Actual Cause
The But-For Test
Before a defendant can be liable, the plaintiff must show the defendant's conduct was a factual cause of the harm: but for the conduct, would the injury have occurred?
Two Halves of Causation
In any negligence claim, a plaintiff must prove the defendant's conduct caused the harm. Courts split this into two distinct questions that must both be satisfied.
Defining the But-For Test
The classic formulation asks a counterfactual question. We mentally remove the defendant's conduct and ask whether the harm still happens.
Stated logically, if we let \(C\) be the conduct and \(H\) be the harm, actual cause exists when:
$$ \neg C \implies \neg H $$
Visualizing the Counterfactual
The Formal Statement
When But-For Breaks Down
The but-for test fails in cases of multiple sufficient causes: two independent forces each capable of causing the entire harm.
The Substantial Factor Backup
When the but-for test produces an absurd result (multiple sufficient causes), courts switch to the substantial factor test.
Actual vs. Proximate Cause
| Actual Cause | Proximate Cause | |
|---|---|---|
| Question asked | Did it in fact cause harm? | Is liability fair & foreseeable? |
| Primary test | But-for test | Foreseeability / scope of risk |
| Nature | Factual | Policy / legal |
| Limits liability for | Causally unrelated harms | Remote & unforeseeable harms |
How to Apply It on an Exam
Example 1: Simple Cause
A driver runs a red light and strikes a pedestrian who was lawfully crossing. The pedestrian breaks a leg. Is running the light the actual cause?
Example 2: Harm Would Happen Anyway
A lifeguard negligently fails to throw a rope to a drowning swimmer. Evidence shows the swimmer was already dead from a heart attack before falling in. Is the failure the actual cause of death?
Example 3: Two Sufficient Causes
Two factories independently dump enough pollutant into a stream to kill the plaintiff's livestock. Either discharge alone would have killed the herd. Is Factory 1 an actual cause?
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Scenario | Test to Use | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Single negligent cause | But-for | Cause if harm vanishes |
| Harm would occur anyway | But-for | Not a cause |
| Two sufficient causes | Substantial factor | Both are causes |
| Indivisible joint harm | Substantial factor | Joint liability |
Question 1 of 5
Which question does the but-for test answer?
Question 2 of 5
A homeowner negligently leaves a gas valve open. That same night, before any ignition source could reach the gas, a powerful earthquake collapses the house entirely, killing the resident. Expert testimony establishes the resident would have died in the collapse regardless of the gas.
Is leaving the valve open the actual cause of the death?
Question 3 of 5
When two independent fires, each sufficient to destroy a house, merge and burn it down, which test do courts apply?
Question 4 of 5
The logical statement \(\neg C \implies \neg H\) best expresses which idea?
Question 5 of 5
A doctor negligently misreads an X-ray and fails to diagnose a tumor. At trial, the plaintiff's own expert concedes that even with immediate, correct diagnosis and treatment, the tumor was so advanced that the patient would have died at the same time anyway.
Can the plaintiff establish actual cause of the death?