Contract
Interpretation
Learn how courts read contract language, resolve ambiguities, and give effect to the parties' intent.
What Is Interpretation?
Contract interpretation is the process courts use to determine the meaning of contract language. When parties disagree over what their words mean, a court must decide whose understanding governs.
Three Key Terms
Why It Matters
Disputes arise when the same words carry different meanings to each side. Interpretation rules tell the court how to resolve the conflict.
The Objective Theory
A party's undisclosed, private intent cannot override the reasonable, objective meaning of the words actually used.
The Plain Meaning Rule
Patent vs. Latent Ambiguity
How to Apply the Rules
Interpretive Hierarchy
Example 1: Plain Meaning
A contract says: "Seller shall deliver 1,000 widgets at $5 each." Buyer later argues "each" really meant per dozen.
Example 2: Latent Ambiguity
A buys cotton "arriving on the ship Peerless." Unknown to both, two ships named Peerless sail months apart. Each party meant a different ship.
Example 3: Contra Proferentem
An insurance policy drafted by the insurer is genuinely ambiguous about whether flood damage is covered. The insured reads it as covered; the insurer says it is excluded.
Common Mistakes
Rules at a Glance
| When It Applies | Effect | |
|---|---|---|
| Plain Meaning | Language is clear | Apply ordinary meaning |
| Extrinsic Evidence | Language is ambiguous | Show intended meaning |
| Course of Performance | Conduct under this deal | Strong interpretive aid |
| Trade Usage | Industry custom exists | Fills in or explains terms |
| Contra Proferentem | Still ambiguous after all else | Construe against drafter |
Question 1 of 5
Under the objective theory, whose understanding controls the meaning of contract language?
Question 2 of 5
Under the plain meaning rule, when may a court consider extrinsic evidence of intent?
Question 3 of 5
A contract for "cotton arriving on the ship Peerless" turns out to involve two real ships, both named Peerless, sailing two months apart. The buyer meant the October ship; the seller meant the December ship. Neither knew of the other's ship.
This is best described as what kind of problem?
Question 4 of 5
Which interpretive source generally carries the highest weight?
Question 5 of 5
The doctrine of contra proferentem directs a court to interpret a genuinely ambiguous term: