Breach Analysis
Did the Duty Break?
Learn to determine whether a party's failure to perform amounts to a breach of contract, and how to classify it as material or minor.
What Is a Breach?
A breach of contract occurs when a party fails to perform a contractual duty that has become due, without a valid legal excuse. Before analyzing breach, you must confirm a valid contract exists and that the duty was actually owed.
Key Terms
The Breach Inquiry
Why It Matters
The type of breach controls the remedy. Whether a breach is material or minor determines if the non-breaching party can walk away from the deal entirely or must continue performing while suing for damages.
The Core Rule
Formally, treat breach as a logical condition. If \( P \) = performance occurred, \( E \) = a valid excuse exists, and \( D \) = duty was due, then breach \( B \) holds when:
$$ B = D \land \lnot P \land \lnot E $$
Materiality Factors
Material vs. Minor
How to Apply It
Example 1: Clear Failure
Facts: A contractor agrees to build a house by June 1 for $200,000. By the deadline, no foundation has been poured and the owner has paid a $50,000 deposit. The contractor offers no excuse.
Example 2: Substantial Performance
Facts: A builder completes a $300,000 home exactly to spec, except she installs a different but equivalent brand of pipe that the owner cannot see. The cost to replace it would be $20,000.
Example 3: Excuse Defeats Breach
Facts: A supplier promises 1,000 widgets by July 1. The buyer's payment, a condition precedent to shipment, never arrives. The supplier withholds the goods.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Material | Minor | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose defeated? | Yes | No |
| Other side may suspend? | Yes | No |
| Substantial performance? | No | Yes |
| Remedy | Total damages | Damages only |
Question 1 of 5
Which combination is required for a breach to exist?
Question 2 of 5
A builder finishes a home to spec except for a trivial, hidden pipe-brand substitution. This is most likely a:
Question 3 of 5
The legal significance of classifying a breach as material is that the non-breaching party may:
Question 4 of 5
A buyer's payment is a condition precedent to a supplier's shipment, but the buyer never pays. The supplier withholds the goods. The supplier has:
Question 5 of 5
Which factor is least relevant when deciding whether a breach is material?
Putting It Together
To determine whether a breach occurred, march through the inquiry in order: duty due, failure to perform, no excuse, then classify as material or minor.