01 / 20

Conspiracy
Liability

When two or more people agree to commit a crime, each may be liable for the agreement itself and for crimes committed in its furtherance.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Conspiracy?

A conspiracy is an agreement between two or more persons to accomplish an unlawful objective. It is a separate crime from the underlying offense the parties plan to commit.

Why Conspiracy Matters

Separate Offense
A defendant can be convicted of both conspiracy and the completed crime: no merger at common law.
Vicarious Liability
Each conspirator is liable for foreseeable crimes committed by co-conspirators in furtherance of the plan.
Early Intervention
Police can arrest before the target crime occurs, stopping harm at the planning stage.

The Four Elements

1. Agreement Two or more persons agree on a plan 2. Bilateral Agreement Common law: two or more "guilty minds" required 3. Specific Intent Intent to agree AND intent to achieve objective 4. Overt Act Modern/MPC only: any step in furtherance

The Agreement Element

The agreement need not be express. It can be inferred from the conduct of the parties: a tacit, mutual understanding to pursue an unlawful objective is enough.

The Specific Intent Requirement

Conspiracy is a specific-intent crime requiring a dual intent:

1
Intent to agree with one or more other persons.
2
Intent to achieve the unlawful objective of the agreement.

The Pinkerton Rule

Under the Pinkerton doctrine (federal/majority view), a conspirator is liable for all crimes committed by co-conspirators that are:

1
In furtherance of the conspiracy, and
2
Reasonably foreseeable as a natural consequence of the agreement.

Conspiracy vs. Accomplice Liability

Conspiracy
Liability flows from the agreement. Reaches foreseeable crimes under Pinkerton, even ones you did not aid.
Accomplice
Liability flows from aiding or encouraging a specific crime with intent. No agreement required.

Withdrawal & Termination

From the Conspiracy
Cannot undo the conspiracy charge itself (already complete). Effective withdrawal only bars liability for future crimes of co-conspirators.
Complete Defense
Under the MPC, voluntary withdrawal that thwarts the conspiracy's success is a complete defense to the conspiracy charge.

How to Apply the Doctrine

1
Identify the agreement. Two or more persons with a meeting of the minds on an unlawful objective.
2
Check intent. Specific intent both to agree and to achieve the objective.
3
Verify the overt act if applying modern/MPC law.
4
Apply Pinkerton. Hold each conspirator liable for foreseeable crimes in furtherance of the plan.
5
Consider defenses such as withdrawal, impossibility, or Wharton's Rule.

Worked Example One

Facts: Anna and Ben agree to rob a bank. Before they act, police arrest them. Are they guilty of conspiracy?

Worked Example Two

Carl Dana Agree: burglary Dana shoots a guard during the break-in

Worked Example Three

Facts: Ed agrees with an undercover officer to sell drugs. The officer never intends to follow through. Is Ed guilty of conspiracy under the common law?

Common Mistakes

✕ Forgetting Merger
Conspiracy does not merge with the completed crime: a defendant can be convicted of both.
✕ Ignoring the MPC Split
The MPC uses a unilateral approach and rejects Pinkerton. Know which framework the question tests.
✕ Overlooking Foreseeability
Pinkerton liability requires the crime to be foreseeable AND in furtherance, not just any co-conspirator act.

Common Law vs. MPC

Common Law MPC / Modern
Agreement approachBilateral (2 guilty minds)Unilateral (D's own intent)
Overt act required?NoYes
Pinkerton liability?Yes (majority)Rejected
MergerNo mergerMerges (if same offense)
Withdrawal as defenseLimits future liabilityComplete defense if thwarted

Question 1 of 5

At common law, what completes the crime of conspiracy?

Question 2 of 5

Under the Pinkerton rule, a conspirator is liable for a co-conspirator's crime when it is:

Question 3 of 5

A defendant "agrees" only with an undercover officer who never intends to commit the crime. Under the common law, is there a conspiracy?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about merger is correct at common law?

Question 5 of 5

To effectively withdraw from a conspiracy, a defendant must: