01 / 20

Admissibility
Analysis

Apply the full evidence framework: determine whether a piece of evidence is relevant, competent, and survives every exclusionary rule.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

What Is Admissibility?

Evidence is admissible only if a court may properly receive and consider it. Every item must clear a sequence of gates before reaching the factfinder.

Step One: Relevance

Under FRE 401, evidence is relevant if it has any tendency to make a fact of consequence more or less probable. This is a very low bar.

Probative Value
Does it move the needle on a material fact, even slightly?
Materiality
Is the fact actually at issue under the substantive law?

The Admissibility Pipeline

Relevant? FRE 401-402 Competent? Form / Hearsay FRE 403? Balance Admit Exclude

Core Rule: The FRE 403 Balance

Even relevant, competent evidence may be excluded when its dangers substantially outweigh its probative value.

The Balancing Scale

Probative \( P \) Prejudice \( D \) Admit when \( P \geq D \)

Relevance vs. Competence

Relevance
Logical: does the evidence relate to a fact in dispute? Governed by FRE 401-403.
Competence
Legal: is the form or source proper? Covers hearsay, privilege, authentication, and best evidence.

How to Apply the Framework

1
Identify the evidence. What is being offered, by whom, and for what purpose?
2
Test relevance. Apply FRE 401-402: does it make a material fact more or less probable?
3
Check exclusionary rules. Hearsay, privilege, character, authentication, best evidence.
4
Run FRE 403. Does unfair prejudice substantially outweigh probative value?
5
Conclude. Admit, exclude, or admit for a limited purpose with an instruction.

Worked Example 1

In a negligence case, plaintiff offers a photo of the icy stairs taken the morning of her fall. Defendant objects.

Worked Example 2

In an assault trial, the prosecution offers a graphic autopsy photo. The cause of death is already stipulated.

Worked Example 3

A witness testifies, "My neighbor told me the driver ran the red light." Offered to prove the driver ran the light.

Common Mistakes

✕ Stopping at relevance
Relevance is necessary but not sufficient — always continue to exclusionary rules and FRE 403.
✕ Wrong 403 standard
Prejudice must be unfair and substantially outweigh value, not merely outweigh it.
✕ Ignoring purpose
Evidence may be inadmissible for one purpose yet admissible for another with a limiting instruction.

Framework Summary

QuestionAuthority
Step 1Is it relevant?FRE 401-402
Step 2Is the form proper?Hearsay / Best Evidence
Step 3Is it privileged or barred?Privilege / Character
Step 4Does \( D \gg P \)?FRE 403
Step 5Admit or exclude?Court ruling

Before the Questions

Now apply the full framework to five scenarios.

Question 1 of 5

Under FRE 401, evidence is relevant if it has any tendency to make a fact of consequence more or less probable. This standard is best described as:

Question 2 of 5

For exclusion under FRE 403, unfair prejudice must:

Question 3 of 5

How should the court most likely rule?

Question 4 of 5

The strongest objection is that:

Question 5 of 5

Which sequence correctly orders the admissibility framework?

Framework Mastered