01 / 20

Authority Types
Actual vs. Apparent

When can an agent legally bind a principal? Learn to distinguish actual authority from apparent authority in agency law.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Agency Relationship

Agency is a relationship where one person (the agent) acts on behalf of another (the principal) in dealings with a third party. The central question: when do the agent's actions legally bind the principal?

Principal (business owner) Agent (employee) Third Party (customer) grants authority deals with

Actual Authority

Actual authority exists when the agent reasonably believes, based on the principal's words or conduct, that the principal wants the agent to act. The key is the principal-to-agent communication.

Express
The principal explicitly tells the agent what to do: "Sign this contract for me."
Implied
Authority reasonably necessary to carry out express authority, or arising from custom and prior dealings.

Apparent Authority

Apparent authority exists when the third party reasonably believes the agent has authority, based on manifestations by the principal to the third party. The principal's holding-out creates the appearance.

Principal Third Party principal's manifestation ("She is my manager") Third party reasonably believes agent has authority

The Core Rule

Both forms turn on a manifestation by the principal: but the audience and the perspective differ.

Actual
Manifestation runs principal → agent. Test: did the agent reasonably believe?
Apparent
Manifestation runs principal → third party. Test: did the third party reasonably believe?

Two Directions of Manifestation

Principal Agent Third Party ACTUAL (to agent) APPARENT (to 3rd party) agent transacts with third party

The Key Distinction

ActualApparent
Whose belief matters?Agent'sThird party's
Manifestation to whom?AgentThird party
Source of powerPrincipal's instructionsPrincipal's holding-out
Binds principal?YesYes

How to Analyze a Problem

1
Identify the parties. Who is principal, agent, and third party?
2
Check actual authority. Did the principal tell the agent (expressly or impliedly) to act? Look from the agent's perspective.
3
Check apparent authority. Did the principal make a manifestation to the third party? Was the third party's belief reasonable?
4
Conclude. If either type exists, the principal is bound to the third party.

Example 1: Express Actual

Owner emails her store clerk: "Please order 50 widgets from Supplier Co. today." The clerk places the order. Supplier Co. ships them. Is Owner bound?

Example 2: Apparent Only

Owner publicly introduced Sam as her "store manager." Owner later privately told Sam not to sign leases. Unaware of this, a landlord signs a lease with Sam, relying on his manager title. Is Owner bound?

Example 3: Neither Type

A stranger walks into a shop, falsely tells a customer "I work here," and "sells" the customer a display item. The owner never said or did anything suggesting the stranger had authority. Is the owner bound?

Common Mistakes

✕ Agent self-creation
Thinking an agent's own claims create apparent authority. The manifestation must come from the principal.
✕ Wrong perspective
Using the third party's belief for actual authority. Actual = agent's belief; apparent = third party's belief.
✕ Ignoring reliance
Apparent authority requires the third party's belief to be reasonable and traceable to the principal.

Summary Table

FactorActualApparent
DirectionPrincipal → AgentPrincipal → Third Party
Reasonable belief ofAgentThird Party
SubtypesExpress / Implied(by holding-out)
Agent can self-create?NoNo
ResultPrincipal boundPrincipal bound

Question 1 of 5

For actual authority, whose reasonable belief is the legal test focused on?

Question 2 of 5

Apparent authority is created by a manifestation made to whom?

Question 3 of 5

Is the company likely bound to the $25,000 contract?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about creating apparent authority is true?

Question 5 of 5

A clerk acted under express written instructions from the owner, but the customer never knew of those instructions. Which authority did the clerk have?

Key Takeaways

1
Actual authority = agent's reasonable belief from the principal's words/conduct (express or implied).
2
Apparent authority = third party's reasonable belief from the principal's manifestation to them.
3
An agent cannot create their own apparent authority.
4
If either type exists, the principal is bound to the third party.

You're Ready to Distinguish

Ask two questions: did the principal speak to the agent (actual), and did the principal hold the agent out to the third party (apparent)? Either one binds the principal.