01 / 20

Contract Damages
Making the Injured Party Whole

Learn to calculate expectation, reliance, and restitution damages when a contract is breached.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Why Damages Matter

When one party breaches a contract, the law does not punish the breacher. Instead, the goal is compensation: to put the injured party in the position they would have occupied had the contract been performed.

Three Damage Theories

Expectation
Position as if the contract had been fully performed. The "benefit of the bargain."
Reliance
Position as if the contract had never been made. Reimburses out-of-pocket costs.
Restitution
Recover the benefit conferred on the breaching party to prevent unjust enrichment.

Three Reference Positions

Expectation As if performed Reliance As if never made Restitution Benefit conferred Recovery generally decreases left to right

The Expectation Formula

This formula, from the Restatement (Second) of Contracts, puts the injured party where they would have been if the contract was performed. It accounts for all gains prevented and losses caused by the breach, minus any savings the injured party realized.

Three Limits on Damages

1
Causation. The loss must actually result from the breach.
2
Foreseeability (Hadley v. Baxendale). Consequential damages are recoverable only if they were a foreseeable result of breach at the time of contracting.
3
Certainty & Mitigation. Damages must be proven with reasonable certainty, and avoidable losses cannot be recovered.

Reliance vs. Restitution

Reliance Focus
Measures the plaintiff's loss — money spent in reliance on the promise, whether or not it benefited the defendant.
Restitution Focus
Measures the defendant's gain — the value of the benefit conferred on the breaching party.

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the breach and which party is injured.
2
Compute expectation: value promised minus value received, adjusted for costs avoided.
3
Add recoverable incidental and foreseeable consequential damages.
4
Subtract losses that could have been mitigated.
5
Consider alternatives (reliance or restitution) if expectation is too uncertain.

Example 1: Buyer's Expectation

Seller agrees to deliver a machine for \( \$10{,}000 \). Seller breaches. Buyer must buy a replacement on the market for \( \$13{,}000 \). What is the buyer's expectation recovery?

Example 2: Reliance Damages

A caterer is hired for a wedding for \( \$8{,}000 \). Before any work, the client cancels. The caterer had already spent \( \$2{,}500 \) on non-returnable ingredients and could not prove lost profit with certainty.

Example 3: Restitution

A contractor partially builds a deck worth \( \$6{,}000 \) in market value of work performed, then the homeowner breaches before the \( \$9{,}000 \) contract price is due. The contractor seeks restitution.

Example 4: Expectation + Mitigation

A seller contracts to sell goods for \( \$20{,}000 \) that cost the seller \( \$12{,}000 \) to produce. Buyer breaches; seller resells the goods to another buyer for \( \$18{,}000 \).

Common Mistakes

✕ Ignoring Mitigation
Forgetting to subtract losses the injured party could reasonably have avoided.
✕ Double Recovery
Stacking expectation and reliance for the same loss. Choose one consistent theory.
✕ Punitive Thinking
Contract damages compensate; they do not punish the breacher.
✕ Skipping Foreseeability
Awarding consequential damages that were not foreseeable at contract formation.

Summary Comparison

Expectation Reliance Restitution
Goal As if performed As if never made Undo enrichment
Measures Benefit of bargain Plaintiff's costs Defendant's gain
Typical Size Largest Middle Smallest
When Used Default rule Profit uncertain Benefit conferred

Question 1 of 5

A seller breaches a contract to sell goods for \( \$5{,}000 \). The buyer covers by purchasing identical goods for \( \$6{,}200 \). What are the buyer's expectation damages?

Question 2 of 5

Which damage theory puts the injured party in the position they would have been in if the contract had never been made?

Question 3 of 5

A contractor performs work worth \( \$4{,}000 \) in market value before the owner breaches. The contract price was \( \$5{,}500 \) but profit cannot be proven. Restitution recovery equals:

Question 4 of 5

Under Hadley v. Baxendale, consequential damages are recoverable only if they were:

Question 5 of 5

A seller produces goods for \( \$8{,}000 \) to sell for \( \$14{,}000 \). The buyer breaches and the seller resells the goods to another buyer for \( \$11{,}000 \). The seller's recoverable damages are:

Key Takeaways

1
Expectation is the default: the benefit of the bargain.
2
Reliance reimburses costs; use it when profit is uncertain.
3
Restitution recovers the benefit conferred on the breacher.
4
Always apply causation, foreseeability, certainty, and mitigation.