01 / 20

Conditions and
Promises

Learn to tell apart an event that triggers a duty from a commitment to perform in contract law.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Two Building Blocks of a Contract

Every contract is made of obligations. To analyze a problem, you must separate the two key concepts at work:

Promise
A commitment by a party to do or not do something. Breaking a promise is a breach that gives the other side a remedy.
Condition
An event that must occur (or not occur) before a duty to perform arises. Failure of a condition excuses performance.

Why the Difference Matters

The same words can be read either way, but the legal consequences are dramatically different:

If a Promise Fails
The party is in breach. The other party can sue for damages and may still owe its own performance.
If a Condition Fails
No breach occurs. The conditioned duty is discharged: that party simply does not have to perform.

A Conditional Duty in Motion

Condition Event must occur Duty to Perform becomes due If satisfied Duty Discharged no breach If it fails

The Core Rule

1
Conditions control when a duty must be performed.
2
Promises control what a party has committed to do.
3
A single clause can be drafted as a condition, a promise, or both at once.

Three Types of Conditions

Precedent
Event that must occur before the duty arises. "I will pay if the goods are delivered."
Concurrent
Each party's duty is conditioned on the other's simultaneous performance, as in cash sales.
Subsequent
Event that cuts off an existing duty once it occurs.

Condition vs. Promise

ConditionPromise
NatureAn eventA commitment
Who controls itOften outside partyThe promisor
If it failsDuty excusedBreach
Remedy availableNone for failureDamages
Typical words"if," "provided that," "on condition that""shall," "promises to," "agrees to"

How to Classify a Clause

1
Read the language. "If," "when," or "provided that" signals a condition; "shall" or "agrees to" signals a promise.
2
Ask who controls the event. If a third party or outside event controls it, it is more likely a condition.
3
Test the consequence. Would failure excuse a duty (condition) or trigger liability (promise)?
4
When in doubt, courts prefer a promise to avoid forfeiture.

Worked Example: Plain Condition

"Owner will pay Builder $50,000 if and when the architect certifies the work is complete."

Worked Example: A Promise

"Contractor shall complete the roof by June 1 and Owner shall pay $20,000."

Worked Example: A Promissory Condition

"Tenant shall obtain fire insurance, and Landlord's duty to repair arises only if such insurance is in force."

Promise to insure breach if not done Condition to repair excuse if not done

Common Mistakes

✕ Awarding damages for a failed condition
Failure of a pure condition excuses a duty; it is not a breach and gives no damages.
✕ Ignoring the magic words
"If/provided that" point to a condition; "shall/agrees" point to a promise. Read carefully.
✕ Forgetting dual clauses
A single provision can be a promissory condition: both a promise and a condition.

Quick Summary

ScenarioClassificationConsequence
"Pay if delivered"ConditionDuty excused if no delivery
"Shall complete by date"PromiseBreach if missed
"Shall insure; repair if insured"BothBreach and/or excuse
Ambiguous wordingCourt prefers promiseAvoids forfeiture

Question 1 of 5

What is the primary legal effect when a pure condition fails to occur?

Question 2 of 5

Which word most strongly signals a promise rather than a condition?

Question 3 of 5

How is the financing clause best classified?

Question 4 of 5

When a clause is genuinely ambiguous, courts generally interpret it as which of the following?

Question 5 of 5

"Tenant shall insure, and Landlord must repair only if insurance is in force." The insurance requirement is:

Key Takeaways

1
A condition is an event; failing it excuses a duty with no breach.
2
A promise is a commitment; breaking it is a breach giving damages.
3
Watch the words: "if/provided that" vs. "shall/agrees to."
4
One clause can be both, and courts prefer promises to avoid forfeiture.

You Can Now Distinguish Them

Read the language, find who controls the event, and test the consequence: that is how you separate a condition from a promise.