01 / 20

Accomplice
Liability

When does helping a crime make you the criminal? Learn who counts as an accomplice and how far their liability reaches.

Bar Exam

What Is an Accomplice?

An accomplice is a person who, with the intent that a crime be committed, aids, counsels, or encourages the principal before or during the commission of the offense.

The Parties to a Crime

Principal
The person who actually commits the crime, or who acts through an innocent agent.
Accomplice
One who aids or encourages with intent the crime be committed, before or during the act.
Accessory After
One who helps the felon escape after the crime. NOT an accomplice.

Who Is In and Who Is Out

The Crime Commission Before / During = ACCOMPLICE After = Accessory After Fact Timing of help determines liability

The Core Two-Part Test

1
Act (Actus Reus): The defendant aided, abetted, counseled, encouraged, or facilitated the principal's commission of the crime.
2
Mental State (Mens Rea): The defendant acted with the intent to assist AND the intent that the principal commit the crime: a dual intent.

The Dual Intent Requirement

The majority rule requires that the accomplice purposely act to bring about the crime. Mere knowledge that the principal might commit a crime is usually not enough.

Accomplice vs. Conspirator

Accomplice
Liable for the target crime and crimes that are a natural and probable result of aiding.
Conspirator
Liable for the conspiracy AND, under Pinkerton, all foreseeable crimes committed in furtherance of it.

How Far Does Liability Reach?

An accomplice is liable for the intended crime and for any other crime that is a natural and probable consequence of the conduct they aided.

How to Apply the Rule

1
Identify the principal and the underlying crime committed.
2
Did the defendant aid or encourage? Even slight assistance counts.
3
Check dual intent: did they intend to help AND intend the crime occur?
4
Determine scope: include foreseeable, natural-and-probable crimes.
5
Check defenses: effective withdrawal before the crime occurs.

The Withdrawal Defense

An accomplice may escape liability by withdrawing before the crime is committed: but it must be effective.

Encouraged Only
Must repudiate the encouragement and communicate it before the crime.
Provided Aid
Must neutralize the assistance: e.g. retrieve the weapon, or notify police.

Worked Example 1

Facts: Dana hands her friend Ron a crowbar, knowing and intending that Ron will break into a warehouse to steal goods. Ron commits the burglary. Dana stays home.

Worked Example 2

Facts: A hardware-store clerk sells a hammer to a customer who casually mentions he "might smash a window." The customer later commits vandalism.

Worked Example 3

Facts: Mara drives the getaway car for an armed robbery, intending to help. During the robbery, her co-conspirator unexpectedly shoots and kills a teller.

Common Mistakes

✕ Knowledge = Intent
Assuming mere knowledge that aid will be used for a crime suffices. The majority rule requires intent.
✕ Presence Required
Thinking the accomplice must be at the scene. Aid given beforehand is enough.
✕ After-the-Fact
Treating someone who only helps escape afterward as an accomplice. They are an accessory after the fact.

Summary Comparison

Accomplice Accessory After
TimingBefore / duringAfter completion
Mens ReaDual intentIntent to aid felon
Liable forSame crimeSeparate, lesser offense
PresenceNot requiredNot required
ScopeNatural & probable crimesOnly the cover-up

Question 1 of 5

What is the mens rea generally required for accomplice liability under the majority rule?

Question 2 of 5

A person who helps a felon escape after the crime is committed is best classified as:

Question 3 of 5

Dave hands a friend a gun, intending the friend rob a bank. During the robbery the friend shoots a guard. For what is Dave liable?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement about an effective withdrawal by an accomplice is correct?

Question 5 of 5

A store clerk sells a common knife to a buyer who mutters he "might hurt someone." Under the majority rule, is the clerk an accomplice to the later assault?