Comparative
Fault
How courts divide damages when both the plaintiff and the defendant share blame for an injury.
What Is Comparative Fault?
In a negligence case, sometimes both parties acted carelessly. A pedestrian jaywalks, and a driver speeds. Both contributed to the crash.
Comparative fault is the rule that assigns each party a percentage of responsibility and reduces the plaintiff's recovery by their own share of the blame.
The Core Vocabulary
Dividing the Blame
The Recovery Formula
Three Fault Systems
Modified Thresholds
Comparative vs. Contributory
| Comparative Fault | Contributory Negligence | |
|---|---|---|
| Plaintiff 10% at fault | Recovers 90% | Recovers $0 |
| Effect of small fault | Proportional reduction | Total bar to recovery |
| Fairness goal | Split loss by blame | All-or-nothing |
| Modern adoption | Vast majority of states | Few jurisdictions |
How to Apply It
Example 1: Pure System
A plaintiff suffers $80,000 in damages but is found 25% at fault. The jurisdiction follows pure comparative fault.
Example 2: Modified 50%
Plaintiff has $200,000 in damages and is 55% at fault. The state uses the "50% bar" rule.
Example 3: The 50% Edge
Plaintiff has $120,000 in damages and is exactly 50% at fault. Compare the two modified rules.
| Rule | 50% Bar | 51% Bar |
|---|---|---|
| At exactly 50% | Barred | Recovers |
| Recovery amount | $0 | $60,000 |
Common Mistakes
System Summary
| System | Recovery Rule | Plaintiff 60% Fault |
|---|---|---|
| Pure Comparative | Always reduced by \( f \) | Recovers 40% |
| Modified 50% Bar | Barred if \( f \geq 0.50 \) | $0 |
| Modified 51% Bar | Barred if \( f \geq 0.51 \) | $0 |
| Contributory | Any fault bars recovery | $0 |
Question 1 of 5
A plaintiff with $50,000 in damages is 20% at fault in a pure comparative jurisdiction. What is the recovery?
Question 2 of 5
In a "50% bar" modified system, a plaintiff found exactly 50% at fault recovers:
Question 3 of 5
Under traditional contributory negligence, a plaintiff who is just 1% at fault recovers:
Question 4 of 5
A plaintiff has $300,000 in damages and is 70% at fault in a pure comparative jurisdiction. What is the recovery?
Question 5 of 5
Facts: Dana suffered $100,000 in injuries in a car crash. A jury found Dana 40% at fault and the other driver 60% at fault. The state follows the "51% bar" modified comparative fault rule.
The defense argues Dana should recover nothing because Dana shares significant blame.
What does Dana recover?