Bias and
Character Impeachment
How witnesses are challenged in court: attacking credibility through proof of bias or evidence of character for truthfulness.
What Is Impeachment?
Impeachment means attacking the credibility of a witness, so the jury gives less weight to their testimony. It does not mean removing testimony, just casting doubt on it.
Two Key Impeachment Methods
Why Bias Always Matters
The Bias Rule
Although no federal rule mentions bias by name, the Supreme Court (United States v. Abel) confirmed bias is always relevant to credibility.
The Character Rule (608 & 609)
Bad Acts vs. Convictions
Key Distinction: Bias vs. Character
How to Analyze an Impeachment
Worked Example: Bias
Defendant calls his brother to provide an alibi. On cross, the prosecutor asks: "Isn't the defendant your brother?" The defense objects.
Worked Example: Bad Act
A witness denies ever lying on a job application. The cross-examiner wants to call a former employer to prove the witness actually lied.
Worked Example: Conviction
A prosecution witness was convicted of felony fraud 6 years ago. The defense wants to use it to impeach.
Common Mistakes
Summary Table
| Bias | 608(b) Acts | 609 Convictions | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it shows | Motive to lie | Honesty trait | Honesty trait |
| Extrinsic? | Yes | No | Yes |
| Collateral? | Never | N/A | N/A |
| Balancing? | 403 | 403 | Varies |
Question 1 of 5
A witness testifies for the plaintiff. The defense shows the witness is the plaintiff's business partner. This is an example of impeachment by:
Question 2 of 5
On cross, a witness denies having shoplifted last year. May the examiner call a store clerk to prove the theft occurred?
Question 3 of 5
A witness was convicted of perjury 4 years ago. To impeach, this conviction is:
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about bias evidence is correct?
Question 5 of 5
A defendant was convicted of felony assault (not a dishonesty crime) 5 years ago. When may it impeach him?