The Act Requirement
Actus Reus
Every crime needs a voluntary act (or qualifying omission). Learn how to test whether the actus reus is satisfied.
What Is Actus Reus?
Actus reus is the "guilty act" — the physical component of a crime. A defendant cannot be punished for mere thoughts or status. The law demands an outward, blameworthy conduct element.
The Two Pillars of a Crime
The Voluntary Act Element
The default actus reus is a voluntary act — a bodily movement performed by conscious, willed effort. Some movements are NOT voluntary and cannot ground criminal liability.
Liability for an Omission
A failure to act can satisfy actus reus, but only when a legal duty to act exists. There is generally no duty to rescue a stranger.
The Core Rule
We can express the test as a logical conjunction. Liability for the act element requires the conduct condition and a causal link:
$$ \text{Actus Reus} = (\text{Voluntary Act} \lor \text{Duty-Breach}) \land \text{Causation} $$
Causation: Linking Act to Result
Act vs. Status
A crucial distinction: the law may punish what you do, but generally not who you are. Punishing a mere status (like being an addict) is unconstitutional.
| Voluntary Act | Mere Status | |
|---|---|---|
| Example | Using a drug | Being an addict |
| Conduct? | Willed bodily movement | A condition, not an act |
| Punishable? | Yes | No |
How to Test the Act Element
Worked Example 1
Dana suffers an unexpected epileptic seizure while driving and loses control of the car, injuring a pedestrian. Is the actus reus for battery satisfied?
Worked Example 2
A lifeguard on duty watches a swimmer drown and does nothing, though a rescue was easily possible. Is the actus reus satisfied?
Worked Example 3
Carl shoves Ben, who stumbles into a stranger. Charged with battery on the stranger, Ben argues he did not commit a voluntary act. Is the actus reus satisfied as to Ben?
Common Mistakes
Quick Reference
| Scenario | Actus Reus? | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Willed punch | Yes | Voluntary act |
| Seizure / reflex | No | Involuntary movement |
| Sleepwalking act | No | Unconscious |
| Parent ignores starving child | Yes | Duty + ability + failure |
| Stranger ignores victim | No | No legal duty |
| Being an addict | No | Status, not an act |
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following is required for the actus reus of most crimes?
Question 2 of 5
A person strikes another while having a documented seizure. Is the act element satisfied for that movement?
Question 3 of 5
A passerby sees a stranger fall into a shallow pond and begin to struggle. The passerby could easily pull the person out at no risk but chooses to keep walking, and the stranger drowns. The passerby had no relationship to the victim and did nothing to create the danger.
Is the passerby's failure to act an actus reus?
Question 4 of 5
A statute makes "being addicted to narcotics" a crime. Why does this fail the act requirement?
Question 5 of 5
An off-duty babysitter agreed to watch a toddler for the afternoon. The babysitter saw the child wander toward an open stairwell and, although fully able to step in, deliberately did nothing. The child fell and was seriously hurt.
Is the act element of the offense satisfied?