Contract
Modification
Determine when changes to an existing contract are legally valid and enforceable under common law and the UCC.
What Is a Modification?
A contract modification is a change to the terms of an existing, enforceable agreement. The parties agree to alter their original duties: a new price, a different delivery date, added goods, or revised performance.
First Ask: Which Law Governs?
Before testing a modification, decide which body of law applies. The two regimes treat modification very differently.
The Decision Path
Common Law: New Consideration
At common law, a modification is valid only if it is supported by new consideration. A promise to do what you are already legally bound to do is not consideration: the pre-existing duty rule.
When the Pre-Existing Duty Rule Bends
UCC: Good Faith, No Consideration
Under UCC § 2-209, a modification of a contract for the sale of goods needs no consideration to be binding. The only requirement is good faith: honesty in fact and commercially reasonable conduct.
Watch the Writing Requirement
A modification may need to be in writing to be enforceable:
Modification vs. Accord & Satisfaction
How to Analyze a Modification
Example 1: The Painter
Owner hires Painter to paint a house for \( \$3{,}000 \). Halfway through, Painter says the job is harder than expected and demands \( \$3{,}500 \). Owner orally agrees. Is the extra \( \$500 \) enforceable?
Example 2: The Steel Supplier
Supplier agrees to sell Buyer steel for \( \$50{,}000 \). A genuine market shortage strikes, and Supplier asks for \( \$58{,}000 \). Buyer agrees in writing. Enforceable?
Example 3: The Coerced Deal
Contractor knows Owner faces a deadline. With no change in circumstances, Contractor threatens to walk off unless Owner pays an extra \( \$15{,}000 \). Owner, with no alternatives, agrees. Valid?
Common Mistakes
Quick Comparison
| Common Law | UCC (Goods) | |
|---|---|---|
| New consideration? | Required | Not required |
| Good faith? | Helpful | Required |
| Writing required? | If within Statute | If goods \( \geq \$500 \) |
| Duress defense? | Yes | Yes |
Question 1 of 5
A landscaper contracts to mow a lawn weekly for the season. Mid-season she demands more pay for the same service, and the homeowner orally agrees. Under common law, the extra pay is:
Question 2 of 5
A wholesaler and retailer have a contract for the sale of widgets. They agree in good faith to raise the price after costs rise. What does the UCC require for this modification?
Question 3 of 5
Builder agrees to construct a deck for Owner for \( \$8{,}000 \). After starting, Builder discovers solid bedrock just below the surface, an unforeseen condition that makes excavation far more costly.
Builder asks for an additional \( \$2{,}000 \) to cover the unexpected work, and Owner agrees. The original price did not contemplate any such condition.
Is Owner's promise of the extra \( \$2{,}000 \) likely enforceable?
Question 4 of 5
A supplier, with no change in market conditions, threatens to halt deliveries unless the buyer pays substantially more, knowing the buyer has no alternative source. The buyer agrees. The modification is most likely:
Question 5 of 5
Two parties orally agree to modify a goods contract, raising the total price from \( \$400 \) to \( \$600 \). Which statement is most accurate?