01 / 20

Assignment & Sublease

Two ways a tenant can transfer their leasehold interest, and why the difference changes who owes what to whom.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Players in a Lease Transfer

A lease creates two relationships: privity of contract (the lease promises) and privity of estate (current possession of the land). When a tenant transfers their interest, the key question is: which relationships move, and which stay?

Landlord (L) Tenant (T) Privity of Estate Privity of Contract

What Is an Assignment?

An assignment transfers the tenant's entire remaining interest in the lease. The original tenant keeps nothing; the assignee steps into the tenant's shoes for the whole rest of the term.

Full Transfer
All remaining time is conveyed, with no reversion kept back by the tenant.
Estate Moves
Privity of estate now runs between landlord and assignee.

What Is a Sublease?

A sublease transfers less than the entire remaining interest. The tenant keeps a reversion: the right to retake possession before the original lease ends, even if just by one day.

Partial Transfer
Tenant retains some portion of the term, or a right to reenter.
Tenant Stays In
The original tenant becomes the sublessee's landlord.

The Governing Rule

The label the parties use does not control. Courts classify the transfer by how much of the term is transferred:

1
Entire remaining term transferred → it is an assignment, regardless of what the document says.
2
Anything less than the full term (tenant keeps a reversion) → it is a sublease.

Who Has Privity After Transfer?

ASSIGNMENT Landlord Assignee Estate L & T keep contract (original lease) SUBLEASE Landlord Tenant Sublessee new lease L deals only with T

Who Owes the Rent?

Assignment
Assignee is liable to L on privity of estate. Original T remains liable on privity of contract unless released by novation.
Sublease
Sublessee owes only the original T. The L cannot reach the sublessee for rent absent assumption.

The Critical Distinction

Everything turns on one fact: did the tenant keep a reversion? Use this test on every fact pattern.

Transfer starts Lease ends Transfers to end = ASSIGNMENT Stops short = SUBLEASE (reversion kept)

How to Apply It

1
Identify the original lease term. When does it end?
2
Identify the transferred period. When does the transfer end?
3
Compare. Transfer runs to the lease's end → assignment. Transfer stops short → sublease.
4
Check for a right of reentry. A retained power to retake on breach also signals a sublease in many jurisdictions.
5
Apply liability rules based on the classification.

Worked Example 1

T has a 5-year lease with 3 years left. T transfers all 3 remaining years to A. Assignment or sublease?

Now Lease ends Transfer covers all 3 years

Worked Example 2

T has 3 years left and transfers 2 years and 11 months to S, keeping the final month. Assignment or sublease?

Now Lease ends Transfer stops short kept

Worked Example 3

T transfers all remaining time to X but reserves a right to reenter if X fails to pay. The document is titled "Sublease." How is it classified?

Do the Covenants Run?

After an assignment, lease covenants bind the assignee only if they run with the land: they must touch and concern the land and the parties must have intended them to run.

Run With Land
Rent, repairs, taxes, insurance bind the assignee while in privity of estate.
Personal
Promises that don't touch and concern (e.g., a personal service) do not bind the assignee.

Common Mistakes

✕ Trusting the label
A document titled "Sublease" can be an assignment. Classify by what is transferred, not the heading.
✕ Forgetting tenant liability
The original tenant stays liable on the contract after either transfer unless released by the landlord.
✕ Suing the wrong party
A landlord cannot sue a sublessee for rent: there is no privity. That only works against an assignee.
✕ Ignoring the reversion
Even one retained day makes it a sublease. Always compare the transfer's end to the lease's end.

Side-by-Side Summary

Assignment Sublease
Interest transferredEntire remaining termLess than full term
Reversion keptNoYes
Privity of estate (L–transferee)YesNo
L can sue transferee for rentYesNo
Original tenant still liableYes (contract)Yes (contract)

Question 1 of 5

T has 4 years remaining and transfers all 4 years to A, keeping nothing. This is best classified as:

Question 2 of 5

A document is titled "Assignment," but T retains the last 6 months of the term. How is it classified?

Question 3 of 5

After a valid sublease, the original landlord wants unpaid rent. Whom can the landlord sue directly?

Question 4 of 5

After a valid assignment with no release, which statement is most accurate?

Question 5 of 5

Under the majority view, T transfers the entire remaining term but reserves only a right of reentry on breach. This is: