Admissibility
Analysis
Apply the full evidence framework: determine whether a piece of evidence is relevant, competent, and survives every exclusionary rule.
What Is Admissibility?
Evidence is admissible only if a court may properly receive and consider it. Every item must clear a sequence of gates before reaching the factfinder.
Step One: Relevance
Under FRE 401, evidence is relevant if it has any tendency to make a fact of consequence more or less probable. This is a very low bar.
The Admissibility Pipeline
Core Rule: The FRE 403 Balance
Even relevant, competent evidence may be excluded when its dangers substantially outweigh its probative value.
The Balancing Scale
Relevance vs. Competence
How to Apply the Framework
Worked Example 1
In a negligence case, plaintiff offers a photo of the icy stairs taken the morning of her fall. Defendant objects.
Worked Example 2
In an assault trial, the prosecution offers a graphic autopsy photo. The cause of death is already stipulated.
Worked Example 3
A witness testifies, "My neighbor told me the driver ran the red light." Offered to prove the driver ran the light.
Common Mistakes
Framework Summary
| Question | Authority | |
|---|---|---|
| Step 1 | Is it relevant? | FRE 401-402 |
| Step 2 | Is the form proper? | Hearsay / Best Evidence |
| Step 3 | Is it privileged or barred? | Privilege / Character |
| Step 4 | Does \( D \gg P \)? | FRE 403 |
| Step 5 | Admit or exclude? | Court ruling |
Before the Questions
Now apply the full framework to five scenarios.
Question 1 of 5
Under FRE 401, evidence is relevant if it has any tendency to make a fact of consequence more or less probable. This standard is best described as:
Question 2 of 5
For exclusion under FRE 403, unfair prejudice must:
Question 3 of 5
A witness testifies: "My neighbor told me she saw the defendant leaving the bank at 3 p.m."
The statement is offered to prove the defendant was at the bank at 3 p.m. No hearsay exception applies, and the neighbor is not testifying.
How should the court most likely rule?
Question 4 of 5
The cause of death in a homicide trial is stipulated. The prosecution nonetheless offers extremely graphic autopsy photographs.
The photos add little to the undisputed cause of death but risk inflaming the jury.
The strongest objection is that:
Question 5 of 5
Which sequence correctly orders the admissibility framework?