01 / 21

The Development of an
American Culture

Explore how a distinct national identity emerged through literature, art, religion, and reform movements in the early republic and antebellum era.

AP U.S. History

What Is American Culture?

After independence, Americans faced a crucial question: what made them culturally distinct from Britain and Europe? The answer emerged through decades of innovation in literature, art, religion, education, and social reform: a democratic spirit that celebrated the common person, the natural landscape, and the promise of self-improvement.

A Timeline of Cultural Milestones

1790s
Second Great Awakening Begins
Revival meetings spread democratic religion across the frontier
1820s
Hudson River School
Thomas Cole and others celebrate the American landscape in painting
1830s
Transcendentalism Emerges
Emerson, Thoreau, and Fuller champion individualism and nature
1830s
Reform Movements Surge
Abolitionism, temperance, women's rights, and education reform
1848
Seneca Falls Convention
Declaration of Sentiments demands equal rights for women
1850s
American Literary Renaissance
Melville, Hawthorne, Whitman, and Dickinson define a national literature

Three Pillars of American Culture

★ Religion
The Second Great Awakening democratized faith, emphasizing personal salvation and moral reform
★ Literature & Art
Transcendentalism, the Hudson River School, and a literary renaissance forged a distinct voice
★ Reform Movements
Abolitionism, temperance, education reform, and women's rights reflected democratic ideals

The Second Great Awakening

Beginning in the 1790s and peaking in the 1830s, a wave of Protestant revivalism swept the nation. Unlike the top-down preaching of the colonial era, this movement was democratic: anyone could achieve salvation through personal faith and moral action.

1
Camp meetings: Massive outdoor revivals on the frontier drew thousands, breaking down denominational barriers.
2
New denominations grew: Baptists and Methodists surged in membership, emphasizing emotional conversion over formal theology.
3
Reform impulse: The belief that society could be perfected fueled abolitionism, temperance, and other movements.

How Religion Fueled Reform

Second Great Awakening Belief in Human Perfectibility Abolitionism End slavery Temperance Limit alcohol Education Common schools Women's Rights Seneca Falls Distinctly American Democratic Culture

Transcendentalism and American Identity

Emerging in New England in the 1830s, Transcendentalism argued that intuition and nature were paths to truth, not just reason or established religion. It became the most distinctly American intellectual movement of the era.

Ralph Waldo Emerson
"Self-Reliance" (1841) urged Americans to trust their own judgment over conformity and tradition
Henry David Thoreau
Walden (1854) celebrated simple living; "Civil Disobedience" justified resisting unjust laws

The American Literary Renaissance

★ Walt Whitman
Leaves of Grass (1855): celebrated democracy, the body, and the common laborer in free verse
★ Herman Melville
Moby-Dick (1851): a sprawling epic exploring obsession, fate, and the American quest for mastery over nature
★ Nathaniel Hawthorne
The Scarlet Letter (1850): examined sin, guilt, and the legacy of Puritanism in American society

The Hudson River School

The American Sublime Untamed Wilderness Divine Light Reflective Waters

The Hudson River School (1820s-1870s) was America's first major art movement. Painters like Thomas Cole and Frederic Church depicted the American wilderness as a source of spiritual inspiration and national pride: unlike Europe's cultivated landscapes, America's nature was vast, untamed, and sublime.

First vs. Second Great Awakening

First Great Awakening Second Great Awakening
Period 1730s-1740s 1790s-1840s
Theology Calvinist: predestination Free will: personal salvation
Key Figures Jonathan Edwards, George Whitefield Charles Finney, Lyman Beecher
Social Impact Challenged church hierarchy Fueled abolitionism and reform
Audience Colonial congregations Frontier camp meetings, all classes
Cultural Effect Planted seeds of colonial unity Shaped a distinctly American identity

How to Analyze Cultural Sources

1
Identify the cultural sphere: Is this source about religion, literature, art, or reform? What movement does it belong to?
2
Connect to democratic ideals: How does it reflect equality, individualism, self-improvement, or popular participation?
3
Link to political context: Tie cultural developments to Jacksonian democracy, the Market Revolution, or sectional tensions.
4
Evaluate change over time: How did this cultural development differ from colonial or European precedents? What was new?
5
Assess limits: Who was included and who was excluded from this cultural movement? Consider race, gender, class, and region.

Example: Emerson's "Self-Reliance"

1
Cultural sphere: Literature and philosophy: part of the Transcendentalist movement centered in New England.
2
Democratic ideals: Celebrates the individual's inner voice over institutional authority: mirrors Jacksonian faith in the common person.
3
Political context: Written during the Market Revolution, when Americans debated whether material success should define national identity.
4
What's new: Rejected European Romanticism's aristocratic tone in favor of a distinctly American democratic individualism.

Example: The Seneca Falls Convention

The Declaration of Sentiments, modeled on the Declaration of Independence, illustrates how American culture turned its own founding ideals into tools for social reform.

Religious roots
Many organizers, including Lucretia Mott, were Quakers inspired by the Second Great Awakening's emphasis on moral perfectibility
Abolitionist links
Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Frederick Douglass connected women's rights to the broader anti-slavery movement

Example: Abolitionism as Culture

Abolitionism was not just a political movement: it was a cultural revolution that produced literature, art, music, and public oratory aimed at transforming Americans' moral conscience.

★ William Lloyd Garrison
The Liberator (1831): used the press as a weapon of moral suasion, demanding immediate emancipation
★ Frederick Douglass
Narrative of the Life (1845): a slave narrative that became a bestseller, humanizing enslaved people for white audiences
★ Harriet Beecher Stowe
Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852): the novel that "started" the Civil War, according to legend, by making slavery a moral outrage

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Treating culture as separate from politics
The AP exam rewards connecting cultural developments to political and economic context: the Market Revolution, Jacksonian democracy, and sectionalism.
✕ Confusing the two Great Awakenings
The First (1730s-1740s) was about religious authority; the Second (1790s-1840s) was about perfectionism and reform. They have very different historical effects.
✕ Ignoring who was excluded
Most cultural movements were led by middle-class white Northerners. The AP exam often asks about the limits and contradictions of "American" culture.

Summary: Movements at a Glance

Movement Key Idea Key Figure AP Significance
2nd Great Awakening Personal salvation, perfectibility Charles Finney Fueled all reform movements
Transcendentalism Individualism, nature, intuition Emerson, Thoreau Intellectual foundation of American identity
Hudson River School American landscape as sublime Thomas Cole National pride through art
Abolitionism Slavery as moral evil Garrison, Douglass Deepened sectional crisis
Women's Rights Equality of the sexes Stanton, Mott Extended democratic ideals

Question 1 of 5

The Second Great Awakening most directly contributed to which of the following developments in the early 1800s?

Question 2 of 5

Which of the following best describes the core belief of Transcendentalism?

Question 3 of 5

The authors of this document most clearly drew on which of the following to make their argument?

Question 4 of 5

The Hudson River School artists contributed to the development of American culture primarily by:

Question 5 of 5

A historian studying the development of American culture before the Civil War would most likely criticize these cultural movements for: