Administrative
Authority
How agencies get power, exercise it, and the limits the law places on them. Learn to analyze agency authority like a bar examinee.
What Is an Agency?
An administrative agency is a governmental body created by the legislature to carry out specific tasks: regulating industries, distributing benefits, or enforcing statutes. Examples include the EPA, SEC, and the IRS.
The Enabling Statute
An agency's powers flow from its enabling statute (also called an "organic act"). This is the legislature's grant of authority. The first question in any analysis is always: Did Congress authorize this action?
Express vs. Implied Authority
The Nondelegation Doctrine
Congress may delegate legislative power to agencies, but the statute must contain an "intelligible principle" to guide the agency's discretion. This is the formal rule that legitimizes delegated lawmaking.
Judicial Review of Interpretation
When an agency interprets the statute it administers, courts decide whether to defer. Under recent law (Loper Bright, 2024), courts no longer automatically defer to agencies; they exercise independent judgment on questions of law.
Rulemaking vs. Adjudication
Notice-and-Comment Rulemaking
How to Analyze Agency Authority
Worked Example One
Facts: A statute empowers the Clean Air Agency to "set standards limiting air pollutants." The agency issues a rule capping factory emissions.
Worked Example Two
Facts: The same statute is silent on inspections. The agency conducts unannounced facility inspections to verify emissions data.
Worked Example Three
Facts: The Clean Air Agency issues a rule requiring all factories to also reduce employee carbon footprints at home, citing general "public welfare."
Common Mistakes
Authority Summary
| Question | Source | |
|---|---|---|
| Power exists? | Express or implied? | Enabling statute |
| Delegation valid? | Intelligible principle? | Constitution |
| Procedure proper? | Notice-and-comment? | APA / statute |
| Interpretation correct? | Best reading of law? | Courts (Loper Bright) |
| Action reasonable? | Arbitrary or capricious? | Judicial review |
Question 1 of 5
An administrative agency's power to act ultimately derives from:
Question 2 of 5
For a delegation of legislative power to an agency to be constitutional, the statute must contain:
Question 3 of 5
An agency adopts a substantively reasonable rule but never published a notice or accepted public comment. The rule is most likely:
Question 4 of 5
A statute lets an agency "license radio broadcasters." The agency, with no statutory basis, also begins regulating internet streaming services. This action is best described as:
Question 5 of 5
Under Loper Bright (2024), when a court reviews an agency's interpretation of an ambiguous statute it administers, the court should: