Conditions and
Promises
Learn to tell apart an event that triggers a duty from a commitment to perform in contract law.
Two Building Blocks of a Contract
Every contract is made of obligations. To analyze a problem, you must separate the two key concepts at work:
Why the Difference Matters
The same words can be read either way, but the legal consequences are dramatically different:
A Conditional Duty in Motion
The Core Rule
Three Types of Conditions
Condition vs. Promise
| Condition | Promise | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | An event | A commitment |
| Who controls it | Often outside party | The promisor |
| If it fails | Duty excused | Breach |
| Remedy available | None for failure | Damages |
| Typical words | "if," "provided that," "on condition that" | "shall," "promises to," "agrees to" |
How to Classify a Clause
Worked Example: Plain Condition
"Owner will pay Builder $50,000 if and when the architect certifies the work is complete."
Worked Example: A Promise
"Contractor shall complete the roof by June 1 and Owner shall pay $20,000."
Worked Example: A Promissory Condition
"Tenant shall obtain fire insurance, and Landlord's duty to repair arises only if such insurance is in force."
Common Mistakes
Quick Summary
| Scenario | Classification | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| "Pay if delivered" | Condition | Duty excused if no delivery |
| "Shall complete by date" | Promise | Breach if missed |
| "Shall insure; repair if insured" | Both | Breach and/or excuse |
| Ambiguous wording | Court prefers promise | Avoids forfeiture |
Question 1 of 5
What is the primary legal effect when a pure condition fails to occur?
Question 2 of 5
Which word most strongly signals a promise rather than a condition?
Question 3 of 5
"Buyer agrees to purchase the home provided that Buyer is able to obtain a mortgage at no more than 6% interest within 30 days."
Buyer applies in good faith but no lender approves a loan at that rate. Buyer refuses to close.
How is the financing clause best classified?
Question 4 of 5
When a clause is genuinely ambiguous, courts generally interpret it as which of the following?
Question 5 of 5
"Tenant shall insure, and Landlord must repair only if insurance is in force." The insurance requirement is:
Key Takeaways
You Can Now Distinguish Them
Read the language, find who controls the event, and test the consequence: that is how you separate a condition from a promise.