Agency
Formation
When does one person legally act on behalf of another? Learn how an agency relationship is created and how to spot it on the bar exam.
What Is an Agency Relationship?
An agency relationship is a fiduciary relationship that arises when one person (the principal) manifests assent that another person (the agent) shall act on the principal's behalf and subject to the principal's control, and the agent consents to act.
The Two Parties
Why Formation Matters
The Core Formation Rule
Agency is formed when all three elements are satisfied. We can express the test as a logical conjunction:
No written contract or payment is required. The relationship may be created informally, even gratuitously.
The Three Elements (ABC)
Capacity to Form Agency
Agent vs. Independent Contractor
The decisive factor is control. If the principal controls only the result, the worker is likely an independent contractor. If the principal controls the manner and means, an agency exists.
| Agent / Employee | Independent Contractor | |
|---|---|---|
| Control over work | Manner & method | Result only |
| Tools supplied by | Principal | Worker |
| Skill required | Often lower | Often specialized |
| Vicarious liability | Yes (usually) | No (usually) |
How to Apply the Test
Worked Example One
Facts: Olivia asks her friend Ben to sell her bicycle and tells him exactly how to advertise it and what price to accept. Ben agrees and lists it. No money changes hands.
Worked Example Two
Facts: A homeowner hires a licensed plumber to fix a leak. The homeowner does not direct how the plumber does the job, only that the leak be repaired by Friday.
Worked Example Three
Facts: A 15-year-old "hires" a neighbor to manage and sign contracts for his lawn business. The neighbor agrees and works under the teen's direction.
Common Mistakes
Formation Checklist
| Element | Question to Ask | Required? |
|---|---|---|
| Assent | Did both parties agree? | Yes |
| Benefit | For the principal's benefit? | Yes |
| Control | Right to control manner? | Yes |
| Capacity | Does principal have it? | Yes |
| Writing | Is a document required? | No |
| Payment | Is compensation needed? | No |
Question 1 of 5
Which three elements must all be satisfied to form an agency relationship?
Question 2 of 5
A friend agrees, without any payment, to drive your packages to the post office under your specific instructions. Is an agency formed?
Question 3 of 5
What is the single most decisive factor distinguishing an agent/employee from an independent contractor?
Question 4 of 5
A mentally incompetent adult "appoints" a neighbor to manage all of his financial contracts. The neighbor agrees and acts under his direction. What is the likely result?
Question 5 of 5
Facts: A homeowner hires a roofing company to replace her roof. The contract states the company will use its own crew, supply its own tools, complete the work by a set date, and decide all methods of installation. The homeowner only inspects the finished result.
Is the roofing company an agent of the homeowner?