01 / 20

Authentication
of Evidence

Before evidence comes in, the proponent must show it is what it claims to be. Learn how to satisfy the authentication requirement.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Authentication?

Authentication is the process of showing that a piece of evidence is genuine: that the document, object, recording, or photo is what the offering party says it is.

Authentication is a condition relevance question. It is a low threshold: the proponent need not prove genuineness conclusively, only enough that a reasonable juror could find it genuine.

Why It Matters

A handwritten note saying "I'll pay you back" is irrelevant unless it actually came from the defendant. Authentication is the link between the item and the claim.

The Item a document Authentication The Claim "signed by D"

The Standard

The judge decides only whether enough evidence exists for a reasonable jury to find the item genuine. The jury makes the final call on genuineness.

1
Judge (gatekeeper): Is there evidence sufficient to support a finding of authenticity? A prima facie showing.
2
Jury (factfinder): Given all the evidence, do we actually believe it is genuine and how much weight do we give it?

Common Methods — FRE 901(b)

Witness Testimony
A witness with knowledge testifies the item is what it claims to be.
Handwriting
Lay opinion (familiar before litigation) or expert comparison.
Distinctive Features
Appearance, contents, substance, or pattern taken with circumstances.
Voice / Phone
Identifying a voice or showing how a call was placed and answered.
Public Records
Evidence the record came from the public office where such records are kept.

Self-Authenticating — FRE 902

Some items require no extrinsic evidence of authenticity. They authenticate themselves under FRE 902.

1
Public documents under seal, or certified copies of public records.
2
Official publications issued by a public authority.
3
Newspapers and periodicals, and trade inscriptions (labels, tags affixed in the course of business).
4
Acknowledged (notarized) documents and certified business records.

Chain of Custody

For evidence that is not readily identifiable (like a vial of blood or a baggie of powder), the proponent traces the item from seizure to courtroom.

Seized at scene Lab tested Court offered

Authentication vs. Other Hurdles

Authentication is separate from relevance, hearsay, and the best evidence rule. Each must be satisfied independently.

Authentication Hearsay
QuestionIs it genuine?Truth of statement?
Decided byJudge (prima facie)Judge (rule)
ThresholdCould a jury find?Exception applies?
AffectsFoundationOut-of-court use

How to Apply the Rule

1
Identify the claim. What does the proponent say the item is?
2
Check self-authenticating. Does FRE 902 apply (seal, certification, trade inscription)? If so, you are done.
3
Find a 901(b) method. Witness knowledge, distinctive characteristics, voice ID, reply doctrine, chain of custody.
4
Ask the threshold question. Could a reasonable jury find the item genuine? If yes, it is authenticated.

Worked Example 1

P offers a letter, claiming D wrote it. A coworker who saw D write countless memos before this lawsuit testifies the handwriting is D's.

Worked Example 2 — Reply Doctrine

P mailed a demand letter to D's business address. P offers a reply on D's letterhead referencing the demand by date and amount.

P sends demand to D's address reply received Reply references date & amount

Worked Example 3 — A Tricky One

The prosecution offers a printout of a text message claiming it came from the defendant's phone. The only proof is that the printout shows the defendant's name.

Common Mistakes

✕ Conflating Hurdles
Thinking authentication also defeats hearsay. They are independent objections.
✕ Demanding Certainty
Requiring proof of genuineness beyond doubt. The standard is only "could a jury find."
✕ Litigation-Only Familiarity
Using a witness who became familiar with handwriting just for trial — not allowed for lay opinion.
✕ Name = Authentic
Assuming a name on a text or email proves the sender. Need distinctive content.
✕ Chain Gaps Exclude
Thinking any custody gap bars the item. Minor gaps go to weight, not admissibility.

Summary Table

Evidence Type How to Authenticate
HandwritingLay opinion (pre-litigation) or expert comparison
Reply letter/emailReply doctrine — content shows it answers a sent message
VoiceAnyone who has heard the voice identifies it
Physical objectDistinctive features or chain of custody
Public recordSelf-authenticating under FRE 902 (seal/certification)
Notarized docSelf-authenticating — acknowledged document

Question 1 of 5

Under FRE 901(a), what must the proponent show to authenticate evidence?

Question 2 of 5

A clerk produces a court record bearing the official seal of the court. What is required to authenticate it?

Question 3 of 5

A witness studied the defendant's handwriting for the first time the week before trial, just to testify. Can she give a lay opinion authenticating the handwriting?

Question 4 of 5

How should the court treat the 30-minute custody gap?

Question 5 of 5

The prosecution offers a text message printout showing only the defendant's name as the sender, with no other proof of origin. Is it authenticated?

You've Got Authentication