The Best
Evidence Rule
When proving the content of a writing, recording, or photograph, the law prefers the original. Learn when an original is required and when a duplicate or other proof will do.
What Is the Best Evidence Rule?
The Best Evidence Rule (also called the Original Document Rule) governs how a party proves what a document actually says. It applies under the Federal Rules of Evidence (FRE 1001–1008).
The rule exists to guard against fraud, mistranscription, and faulty memory when the precise terms of a document are central to the case.
Key Definitions
When Does It Apply?
The Formal Rule (FRE 1002)
We can express the rule as a conditional. Let \( C \) = "proving the content of a document" and let \( O \) = "an original is required":
$$ C \implies O \quad \text{(unless an exception applies)} $$
Two Triggers for "Content"
Key Distinction: Existence vs. Content
How to Apply the Rule
When the Original Is Excused (FRE 1004)
Example 1: The Lease Terms
Facts: A landlord sues a tenant, claiming the written lease required rent of $1,200/month. To prove that term, the landlord wants the tenant to testify about the amount.
Example 2: Eyewitness vs. Photo
Facts: A witness personally saw a car run a red light. There also happens to be a traffic-camera photograph of the same event. The witness wants to testify, "The car ran the red light."
Example 3: The Lost Letter
Facts: A plaintiff seeks to prove the content of a defamatory letter. The original was accidentally destroyed in a flood. The plaintiff wants to testify about what the letter said.
Common Mistakes
Quick-Reference Summary
| Rule | Effect | |
|---|---|---|
| FRE 1002 | Original required | Need original to prove content |
| FRE 1003 | Duplicates OK | Admissible unless authenticity/fairness issue |
| FRE 1004 | Original excused | Lost, destroyed, unobtainable, or collateral |
| FRE 1005 | Public records | Certified copy suffices |
| FRE 1008 | Jury question | Jury decides disputed factual issues |
Question 1 of 5
A witness who personally watched a robbery wants to describe what she saw. A surveillance video also recorded the event. Does the Best Evidence Rule require producing the video?
Question 2 of 5
A party wants to prove the exact terms of a written contract. Under FRE 1003, a photocopy of the signed contract is offered. The opponent does not dispute its authenticity. The copy is:
Question 3 of 5
A plaintiff must prove the words of a defamatory letter. The original was innocently destroyed in a fire. May the plaintiff testify about its contents?
Question 4 of 5
Which situation does NOT trigger the Best Evidence Rule?
Question 5 of 5
A party who needed the original document deliberately shredded it to keep it from trial, then offers a copy. The likely result is: