01 / 20

Confession
Admissibility

Learn how courts decide whether a suspect's statement may be used at trial: the Fifth Amendment, Miranda warnings, and the voluntariness standard.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Confession?

A confession is any statement by a suspect that admits guilt or supplies facts the prosecution can use to prove a crime. Before a confession reaches a jury, the court must decide whether it was obtained lawfully.

Three Constitutional Screens

5th Amendment Miranda warnings in custody Due Process Voluntariness no coercion 6th Amendment Right to counsel after charge Admissible? Must pass all three

The Miranda Rule

Under Miranda v. Arizona, statements from custodial interrogation are inadmissible unless police gave the warnings and the suspect validly waived them.

Custody
A reasonable person would not feel free to leave: a formal arrest or its functional equivalent.
Interrogation
Express questioning OR words/actions police should know are likely to elicit an incriminating response.

The Four Warnings

1
Right to remain silent. You do not have to say anything.
2
Anything used against you. Statements may be evidence in court.
3
Right to an attorney. You may consult a lawyer before and during questioning.
4
Appointed counsel. If you cannot afford one, a lawyer will be provided.

The Voluntariness Standard

Separate from Miranda, the Due Process Clause bars any confession that is not the product of the suspect's free and rational choice. The test looks at the totality of the circumstances.

Totality of Circumstances Police conduct threats, deception Suspect traits age, education Conditions length, isolation Free & rational choice?

Miranda vs. Voluntariness

MirandaVoluntariness
Source5th AmendmentDue Process
TriggerCustody + interrogationAny state action
FocusWarnings & waiverCoercion / free will
State action neededYesYes
Impeachment useAllowedNever (if involuntary)

How to Analyze a Confession

1
State action? A private actor's coercion does not trigger constitutional protections.
2
Custody + interrogation? If yes, warnings and a valid waiver are required (Miranda).
3
Voluntary? Examine the totality of circumstances for coercion.
4
Sixth Amendment? Has the right to counsel attached and been violated?

Example 1: Traffic Stop

An officer pulls over a driver for speeding and asks, "Have you been drinking?" The driver answers "Yes" before any warnings. The driver moves to suppress.

Example 2: Station House

Police arrest a suspect, bring him to the station, and question him for two hours without giving any warnings. He confesses to a burglary.

Example 3: Coerced Waiver

Police read full Miranda warnings, then deny the suspect food, water, and sleep for 18 hours until he signs a confession. He moves to suppress.

Common Mistakes

✕ Assuming arrest equals interrogation
Custody alone does not trigger Miranda; questioning (or its functional equivalent) must also occur.
✕ Forgetting the impeachment rule
A Miranda-defective but voluntary statement can still impeach a testifying defendant.
✕ Ignoring state action
Coercion by a private citizen does not implicate Due Process or Miranda.

Suppression Summary

DefectCase-in-ChiefImpeachment
Miranda violation (voluntary)ExcludedAllowed
Involuntary confessionExcludedExcluded
No defectAdmissibleAdmissible

The Sixth Amendment Screen

The Sixth Amendment right to counsel attaches after formal charges (indictment, arraignment, or first appearance). It is offense-specific: police may still question about unrelated crimes.

Quick Recap

5th / Miranda
Warnings for custodial interrogation; voluntary statements impeach.
Due Process
Totality test for voluntariness; involuntary = excluded for all uses.
6th Amendment
Attaches after charge; offense-specific right to counsel.

Question 1 of 5

Both Miranda's two triggering conditions must exist together. They are:

Question 2 of 5

A voluntary statement obtained without Miranda warnings may still be used to:

Question 3 of 5

How should the court rule?

Question 4 of 5

A private security guard physically threatens a shoplifter into confessing. Police were not involved. The confession is:

Question 5 of 5

The Sixth Amendment right to counsel attaches when: