01 / 20

The Confrontation
Clause

The Sixth Amendment right of a criminal defendant to be confronted with the witnesses against him — and how it limits the use of out-of-court statements.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What the Clause Guarantees

The Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment provides that in all criminal prosecutions, the accused has the right "to be confronted with the witnesses against him." This means the prosecution generally cannot use a witness's statement against a defendant unless the defendant has had a chance to cross-examine that witness.

Three Key Terms

Testimonial
A statement made for the primary purpose of establishing facts for later use at trial.
Declarant
The person who made the out-of-court statement that the prosecution seeks to use.
Unavailable
The declarant cannot testify at trial (death, privilege, absence despite a good-faith effort to produce).

Visualizing the Flow

Declarant Out-of-court statement Offered at trial Is the statement testimonial? No Yes No Clause issue (hearsay rules only) Barred unless: declarant unavailable AND prior chance to cross-examine

The Crawford Rule

In Crawford v. Washington (2004), the Supreme Court held that a testimonial statement of an absent witness may be admitted against a criminal defendant only if:

1
The declarant is unavailable to testify at trial, AND
2
The defendant had a prior opportunity to cross-examine the declarant about the statement.

Testimonial vs. Non-Testimonial

Davis v. Washington (2006) drew the line for police interrogations using the primary purpose test:

Non-Testimonial
Primary purpose is to meet an ongoing emergency (e.g., a 911 call describing an attack in progress). No Clause problem.
Testimonial
Primary purpose is to establish past events for later prosecution (e.g., stationhouse questioning after danger has passed). Clause applies.

Hearsay vs. Confrontation

Two separate doctrines often apply at once. A statement must survive both to come in against a criminal defendant.

Hearsay Rule Confrontation Clause
SourceRules of EvidenceSixth Amendment
Applies inCivil & criminalCriminal only
Triggered byOut-of-court statement for its truthTestimonial statement
Cured byA hearsay exceptionUnavailability + prior cross

How to Apply It

1
Criminal case? If not, the Clause does not apply — analyze hearsay only.
2
Offered against the accused? The Clause protects only the defendant.
3
Testimonial? Apply the primary-purpose test. If non-testimonial, no Clause issue.
4
Did the declarant testify? If the declarant is on the stand and subject to cross, the Clause is satisfied.
5
If absent: admissible only if unavailable AND there was a prior opportunity to cross-examine.

Example 1: 911 Call

A victim calls 911 screaming, "He's hitting me — he's here right now!" while the attack is happening. The victim later refuses to testify. The prosecution offers the 911 recording.

Example 2: Stationhouse Statement

Hours after the suspect is arrested and the scene is secure, police take a written statement from a witness describing what the defendant did. At trial, the witness has moved abroad and cannot be located. The defense never had a chance to question her.

Example 3: Prior Testimony

At a preliminary hearing, the defendant's attorney cross-examined a witness. By trial the witness has died. The prosecution offers a transcript of the preliminary-hearing testimony.

The Forfeiture Doctrine

A defendant who wrongfully causes a witness's absence loses, or "forfeits," the confrontation objection.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the doctrines
Assuming a hearsay exception automatically defeats a confrontation objection. They are separate hurdles.
✕ Ignoring "testimonial"
Applying the Clause to every out-of-court statement. Only testimonial statements trigger it.
✕ Forgetting the live witness
If the declarant testifies at trial subject to cross, there is no Clause problem at all.
✕ Applying it in civil cases
The Confrontation Clause protects only the accused in criminal prosecutions.

Quick Summary

Scenario Result Why
Non-testimonial (ongoing emergency)AdmissibleClause not triggered
Testimonial, declarant testifiesAdmissibleCross available now
Testimonial, unavailable + prior crossAdmissibleCrawford satisfied
Testimonial, no prior crossBarredCrawford violated
Absence caused by defendant's intentAdmissibleForfeiture by wrongdoing

Question 1 of 5

In which type of case does the Confrontation Clause apply?

Question 2 of 5

Under Crawford, a testimonial statement of an absent witness is admissible against the defendant only if which two conditions are met?

Question 3 of 5

How should the court rule on the objection?

Question 4 of 5

A witness gave a written statement at the police station after the danger had passed, was never cross-examined, and has since disappeared. The prosecution offers the statement. The court should:

Question 5 of 5

Under Giles v. California, when does a defendant forfeit the right to confront an absent witness?

Putting It Together

1
Screen first: criminal case, statement against the accused.
2
Ask "testimonial?" using the primary-purpose test.
3
If testimonial, require unavailability plus a prior chance to cross-examine.
4
Remember forfeiture by wrongdoing and that hearsay analysis is separate.