01 / 20

Consideration
The Heart of a Bargain

Every enforceable contract needs bargained-for exchange. Learn to spot when valid consideration truly exists.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Consideration?

Consideration is the price of the bargain: what each party gives or promises to give in exchange for the other's promise. It is one of the essential elements that makes a promise legally enforceable.

The Two Elements of Consideration

Promisor Makes a promise Promisee Gives something promise value 1. Bargained-for Exchange 2. Legal Value (benefit/detriment)

Element 1: Bargained-For Exchange

The promise must be sought by the promisor in exchange for the promisee's performance or return promise, and given by the promisee in exchange for that promise. This is the "this-for-that" requirement.

Element 2: Legal Value

Legal Benefit
The promisor receives something they were not previously entitled to.
Legal Detriment
The promisee does, or promises to do, something they were not legally obligated to do (or forbears a legal right).

The Core Rule

Bargained-For + Legal Value (each side) = Valid Consideration

Bargain vs. Gift

Enforceable Bargain
"I'll pay you $500 if you paint my fence." Each side gives value: money for labor. Consideration exists.
Unenforceable Gift
"I'll give you $500 because I like you." Nothing is sought in return: no consideration, no contract.

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the promise. What did one party promise to do?
2
Find the price. What did the promisee give or promise in return?
3
Test for bargain. Did the promisor seek that thing in exchange for the promise?
4
Test for legal value. Did the promisee incur a detriment or the promisor gain a benefit?
5
Screen out the traps. Past consideration, pre-existing duty, and illusory promises all fail.

Worked Example: Simple Sale

Facts: Alex promises to sell Beth his bicycle for \( \$200 \). Beth promises to pay \( \$200 \).

Alex Beth bicycle $200

Worked Example: Past Consideration

Facts: After Carla had already mowed Dan's lawn for free last week, Dan says, "Because you mowed my lawn, I'll pay you \( \$50 \)." Carla now sues for the \( \$50 \).

Worked Example: Pre-Existing Duty

Facts: A contractor agreed to build a deck for \( \$5{,}000 \). Midway, with no new circumstances, he demands an extra \( \$1{,}000 \) "to finish." The owner agrees but later refuses to pay the extra.

Common Mistakes

✕ Adequacy ≠ Validity
Courts do not weigh adequacy. Even a peppercorn or \( \$1 \) can be valid consideration if bargained for.
✕ Illusory Promises
"I'll buy as much as I want" promises nothing. With no real commitment, there is no consideration.
✕ Moral Obligation
A promise made only out of moral duty or gratitude generally lacks consideration.

Valid vs. Invalid Consideration

Valid Invalid
Bargained forYesGift, moral obligation
TimingPresent/futurePast consideration
CommitmentReal obligationIllusory promise
DutyNew dutyPre-existing duty
AdequacyNot requiredN/A

A Quick Recap

1
Two elements: bargained-for exchange + legal value on each side.
2
Gifts fail because nothing is sought in return.
3
Watch the traps: past consideration, pre-existing duty, illusory promises.
4
Adequacy is irrelevant: courts won't measure the size of the bargain.

Question 1 of 5

Uncle promises niece \( \$1{,}000 \) "because you are such a good kid." Niece does nothing in return. Is there consideration?

Question 2 of 5

An aunt promises her nephew \( \$5{,}000 \) if he refrains from smoking and drinking until age 21. He does so. Is there valid consideration?

Question 3 of 5

A salesman rescues a drowning child. Grateful, the parent later promises to pay him \( \$2{,}000 \). Is the promise supported by consideration?

Question 4 of 5

A police officer, already on duty to find a fugitive, claims a private \( \$500 \) reward for the capture. Is there consideration for the reward promise?

Question 5 of 5

A buyer promises a seller, "I will buy as many widgets as I feel like buying, at \( \$2 \) each." Does this promise furnish consideration?

You've Got Consideration Down