctrine most likely bars recovery?
Question 4 of 5
Special (consequential) damages are recoverable only if the breaching party:
Question 5 of 5
Facts: A supplier promises to deliver a custom engine part by Friday for a factory. The supplier knows the factory's entire production line halts without the part. The supplier delivers two weeks late. The factory loses $80,000 in profits. The factory could have rented a temporary substitute part for $5,000 but chose not to.
What is the factory's likely recovery?