01 / 20

Breach Analysis
Did the Duty Break?

Learn to determine whether a party's failure to perform amounts to a breach of contract, and how to classify it as material or minor.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is a Breach?

A breach of contract occurs when a party fails to perform a contractual duty that has become due, without a valid legal excuse. Before analyzing breach, you must confirm a valid contract exists and that the duty was actually owed.

Key Terms

Duty Due
A performance obligation whose conditions have been satisfied and whose time has arrived.
Material Breach
A serious failure that defeats the contract's essential purpose; the injured party may suspend and sue.
Minor Breach
A small deviation; the contract stands and the injured party may recover only damages.

The Breach Inquiry

Was a duty due? Did the party fail to perform? Any valid excuse? Material or minor?

Why It Matters

The type of breach controls the remedy. Whether a breach is material or minor determines if the non-breaching party can walk away from the deal entirely or must continue performing while suing for damages.

The Core Rule

Formally, treat breach as a logical condition. If \( P \) = performance occurred, \( E \) = a valid excuse exists, and \( D \) = duty was due, then breach \( B \) holds when:

$$ B = D \land \lnot P \land \lnot E $$

Materiality Factors

1
Deprivation of benefit. How much of the expected benefit did the injured party lose?
2
Adequacy of compensation. Can money damages make the injured party whole?
3
Forfeiture to the breaching party. Will calling it material cause unfair loss to the breacher?
4
Likelihood of cure. Can the breaching party still fix the problem in time?
5
Good faith. Was the failure willful, negligent, or innocent?

Material vs. Minor

Material Breach
Defeats the essential purpose. Injured party may suspend performance, treat the contract as ended, and sue for total damages.
Minor Breach
Substantial performance was rendered. Injured party must still perform and may sue only for the loss caused by the deviation.

How to Apply It

1
Confirm a valid contract and identify each party's duties.
2
Check the duty is due: conditions satisfied and time arrived.
3
Identify the failure to perform and rule out any valid excuse.
4
Classify the breach using the materiality factors.
5
State the remedy that follows from the classification.

Example 1: Clear Failure

Facts: A contractor agrees to build a house by June 1 for $200,000. By the deadline, no foundation has been poured and the owner has paid a $50,000 deposit. The contractor offers no excuse.

Example 2: Substantial Performance

Facts: A builder completes a $300,000 home exactly to spec, except she installs a different but equivalent brand of pipe that the owner cannot see. The cost to replace it would be $20,000.

Example 3: Excuse Defeats Breach

Facts: A supplier promises 1,000 widgets by July 1. The buyer's payment, a condition precedent to shipment, never arrives. The supplier withholds the goods.

Common Mistakes

✕ Skipping "duty due"
Calling a failure a breach before confirming conditions were met and the time arrived.
✕ Ignoring excuses
Forgetting impossibility, frustration, or the other side's prior breach can excuse performance.
✕ Wrong classification
Treating a trivial deviation as material and letting your client wrongly walk away.
✕ Confusing remedy
Awarding total cancellation for a minor breach instead of limited damages.

Summary Table

Material Minor
Purpose defeated? Yes No
Other side may suspend? Yes No
Substantial performance? No Yes
Remedy Total damages Damages only

Question 1 of 5

Which combination is required for a breach to exist?

Question 2 of 5

A builder finishes a home to spec except for a trivial, hidden pipe-brand substitution. This is most likely a:

Question 3 of 5

The legal significance of classifying a breach as material is that the non-breaching party may:

Question 4 of 5

A buyer's payment is a condition precedent to a supplier's shipment, but the buyer never pays. The supplier withholds the goods. The supplier has:

Question 5 of 5

Which factor is least relevant when deciding whether a breach is material?

Putting It Together

To determine whether a breach occurred, march through the inquiry in order: duty due, failure to perform, no excuse, then classify as material or minor.