01 / 20

Cotenant Rights
Shared Ownership of Land

When two or more people own the same property at once, the law gives each a set of rights and duties. Learn to analyze how cotenants share, use, profit from, and account for jointly held land.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Cotenancy?

A cotenancy exists when two or more people hold concurrent ownership of the same property. Each owner is called a cotenant, and each holds an undivided fractional interest in the whole property.

Three Forms of Concurrent Ownership

Tenancy in Common
The default. Separate but undivided interests. No survivorship; shares pass by will or intestacy.
Joint Tenancy
Requires the four unities; carries the right of survivorship. A deceased tenant's share vanishes to the survivors.
Tenancy by Entirety
Joint tenancy between spouses. Survivorship plus protection from one spouse's individual creditors.

The Undivided Interest

Wrong: physical division A's half B's half ✕ Not how it works Right: undivided whole A & B each own a share of ALL of it ✓ Each may use the entire land

Core Rule: Equal Right to Possess

This default rule controls many exam questions. A cotenant living on the land alone is simply exercising her own right to possess the whole. Mere absence by the others is not a basis to demand rent.

The Exception: Ouster

Ouster occurs when one cotenant wrongfully excludes another from possession, denying that cotenant's right to enter and use the property.

Effect on Rent
The ousting cotenant must pay the excluded cotenant their fair rental share of the property.
Adverse Possession
An ouster can start the clock running for one cotenant to claim title by adverse possession.

Sharing Rents and Profits

When a cotenant collects rent from a third party or profits from the land, those receipts must be shared with the other cotenants in proportion to their interests.

Costs, Repairs & Improvements

1
Carrying costs. Taxes and mortgage interest are shared by all cotenants in proportion to their ownership; a paying cotenant may seek contribution.
2
Necessary repairs. A repairing cotenant may demand contribution, but generally only at partition or accounting, not immediately.
3
Improvements. No right to contribution. The improver recovers value only as a credit at partition, limited to the added value.
4
Waste. A cotenant may not commit voluntary, permissive, or ameliorative waste against the others' interests.

Key Distinction: Repairs vs. Improvements

Necessary Repairs Improvements
Right to contribution?Yes (at accounting)No
Recovery timingPartition / accountingPartition only
Amount recoverableProportional share of costLimited to added value
Notice required?Often required firstNot relevant

The Right of Partition

Any cotenant in a tenancy in common or joint tenancy may seek partition to end the cotenancy. Courts prefer partition in kind (physical division); if impractical, they order partition by sale and divide the proceeds.

A + B Cotenancy partition A's parcel B's parcel Separate ownership

How to Analyze a Cotenant Problem

1
Identify the cotenancy type. TIC, joint tenancy, or tenancy by entirety, and the fractional shares.
2
Ask: who is in possession? Sole possession alone owes no rent, unless there has been an ouster.
3
Trace money flows. Third-party rents and profits are shared; carrying costs are shared; classify repairs vs. improvements.
4
Resolve at accounting or partition. Most credits and contributions are settled when the cotenancy ends.

Worked Example: Sole Possession

A and B own a cabin as tenants in common, each holding \( \tfrac{1}{2} \). B moves to another state. A lives in the cabin alone for two years and never blocks B from entering. B sues A for half the cabin's rental value.

Worked Example: Rents from a Third Party

A and B own farmland as tenants in common in shares of \( \tfrac{3}{4} \) and \( \tfrac{1}{4} \). A leases the land to a farmer for \( \$2{,}000 \) per month and pays \( \$400 \) per month in property taxes from the rent.

Worked Example: Improvements vs. Repairs

A and B each own \( \tfrac{1}{2} \) of a house. A spends \( \$8{,}000 \) fixing a failed roof (a necessary repair) and \( \$20{,}000 \) adding a new pool that raises the home's value by \( \$12{,}000 \).

Common Mistakes

✕ Charging rent for sole use
A cotenant living alone owes no rent absent an ouster, even if the others stay away.
✕ Full cost for improvements
Improvers recover only the added value at partition, not the full amount spent.
✕ Confusing survivorship
Tenants in common have no survivorship; their shares pass by will or intestacy.
✕ Ignoring net amount
Shared rents are calculated net of taxes and other carrying costs first.

Summary of Cotenant Rights

ItemDefault Rule
PossessionEach may possess the whole
Rent for sole useNone, unless ouster
Third-party rentsShared by interest, net
Necessary repairsContribution at accounting
ImprovementsAdded value only, at partition
Ending the cotenancyPartition (in kind or by sale)

Question 1 of 4

A and B are tenants in common. B moves away; A lives alone in the property for three years but never bars B from entering. B sues A for rent. What is the likely result?

Question 2 of 4

A owns \( \tfrac{2}{3} \) and B owns \( \tfrac{1}{3} \) as tenants in common. A leases to a third party for \( \$900 \) per month and pays \( \$150 \) per month in taxes from the rent. How much per month is B entitled to?

Question 3 of 4

A spends \( \$30{,}000 \) building an addition that raises the home's value by \( \$18{,}000 \). At partition, what may A recover from co-owner B's interest?

Question 4 of 4

Which feature distinguishes a joint tenancy from a tenancy in common?