I'll generate a complete, self-contained HTML slide deck on Comparative Fault following the design system exactly. ```html Comparative Fault — Bar Exam
01 / 20

Comparative
Fault

How courts divide damages when both the plaintiff and the defendant share blame for an injury.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Comparative Fault?

In a negligence case, sometimes both parties acted carelessly. A pedestrian jaywalks, and a driver speeds. Both contributed to the crash.

Comparative fault is the rule that assigns each party a percentage of responsibility and reduces the plaintiff's recovery by their own share of the blame.

The Core Vocabulary

Plaintiff
The injured party who sues to recover damages.
Defendant
The party alleged to have caused the harm.
Damages
The total dollar value of the plaintiff's injury.

Dividing the Blame

$100,000 Total Damages Defendant 70% Plaintiff 30% Recovery $70,000 Reduction −$30,000 Plaintiff 30% at fault → loses 30% of recovery

The Recovery Formula

D
Total damages. The full dollar value of the plaintiff's injury, before any reduction.
f
Plaintiff's fault fraction. Their share of the blame expressed as a decimal, where \( 0 \leq f \leq 1 \).

Three Fault Systems

Pure Comparative
Plaintiff recovers reduced damages no matter how high their own fault — even at 99%.
Modified Comparative
Recovery is barred once the plaintiff's fault crosses a threshold (50% or 51%).
Contributory
Any plaintiff fault, even 1%, completely bars recovery (the old common-law rule).

Modified Thresholds

"50% Bar" Rule 0%–49% recovers 50%+ barred "51% Bar" Rule 0%–50% recovers 51%+ barred Difference: who recovers at exactly 50% fault

Comparative vs. Contributory

Comparative Fault Contributory Negligence
Plaintiff 10% at fault Recovers 90% Recovers $0
Effect of small fault Proportional reduction Total bar to recovery
Fairness goal Split loss by blame All-or-nothing
Modern adoption Vast majority of states Few jurisdictions

How to Apply It

1
Identify the system. Pure, modified (50% or 51%), or contributory.
2
Determine total damages \( (D) \) — the full value of the harm.
3
Find the plaintiff's fault %. Convert it to the fraction \( f \).
4
Check the threshold. In a modified system, is the plaintiff barred?
5
Compute recovery with \( D \times (1 - f) \) if not barred.

Example 1: Pure System

A plaintiff suffers $80,000 in damages but is found 25% at fault. The jurisdiction follows pure comparative fault.

Example 2: Modified 50%

Plaintiff has $200,000 in damages and is 55% at fault. The state uses the "50% bar" rule.

Recovers (under 50%) Plaintiff = 55% → BARRED 55% > 50% threshold

Example 3: The 50% Edge

Plaintiff has $120,000 in damages and is exactly 50% at fault. Compare the two modified rules.

Rule 50% Bar 51% Bar
At exactly 50% Barred Recovers
Recovery amount $0 $60,000

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping the threshold
In a modified system, always check if the plaintiff is barred before multiplying.
✕ Reducing by defendant's fault
Recovery is reduced by the plaintiff's own fault, not the defendant's.
✕ Confusing 50% vs 51%
The two rules split at exactly 50% — read the facts carefully.
✕ Treating it as all-or-nothing
That is contributory negligence, not comparative fault.

System Summary

System Recovery Rule Plaintiff 60% Fault
Pure Comparative Always reduced by \( f \) Recovers 40%
Modified 50% Bar Barred if \( f \geq 0.50 \) $0
Modified 51% Bar Barred if \( f \geq 0.51 \) $0
Contributory Any fault bars recovery $0

Question 1 of 5

A plaintiff with $50,000 in damages is 20% at fault in a pure comparative jurisdiction. What is the recovery?

Question 2 of 5

In a "50% bar" modified system, a plaintiff found exactly 50% at fault recovers:

Question 3 of 5

Under traditional contributory negligence, a plaintiff who is just 1% at fault recovers:

Question 4 of 5

A plaintiff has $300,000 in damages and is 70% at fault in a pure comparative jurisdiction. What is the recovery?

Question 5 of 5

What does Dana recover?

Key Takeaways

1
Identify the system first — it controls whether recovery is even possible.
2
Modified systems have a threshold (50% or 51%) that can bar recovery entirely.
3
If not barred, recovery is \( D \times (1 - f) \) — reduce by the plaintiff's fault.
4
Contributory negligence bars recovery for any plaintiff fault — the opposite of comparative fault.