01 / 20

Burden of Proof
Standards of Persuasion

Learn who must prove what, and how convincing the evidence must be across civil and criminal cases.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is the Burden of Proof?

The burden of proof is the duty placed on a party to prove its claims. It answers two essential questions in every trial: who must prove the facts, and how much evidence is enough to win.

Two Components of the Burden

Burden of Production Must present enough evidence to put a fact in dispute (Decided by judge) Burden of Persuasion Must convince the fact-finder to the required standard (Decided by jury)

Three Standards of Persuasion

Preponderance
More likely than not — over \(50\%\). The default standard in civil cases.
Clear & Convincing
Substantially more likely true — a firm conviction. Used in special civil matters.
Beyond Reasonable Doubt
Near certainty. The highest standard, reserved for criminal cases.

The Spectrum of Certainty

\(0\%\)
\(100\%\)
\(>50\%\)
Preponderance
\(\approx 75\%\)
Clear & Convincing Beyond Reasonable Doubt Increasing degree of certainty required →

Core Rule: Civil Cases

In an ordinary civil case, the plaintiff bears the burden of persuasion by a preponderance of the evidence. The plaintiff must show each element is more likely true than not.

Core Rule: Criminal Cases

In a criminal case, the prosecution must prove every element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. The defendant is presumed innocent and never bears the burden to prove innocence.

Production vs. Persuasion

ProductionPersuasion
Question answeredIs there enough to reach a jury?Who wins on the merits?
Decided byJudgeJury (fact-finder)
When it mattersBefore submissionAt deliberation
Can shift?Yes, may shiftGenerally fixed

How to Apply the Standards

1
Identify the type of case. Civil or criminal? This sets the baseline standard.
2
Determine who bears the burden. Usually the party asserting the claim (plaintiff or prosecution).
3
Select the correct standard. Preponderance, clear and convincing, or beyond a reasonable doubt.
4
Apply to each element. Measure whether the evidence meets the threshold for every required element.

Example 1: Negligence Claim

A plaintiff sues a driver for negligence. The evidence makes it appear about \(55\%\) likely the driver was careless. Does the plaintiff meet the burden?

Example 2: Criminal Fraud

A defendant is charged with fraud. The jury believes there is roughly an \(80\%\) chance the defendant is guilty. Should the jury convict?

Example 3: Fraud in a Civil Suit

A plaintiff brings a civil claim for fraud. Many jurisdictions require fraud to be proven by clear and convincing evidence, not mere preponderance.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing the parts
Mixing up the burden of production (reach the jury) with the burden of persuasion (win the case).
✕ Wrong default
Assuming all civil claims use preponderance, ignoring clear-and-convincing exceptions like fraud.
✕ Shifting to defendant
Thinking a criminal defendant must prove innocence. The prosecution always bears the burden.

Summary Table

StandardThresholdTypical Use
Preponderance\( > 50\% \)Most civil cases
Clear & Convincing\( \approx 75\% \)Fraud, parental rights
Beyond Reasonable Doubt\( \approx 100\% \)Criminal cases

Question 1 of 5

What is the standard of proof in an ordinary civil case?

Question 2 of 5

In a criminal trial, who bears the burden of proof and to what standard?

Question 3 of 5

A jury finds it about \(60\%\) likely the defendant breached a contract in a civil suit. What result?

Question 4 of 5

Which component of the burden is decided by the judge rather than the jury?

Question 5 of 5

Which claim most commonly requires the heightened clear and convincing standard?

You've Got the Burden Down

You can now identify who must prove a fact and apply the correct standard — preponderance, clear and convincing, or beyond a reasonable doubt.