Cotenant Rights
Shared Ownership of Land
When two or more people own the same property at once, the law gives each a set of rights and duties. Learn to analyze how cotenants share, use, profit from, and account for jointly held land.
What Is a Cotenancy?
A cotenancy exists when two or more people hold concurrent ownership of the same property. Each owner is called a cotenant, and each holds an undivided fractional interest in the whole property.
Three Forms of Concurrent Ownership
The Undivided Interest
Core Rule: Equal Right to Possess
This default rule controls many exam questions. A cotenant living on the land alone is simply exercising her own right to possess the whole. Mere absence by the others is not a basis to demand rent.
The Exception: Ouster
Ouster occurs when one cotenant wrongfully excludes another from possession, denying that cotenant's right to enter and use the property.
Sharing Rents and Profits
When a cotenant collects rent from a third party or profits from the land, those receipts must be shared with the other cotenants in proportion to their interests.
Costs, Repairs & Improvements
Key Distinction: Repairs vs. Improvements
| Necessary Repairs | Improvements | |
|---|---|---|
| Right to contribution? | Yes (at accounting) | No |
| Recovery timing | Partition / accounting | Partition only |
| Amount recoverable | Proportional share of cost | Limited to added value |
| Notice required? | Often required first | Not relevant |
The Right of Partition
Any cotenant in a tenancy in common or joint tenancy may seek partition to end the cotenancy. Courts prefer partition in kind (physical division); if impractical, they order partition by sale and divide the proceeds.
How to Analyze a Cotenant Problem
Worked Example: Sole Possession
A and B own a cabin as tenants in common, each holding \( \tfrac{1}{2} \). B moves to another state. A lives in the cabin alone for two years and never blocks B from entering. B sues A for half the cabin's rental value.
Worked Example: Rents from a Third Party
A and B own farmland as tenants in common in shares of \( \tfrac{3}{4} \) and \( \tfrac{1}{4} \). A leases the land to a farmer for \( \$2{,}000 \) per month and pays \( \$400 \) per month in property taxes from the rent.
Worked Example: Improvements vs. Repairs
A and B each own \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) of a house. A spends \( \$8{,}000 \) fixing a failed roof (a necessary repair) and \( \$20{,}000 \) adding a new pool that raises the home's value by \( \$12{,}000 \).
Common Mistakes
Summary of Cotenant Rights
| Item | Default Rule |
|---|---|
| Possession | Each may possess the whole |
| Rent for sole use | None, unless ouster |
| Third-party rents | Shared by interest, net |
| Necessary repairs | Contribution at accounting |
| Improvements | Added value only, at partition |
| Ending the cotenancy | Partition (in kind or by sale) |
Question 1 of 4
A and B are tenants in common. B moves away; A lives alone in the property for three years but never bars B from entering. B sues A for rent. What is the likely result?
Question 2 of 4
A owns \( \tfrac{2}{3} \) and B owns \( \tfrac{1}{3} \) as tenants in common. A leases to a third party for \( \$900 \) per month and pays \( \$150 \) per month in taxes from the rent. How much per month is B entitled to?
Question 3 of 4
A spends \( \$30{,}000 \) building an addition that raises the home's value by \( \$18{,}000 \). At partition, what may A recover from co-owner B's interest?
Question 4 of 4
Which feature distinguishes a joint tenancy from a tenancy in common?