01 / 20

Character
Evidence

When can a person's character traits be used as proof? Master the rules of admissibility under the Federal Rules of Evidence.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Character Evidence?

Character evidence is proof about a person's general disposition or moral qualities, offered to suggest how that person likely behaved on a particular occasion.

The law is deeply suspicious of this reasoning because it risks unfair prejudice, distracts the jury, and punishes people for who they are rather than what they did.

Three Forms of Proof

Character can be proven three ways. Which form is allowed depends on the context.

Reputation
What the community says about the person.
Opinion
A witness's personal belief about the person's character.
Specific Acts
Particular instances of past conduct.

The General Rule: FRE 404(a)

Bad Character "He is violent" Acted Badly "So he hit her" FORBIDDEN PROPENSITY INFERENCE The law cuts the chain of reasoning here

Criminal Case Exceptions

In a criminal case, the propensity ban relaxes. The defendant holds the key.

1
Defendant opens the door. A criminal defendant may offer evidence of a pertinent good character trait (e.g., peacefulness in an assault case).
2
Prosecution rebuts. Once the door is opened, the prosecution may offer evidence of the same trait to rebut.
3
Victim's character. Defendant may offer evidence of the victim's pertinent trait; prosecution may then rebut and offer the defendant's same trait.

Character vs. Non-Character Purpose

Specific prior acts are barred only when used for propensity. Under FRE 404(b), they ARE admissible for another purpose, remembered by MIMIC:

M — Motive
Why the person would act.
I — Intent
Mental state, not by accident.
M — Mistake
Absence of mistake.
I — Identity
A signature "modus operandi."
C — Common Plan
A common scheme or plan.

How to Analyze Admissibility

1
Identify the purpose. Is the evidence offered to show propensity, or for some other reason (MIMIC, character at issue, impeachment)?
2
Civil or criminal? Character is far more restricted in civil cases. Criminal cases have defendant-driven exceptions.
3
Check the proper form. Reputation, opinion, or specific acts? Match the form to the context.
4
Apply FRE 403 balancing. Even relevant evidence is excluded if unfair prejudice substantially outweighs probative value.

When Character Is "At Issue"

Sometimes character is an essential element of a claim or defense. Then all three forms—including specific acts—are freely admissible.

Defamation
The plaintiff's reputation is the core of the case.
Negligent Hiring
The employee's character is an element of the claim.
Child Custody
A parent's character directly determines fitness.

Worked Example One

Analysis: The prosecution is offering bad character to show Dan acted violently. This is pure propensity evidence offered first by the prosecution.

Worked Example Two

Analysis: The prior fires are specific acts. Offered for propensity they would be barred—but here they show motive (insurance fraud) and a common plan.

Worked Example Three

Analysis: Dan offers the victim's pertinent trait (violence) by reputation, a proper form. This supports his self-defense claim.

Habit Is Not Character

Habit (FRE 406) is a regular, specific, near-automatic response to a particular situation. Unlike character, habit is always admissible to prove conduct.

Character Habit
Scope General disposition Specific, repeated response
Example "Careful person" "Always signals at Elm St."
Admissible? Generally barred Always admissible

Special Rules: Sexual Assault

In sexual assault and child molestation cases, the rules flip. The prosecution gets extra power.

FRE 413–415
Defendant's prior sexual assaults ARE admissible to show propensity.
FRE 412
Rape shield: the victim's sexual history is generally inadmissible.

Common Mistakes

✕ Letting prosecution strike first
In criminal cases, the prosecution cannot introduce the defendant's bad character until the defendant opens the door.
✕ Forgetting FRE 403
Even MIMIC evidence must survive the probative-vs-prejudice balancing test.
✕ Confusing habit with character
Habit is specific and automatic; character is general disposition. Only habit is freely admissible.
✕ Wrong form of proof
On direct, only reputation and opinion are allowed; specific acts come out mainly on cross.

Admissibility Summary

Civil Case Criminal Case
Propensity use Barred Barred (with exceptions)
Defendant's good character Not allowed Allowed if pertinent
MIMIC (404(b)) Allowed Allowed
Character at issue All forms allowed All forms allowed
Habit Always Always

Question 1 of 5

In a criminal battery trial, the prosecution's first witness testifies that the defendant "is known around town as a violent man." The defense objects. How should the court rule?

Question 2 of 5

A defendant is charged with theft by a unique method: disabling alarms with a specific homemade device. The prosecution offers evidence of three prior thefts using the identical device. This is most likely admissible to prove:

Question 3 of 5

A witness testifies that the plaintiff "every single time he reaches the Oak Street intersection, comes to a complete stop and checks both ways." This evidence is best characterized as:

Question 4 of 5

In a defamation suit, the defendant published that the plaintiff is "a dishonest cheat." To defend, the defendant offers specific instances of the plaintiff's past fraudulent conduct. This evidence is:

Question 5 of 5

A defendant charged with assault calls a witness who testifies, "In my opinion, the defendant is a peaceful person." Which response by the prosecution is proper?