01 / 20
=

Analogical
Case Analysis

Compare the facts of a precedent to the facts before you to decide whether the prior case is analogous or distinguishable.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

Reasoning by Analogy

Common-law reasoning runs on precedent. When a prior case shares the legally significant facts of your case, its holding governs. Your job is to test that overlap.

Three Key Terms

Holding
The legal rule the court applied to the material facts to reach its result.
Analogous
The precedent's material facts match yours closely enough that its rule applies.
Distinguishable
A material fact differs, so the precedent's rule should not control.

Matching Material Facts

Precedent Material facts A · B · C Holding Rule R applies Your Case Material facts A · B · C Conclusion Rule R applies? ≅

The Analogical Test

We can frame the overlap as a similarity score. Let \( M_p \) be the set of material facts in the precedent and \( M_c \) the material facts in your case:

$$ S = \frac{|M_p \cap M_c|}{|M_p \cup M_c|} $$

When \( S \) is high and the differences are immaterial, the precedent controls. When a single difference is outcome-determinative, the case is distinguishable even if \( S \) is otherwise large.

Material vs. Immaterial

Not every factual difference defeats an analogy. The threshold question: would this difference have changed the court's reasoning?

Material Difference
Goes to a fact the court relied on to apply the rule. Example: contract vs. tort, employee vs. independent contractor.
Immaterial Difference
Background detail with no legal weight. Example: the parties' names, the city, the time of day.

A Step-by-Step Method

1
State the precedent's rule. Identify the holding and the facts that triggered it.
2
List your material facts. Strip away background detail.
3
Compare fact by fact. Note overlaps and differences.
4
Test each difference. Is it outcome-determinative or trivial?
5
Conclude. Analogous (precedent controls) or distinguishable (it does not).

Example 1: Analogous

Precedent: A store left a freshly mopped floor with no warning sign; a shopper slipped. Court held the store breached its duty of care.

Your case: A grocery left a spilled-juice puddle with no sign; a customer slipped.

Example 2: Distinguishable

Precedent: A landlord was liable for a tenant's injury from a defect in a common stairway the landlord controlled.

Your case: A tenant is injured by a defect inside her own leased unit, an area the lease places under the tenant's control.

Example 3: Close Call

Precedent ✓ Promise made ✓ Reliance ✓ Detriment Enforced Your Case ✓ Promise made ✓ Reliance ✕ No detriment Not enforced?

Common Mistakes

✕ Counting noise
Treating immaterial details (names, dates) as if they break or build an analogy.
✕ Surface matching
Comparing facts without asking why the court relied on them.
✕ Ignoring policy
Forgetting that the reasons behind the holding must also apply.
✕ One-sided analysis
Arguing only similarities or only differences, never both.

Analogous vs. Distinguishable

AnalogousDistinguishable
Material factsMatch the precedentDiffer in a key fact
DifferencesImmaterial onlyOutcome-determinative
Policy reasonsApply equallyPull the other way
EffectPrecedent controlsPrecedent does not apply
Your argumentRule should followCourt should depart

Putting It Together

Question 1 of 5

Which factual difference would most likely make a precedent distinguishable?

Question 2 of 5

How should you treat the precedent?

Question 3 of 5

In the similarity measure \( S = \dfrac{|M_p \cap M_c|}{|M_p \cup M_c|} \), a high value of \( S \) guarantees the precedent controls.

Question 4 of 5

What is the best characterization?

Question 5 of 5

A complete analogical analysis on the exam should:

You Can Now Reason by Analogy

You can isolate material facts, map them onto a precedent, test each difference for legal weight, and reach a defensible conclusion.

Session Complete

Apply the analogical method to every precedent you encounter on the Uniform Bar Exam.