01 / 20

Acceptance Rules
Forming the Contract

When an offer becomes a binding deal: the rules of acceptance, rejection, and revocation.

Bar Exam (Uniform)

The Four Key Terms

Contract formation turns on the life of an offer. From the moment an offer is made, certain events can either lock it in or kill it. Mastering these four terms is the foundation.

Offer
A manifestation of willingness to enter a bargain, made so the other party knows assent will conclude the deal.
Acceptance
The offeree's manifestation of assent to the terms of the offer, creating a binding contract.
Rejection
The offeree's refusal of the offer, which terminates the power to accept.
Revocation
The offeror's withdrawal of the offer before it has been accepted.

The Power of Acceptance

An offer creates a power of acceptance in the offeree. The offeree holds the key: only the offeree can turn the offer into a contract by accepting. That power lasts until something ends it.

Offeror makes offer Offeree holds power OFFER ACCEPTANCE = contract

Ending the Power to Accept

The power of acceptance does not last forever. It can be terminated in several ways — and once terminated, an attempted acceptance is too late.

1
Rejection or counteroffer by the offeree.
2
Revocation by the offeror before acceptance.
3
Lapse of time — the stated period, or a reasonable time, expires.
4
Death or incapacity of either party before acceptance.

Two Governing Rules

Mirror Image Rule
(Common law) Acceptance must match the offer exactly. Any change in terms is a counteroffer, not an acceptance.
Mailbox Rule
Acceptance is effective the moment it is dispatched (mailed), even if it never arrives.

The Mailbox Rule Timeline

Offer made Acceptance DISPATCHED Contract forms here Acceptance RECEIVED Acceptance effective on dispatch → contract already exists before receipt

Counteroffer vs. Mere Inquiry

Not every response that mentions terms is a rejection. The key distinction: does the offeree change the terms, or simply ask a question?

CounterofferMere Inquiry
Effect on offerTerminates itKeeps it alive
NatureProposes new termsAsks if terms could change
Example"I'll pay $90, not $100.""Would you take $90?"
Can still accept?NoYes

A Step-by-Step Approach

1
Identify the offer. Was there a clear manifestation of willingness to be bound?
2
Check if the power survives. Any rejection, revocation, lapse, or death?
3
Test the acceptance. Did it match the offer (mirror image) and use a proper method?
4
Apply timing rules. Acceptance on dispatch; rejection/revocation on receipt.

Example 1: Simple Acceptance

Facts: On Monday, Seller offers to sell a car for $5,000. On Tuesday, Buyer mails a letter saying "I accept your offer for $5,000." The letter arrives Thursday.

Mon: Offer Tue: Mailed CONTRACT Thu: Arrives

Example 2: Revocation Race

Facts: Seller offers Monday. On Wednesday at 9 AM, Buyer mails acceptance. On Wednesday at 2 PM, Buyer receives Seller's revocation (mailed Tuesday). Is there a contract?

Wed 9AM Acceptance mailed CONTRACT FORMS Wed 2PM Revocation received

Example 3: Counteroffer

Facts: Seller offers a painting for $1,000. Buyer replies, "I'll give you $800." Seller refuses. Buyer then says, "Fine, I accept your $1,000 offer." Is there a contract?

Offer $1000 "$800" COUNTEROFFER Offer terminated "I accept" Too late

Common Mistakes

✕ Revocation on dispatch
Revocation is effective on receipt, NOT when mailed. Only acceptance uses dispatch.
✕ Counteroffer = acceptance
A change in terms is a rejection plus a new offer, never an acceptance.
✕ Reviving a dead offer
Once rejected or lapsed, an offer cannot be accepted later without being re-made.
✕ Ignoring option contracts
An offer held open by consideration (an option) cannot be revoked during its term.

Timing Rules Summary

EventEffective WhenWho Acts
AcceptanceOn dispatch (mailbox)Offeree
RejectionOn receiptOfferee
CounterofferOn receiptOfferee
RevocationOn receiptOfferor
LapseEnd of stated/reasonable time—

Question 1 of 5

Under the mailbox rule, when is an acceptance generally effective?

Question 2 of 5

An offeree replies, "I'll take it, but only if you lower the price to $90." This is best classified as a:

Question 3 of 5

A revocation is effective when:

Question 4 of 5

Buyer mails an acceptance at 10 AM. Seller's revocation reaches Buyer at 11 AM. What is the result?

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following does NOT terminate the offeree's power of acceptance?

Key Takeaways

1
Acceptance is effective on dispatch (mailbox rule).
2
Rejection, counteroffer, and revocation are effective on receipt.
3
A counteroffer kills the original offer; a mere inquiry does not.
4
Order the events on a timeline and apply the correct timing rule to each.

You've Mastered
Acceptance Rules

You can now apply the rules of acceptance, rejection, and revocation to determine whether a binding contract was formed.