01 / 20
?

Contract
Interpretation

Learn how courts read contract language, resolve ambiguities, and give effect to the parties' intent.

Bar Exam

What Is Interpretation?

Contract interpretation is the process courts use to determine the meaning of contract language. When parties disagree over what their words mean, a court must decide whose understanding governs.

Three Key Terms

Ambiguity
Language reasonably open to two or more meanings.
Vagueness
Language whose scope or boundary is uncertain.
Plain Meaning
The ordinary sense of clear, unambiguous words.

Why It Matters

Party A "deliver by Friday" means this Friday Party B "deliver by Friday" means next Friday DISPUTE Court Interprets finds parties' intent

Disputes arise when the same words carry different meanings to each side. Interpretation rules tell the court how to resolve the conflict.

The Objective Theory

A party's undisclosed, private intent cannot override the reasonable, objective meaning of the words actually used.

The Plain Meaning Rule

Contract Language Is it clear? CLEAR / Unambiguous Apply plain meaning; no outside evidence AMBIGUOUS Consider extrinsic evidence of intent

Patent vs. Latent Ambiguity

Patent Ambiguity
Apparent on the face of the document. The words themselves are unclear (e.g., "the car" when two cars exist in the contract).
Latent Ambiguity
Hidden until applied to facts. Words seem clear but fit two real-world referents (e.g., two ships both named Peerless).

How to Apply the Rules

1
Read the whole contract. Interpret terms in context, not in isolation.
2
Give words their plain meaning unless a special trade or technical usage applies.
3
Reconcile conflicting terms so all provisions have effect, if possible.
4
If ambiguous, consider extrinsic evidence: course of performance, course of dealing, and trade usage.
5
Apply default canons as a last resort (e.g., construe against the drafter).

Interpretive Hierarchy

1. Express Terms highest priority 2. Course of Performance how parties acted under THIS deal 3. Course of Dealing prior deals between parties 4. Trade Usage industry-wide custom decreasing weight

Example 1: Plain Meaning

A contract says: "Seller shall deliver 1,000 widgets at $5 each." Buyer later argues "each" really meant per dozen.

Example 2: Latent Ambiguity

A buys cotton "arriving on the ship Peerless." Unknown to both, two ships named Peerless sail months apart. Each party meant a different ship.

Example 3: Contra Proferentem

An insurance policy drafted by the insurer is genuinely ambiguous about whether flood damage is covered. The insured reads it as covered; the insurer says it is excluded.

Common Mistakes

✕ Using subjective intent
Relying on what a party privately meant instead of the objective, reasonable meaning.
✕ Ignoring context
Reading a clause in isolation rather than within the whole contract.
✕ Jumping to canons
Applying contra proferentem before exhausting plain meaning and extrinsic evidence.
✕ Confusing ambiguity types
Mixing up patent (on the face) and latent (in application) ambiguities.

Rules at a Glance

When It Applies Effect
Plain MeaningLanguage is clearApply ordinary meaning
Extrinsic EvidenceLanguage is ambiguousShow intended meaning
Course of PerformanceConduct under this dealStrong interpretive aid
Trade UsageIndustry custom existsFills in or explains terms
Contra ProferentemStill ambiguous after all elseConstrue against drafter

Question 1 of 5

Under the objective theory, whose understanding controls the meaning of contract language?

Question 2 of 5

Under the plain meaning rule, when may a court consider extrinsic evidence of intent?

Question 3 of 5

This is best described as what kind of problem?

Question 4 of 5

Which interpretive source generally carries the highest weight?

Question 5 of 5

The doctrine of contra proferentem directs a court to interpret a genuinely ambiguous term:

Key Takeaways

1
Objective standard: meaning turns on a reasonable person, not secret intent.
2
Plain meaning first: only ambiguous language opens the door to extrinsic evidence.
3
Know the hierarchy: express terms control over conduct and trade custom.
4
Canons last: construe against the drafter only when ambiguity remains.