01 / 20

Attempt Liability
Criminal Law

When does an unfinished crime become a punishable offense? Learn the two elements, the line-drawing tests, and the defenses that complete the picture.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is an Attempt?

An attempt is an inchoate (incomplete) crime. The defendant tries to commit a target offense but fails to complete it. The law punishes attempts because the actor has shown both dangerous intent and meaningful action toward harm.

The Two Elements

Mens Rea Specific Intent Purpose to bring about the target crime's result + Actus Reus Overt Act A substantial step beyond mere preparation = Attempt Liability

The Intent Requirement

Attempt is always a specific intent crime, even when the target offense requires a lesser mental state. The defendant must actually desire the completed result.

Key Consequence
You cannot attempt a crime that requires only recklessness or negligence (e.g., no "attempted involuntary manslaughter").
Example
Murder can be committed with reckless disregard, but attempted murder demands intent to kill specifically.

Drawing the Line

The hardest question in attempt law: when does preparation end and a punishable act begin? Two major tests answer this.

1
MPC Substantial Step Test: The act must be a substantial step strongly corroborative of criminal purpose. This is the majority modern view.
2
Proximity Test (Common Law): The act must be dangerously close to completion: the "last act" or near it.

The Spectrum of Conduct

Thought Not punishable Preparation Not yet attempt THE LINE Substantial Step Attempt begins Completion Full crime Liability attaches once conduct crosses the red line

Attempt vs. Other Inchoate Crimes

Attempt Solicitation Conspiracy
Core ActSubstantial stepAsking anotherAgreement
Need Overt Act?YesNoOften (modern)
How Many People?OneTwo partiesTwo or more
Merges?YesYesNo

How to Apply the Doctrine

1
Identify the target crime the defendant was trying to commit.
2
Confirm specific intent to complete that crime (not mere recklessness).
3
Apply the act test: Did conduct go beyond preparation? Use substantial-step (MPC) or proximity (common law).
4
Check defenses: abandonment, legal impossibility, and merger.

The Impossibility Defense

Legal Impossibility
The intended act, even if completed, would not be a crime. This is a valid defense.
Factual Impossibility
A fact unknown to the defendant prevented completion (e.g., empty pocket). This is not a defense.

The Abandonment Defense

Once the defendant has crossed the line into attempt, common law says it is too late: abandonment is no defense. The MPC allows it under narrow conditions.

Worked Example One

Facts: Dan buys a gun, drives to Vic's house, loads the weapon, and points it at Vic intending to kill. The gun jams. Is Dan liable for attempted murder?

Worked Example Two

Facts: Erin researches a store layout, buys a crowbar, and writes a robbery plan. Police arrest her at home before she ever leaves. Attempted robbery?

Worked Example Three

Facts: Frank reaches into Greg's pocket to steal a wallet. The pocket is empty. Frank argues he could not have stolen anything. Result?

Common Mistakes

✕ Allowing Reckless Attempts
Attempt always needs specific intent. There is no "attempted involuntary manslaughter."
✕ Accepting Factual Impossibility
Empty pockets and unloaded guns do not excuse an attempt. Only legal impossibility defends.
✕ Convicting for Both
Attempt merges into the completed crime. You cannot punish both for the same conduct.

Attempt at a Glance

Issue Common Law MPC
Mental StateSpecific intentPurpose / belief
Act TestProximity (last act)Substantial step
AbandonmentNo defenseDefense if voluntary & complete
Factual ImpossibilityNo defenseNo defense
Legal ImpossibilityDefenseGenerally no defense

Question 1 of 5

Which mental state does attempt liability always require?

Question 2 of 5

A defendant fires at a victim who, unknown to him, had already died of a heart attack moments earlier. What is the result?

Question 3 of 5

Under the common law, when does a defendant cross the line into attempt?

Question 4 of 5

A defendant is convicted of attempted robbery, then completes the robbery moments later. How does the law treat the attempt charge?

Question 5 of 5

Under the MPC, abandonment is a valid defense to attempt only if the renunciation is: