01 / 21

The Red Scare
in America

Explore how fear of communism shaped American politics, civil liberties, and society across two distinct waves of anti-radical hysteria.

AP U.S. History

What Was the Red Scare?

The Red Scare refers to periods of intense anti-communist suspicion in the United States. The term "Red" comes from the red flag associated with communism and socialism. During these periods, the federal government, media, and public became consumed by fear that radical leftist ideologies threatened American democracy.

Essential Vocabulary

Communism
Political ideology advocating collective ownership of production and a classless society
Sedition
Conduct or speech inciting rebellion against the authority of the state
Blacklist
A list of persons who are disapproved of and punished by exclusion from employment
McCarthyism
Making accusations of treason without proper evidence, named after Senator Joseph McCarthy
HUAC
House Un-American Activities Committee: investigated alleged communist influence in U.S. institutions

Why Does the Red Scare Matter?

The Red Scare is a defining case study in how fear can override civil liberties in a democracy. It reveals recurring tensions in American history between national security and individual rights—tensions that resurfaced after 9/11 and continue today.

1
Constitutional precedent: Established key First Amendment case law (Schenck v. United States, 1919)
2
Political culture: Anti-communism became a litmus test for patriotism in American politics for decades
3
AP Exam relevance: Connects to themes of American identity, politics and power, and social structures

The First Red Scare (1919–1920)

1917
Russian Revolution
Bolsheviks seize power in Russia, sparking global fear of communist revolution
1919
Anarchist Bombings
Mail bombs sent to 36 prominent Americans; bomb detonates at Attorney General Palmer's home
1919
Major Strikes
Seattle General Strike and Boston Police Strike blamed on radical agitation
1919–20
Palmer Raids
Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer orders mass arrests of suspected radicals; thousands detained
1920
Backlash and Decline
Public opinion turns against Palmer after his predictions of a May Day revolution fail to materialize

The Palmer Raids

Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer launched a series of raids targeting suspected anarchists, communists, and radical labor organizers. His young assistant, J. Edgar Hoover, organized the intelligence-gathering operation that would later evolve into the FBI.

10,000+
Suspected radicals arrested in raids across 30 cities
556
Foreign nationals deported, including anarchist Emma Goldman
Due Process
Many held without warrants or legal counsel, violating constitutional rights

First vs. Second Red Scare

First (1919–1920) Second (1947–1957)
Trigger Russian Revolution, anarchist bombings Soviet expansion, atomic espionage
Duration ~2 years ~10 years
Key Figures Palmer, Hoover (young) McCarthy, Hoover (FBI Director)
Main Tool Mass raids and deportation Congressional hearings, blacklists
Primary Targets Immigrants, labor organizers Government employees, Hollywood, academics
Scope Largely executive action Legislative, judicial, and cultural

The Second Red Scare (1947–1957)

1947
Truman Loyalty Order
Executive Order 9835 requires loyalty investigations for all federal employees
1947
Hollywood Ten
HUAC investigates Hollywood; ten screenwriters and directors jailed for contempt of Congress
1948
Alger Hiss Case
Former State Department official accused of espionage; convicted of perjury in 1950
1950
McCarthy's Wheeling Speech
Senator Joseph McCarthy claims to have a list of 205 communists in the State Department
1950
Rosenbergs Arrested
Julius and Ethel Rosenberg arrested for passing atomic secrets; they were convicted in 1951 and executed in 1953.
1954
Army-McCarthy Hearings
Televised hearings expose McCarthy's tactics; Senate censures him in December 1954

The Rise of McCarthyism

In February 1950, Senator Joseph McCarthy of Wisconsin gave a speech in Wheeling, West Virginia, claiming he held a list of known communists working in the State Department. Though his numbers shifted and his evidence was thin, McCarthy tapped into genuine public anxiety about Soviet espionage.

High Low Public Fear 1947 1949 1950 1952 1954 1957 Peak: McCarthy Era Loyalty Order Soviet A-Bomb Censure

HUAC and Hollywood

The House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) investigated alleged communist influence in the entertainment industry beginning in 1947. Witnesses were asked: "Are you now, or have you ever been, a member of the Communist Party?"

1
Friendly witnesses cooperated, naming alleged communists to avoid punishment
2
The Hollywood Ten refused to testify, citing the First Amendment, and were jailed for contempt
3
The Blacklist barred over 300 artists from working in film, television, and radio
4
Self-censorship spread as studios avoided controversial content to escape scrutiny

Real Espionage Cases

While many accusations were baseless, some Soviet espionage was real. These cases fueled public fear and gave anti-communist crusaders evidence that the threat was genuine.

Alger Hiss
Former State Department official accused by Whittaker Chambers of passing documents to the Soviets. Convicted of perjury in 1950.
Rosenbergs
Julius and Ethel Rosenberg convicted of conspiracy to commit espionage for passing atomic secrets. Executed in 1953.
Venona Project
Declassified in 1995, these decoded Soviet cables confirmed some espionage but showed accusations far exceeded reality.

How to Analyze the Red Scare

On the AP Exam, Red Scare questions test your ability to connect events to broader themes and evaluate historical causation. Follow this framework:

1
Identify the context: What global or domestic events created the conditions for fear? (War, revolution, espionage cases)
2
Examine the actors: Who exploited the fear and why? (Politicians seeking power, bureaucrats expanding authority)
3
Assess the impact: How were civil liberties restricted? Who suffered the most? (Immigrants, minorities, dissenters)
4
Evaluate the backlash: What ended the scare? How did society course-correct? (Legal challenges, public opinion shifts)
5
Draw continuities: Connect to other moments when security fears overrode liberties (Alien and Sedition Acts, Japanese internment, post-9/11)

Key Legislation and Court Cases

Espionage Act (1917)
Criminalized interference with military operations or support for enemies during wartime
Sedition Act (1918)
Extended the Espionage Act to cover speech criticizing the government, flag, or military
Smith Act (1940)
Made it a crime to advocate the violent overthrow of the government; used to prosecute Communist Party leaders
McCarran Act (1950)
Required communist organizations to register; passed over Truman's veto, calling it the "greatest threat to civil liberties"

Impact on Civil Liberties

Red Scare Impact Free Speech Self-censorship, loyalty oaths, chilling effect on dissent Due Process Detention without warrants, guilt by association Freedom of Association Membership in organizations used as evidence of disloyalty Employment Rights Blacklists, loyalty programs, careers destroyed by accusations Privacy and Surveillance

The Fall of McCarthy

McCarthy's downfall came during the Army-McCarthy hearings of 1954. When McCarthy attacked a young lawyer in the Army's legal team, Army counsel Joseph Welch delivered one of the most famous rebukes in American political history:

1
Television exposed McCarthy's bullying tactics to a national audience of 20 million viewers
2
Edward R. Murrow's CBS broadcast challenged McCarthy's methods, turning public opinion
3
The Senate voted 67–22 to censure McCarthy in December 1954, ending his influence

Common Mistakes on the AP Exam

✕ Conflating the Two Scares
Students often merge details from 1919–1920 and 1947–1957. Palmer Raids belong to the First; McCarthyism belongs to the Second.
✕ Assuming All Accusations Were False
Soviet espionage was real (Venona, Hiss, Rosenbergs). The problem was that fear led to baseless accusations far beyond proven cases.
✕ Ignoring Broader Context
The Red Scare didn't happen in a vacuum. Connect it to the broader Cold War, containment policy, and nuclear anxiety.

Question 1 of 5

The Palmer Raids of 1919–1920 were primarily a response to which of the following?

Question 2 of 5

This speech is most directly associated with which historical figure and development?

Question 3 of 5

Which of the following best describes the significance of the Army-McCarthy hearings of 1954?

Question 4 of 5

The Hollywood Ten were jailed for which of the following?

Question 5 of 5

The Red Scare periods are most directly comparable to which other episode in American history in terms of tension between national security and civil liberties?