Analogical
Case Analysis
Compare the facts of a precedent to the facts before you to decide whether the prior case is analogous or distinguishable.
Reasoning by Analogy
Common-law reasoning runs on precedent. When a prior case shares the legally significant facts of your case, its holding governs. Your job is to test that overlap.
Three Key Terms
Matching Material Facts
The Analogical Test
We can frame the overlap as a similarity score. Let \( M_p \) be the set of material facts in the precedent and \( M_c \) the material facts in your case:
$$ S = \frac{|M_p \cap M_c|}{|M_p \cup M_c|} $$
When \( S \) is high and the differences are immaterial, the precedent controls. When a single difference is outcome-determinative, the case is distinguishable even if \( S \) is otherwise large.
Material vs. Immaterial
Not every factual difference defeats an analogy. The threshold question: would this difference have changed the court's reasoning?
A Step-by-Step Method
Example 1: Analogous
Precedent: A store left a freshly mopped floor with no warning sign; a shopper slipped. Court held the store breached its duty of care.
Your case: A grocery left a spilled-juice puddle with no sign; a customer slipped.
Example 2: Distinguishable
Precedent: A landlord was liable for a tenant's injury from a defect in a common stairway the landlord controlled.
Your case: A tenant is injured by a defect inside her own leased unit, an area the lease places under the tenant's control.
Example 3: Close Call
Common Mistakes
Analogous vs. Distinguishable
| Analogous | Distinguishable | |
|---|---|---|
| Material facts | Match the precedent | Differ in a key fact |
| Differences | Immaterial only | Outcome-determinative |
| Policy reasons | Apply equally | Pull the other way |
| Effect | Precedent controls | Precedent does not apply |
| Your argument | Rule should follow | Court should depart |
Putting It Together
Question 1 of 5
Which factual difference would most likely make a precedent distinguishable?
Question 2 of 5
Precedent: A retailer was liable when a customer slipped on an unmarked wet floor in the store.
Your case: A different customer slips on an unmarked spill in the same type of store. The facts of invitee status, known hazard, and lack of warning all match.
How should you treat the precedent?
Question 3 of 5
In the similarity measure \( S = \dfrac{|M_p \cap M_c|}{|M_p \cup M_c|} \), a high value of \( S \) guarantees the precedent controls.
Question 4 of 5
Precedent: A landlord was liable for an injury caused by a defect in a common stairway the landlord controlled and maintained.
Your case: A tenant is injured by a defect located entirely inside her leased apartment, an area the lease assigns to the tenant's exclusive control.
What is the best characterization?
Question 5 of 5
A complete analogical analysis on the exam should:
You Can Now Reason by Analogy
You can isolate material facts, map them onto a precedent, test each difference for legal weight, and reach a defensible conclusion.
Session Complete
Apply the analogical method to every precedent you encounter on the Uniform Bar Exam.