01 / 21
★

The Articles of
Confederation

America's first constitution and why its weaknesses led to the creation of the U.S. Constitution we know today.

AP U.S. History

What Were the Articles of Confederation?

The Articles of Confederation served as the first governing document of the United States, ratified in 1781. They established a "firm league of friendship" among the thirteen states rather than a strong national government.

Historical Context: Why a Weak Government?

The Founders deliberately created a weak central government because they feared tyranny. Their experience under King George III and British Parliament shaped their distrust of concentrated power.

Fear of Monarchy
Colonial experience under British rule made Americans deeply suspicious of executive power.
State Sovereignty
Each state viewed itself as an independent republic and resisted surrendering authority.
Wartime Urgency
The Articles were drafted during the Revolution, prioritizing unity over effective governance.

Timeline: From Drafting to Crisis

1776
Committee Appointed
Continental Congress appoints committee to draft framework, led by John Dickinson
1777
Articles Approved by Congress
Congress sends Articles to states for ratification after months of debate
1781
Ratification Complete
Maryland becomes the last state to ratify after Virginia cedes western lands
1785
Land Ordinance
Congress passes the Land Ordinance, organizing western territory sales
1786
Shays' Rebellion
Armed uprising in Massachusetts exposed the government's inability to maintain order
1787
Northwest Ordinance
Established process for admitting new states and banned slavery in the Northwest Territory

Structure of the Confederation Government

CONFEDERATION CONGRESS NO EXECUTIVE BRANCH NO NATIONAL JUDICIARY UNICAMERAL LEGISLATURE THIRTEEN SOVEREIGN STATES Each state gets ONE vote regardless of size NH MA RI CT NY NJ PA DE MD VA NC SC GA

What Congress Could and Could Not Do

✓ Could Do
Declare war and make peace
Conduct foreign affairs
Coin money
Operate post offices
Manage Native American relations
Settle disputes between states
✕ Could Not Do
Levy taxes
Regulate interstate trade
Raise an army directly
Enforce laws on citizens
Create a national court system
Amend Articles without unanimity

Critical Weaknesses of the Articles

1
No power to tax: Congress could only request money from states, and states regularly refused. The national government was perpetually broke.
2
No power over commerce: States imposed their own tariffs on each other, creating economic chaos and trade wars between neighbors.
3
Unanimous amendment required: All 13 states had to agree to any change, making reform virtually impossible.
4
No executive or judiciary: There was no way to enforce the laws Congress passed or resolve legal disputes at the national level.
5
One state, one vote: Virginia (population ~750,000) had the same vote as Delaware (~60,000), creating representation imbalances.

Genuine Accomplishments

Despite their flaws, the Articles did produce lasting achievements that shaped American governance. The AP exam frequently asks about these successes.

Treaty of Paris (1783)
Successfully negotiated the peace treaty ending the Revolution, securing independence and vast western territory.
Land Ordinance (1785)
Created a systematic survey method for western lands, dividing territory into townships and sections.
Northwest Ordinance (1787)
Established a process for creating new states from western territories, guaranteed civil liberties, and banned slavery in the Northwest Territory.

The Northwest Ordinance: A Closer Look

NORTHWEST TERRITORY WI MI IL IN OH KEY RULES 60,000 pop = statehood No slavery in territory Religious freedom Trial by jury Public education

Shays' Rebellion: The Breaking Point

In 1786-1787, Daniel Shays led an armed uprising of indebted farmers in western Massachusetts. They marched on courthouses to prevent foreclosures on their farms. The national government could not raise troops to respond.

1
Economic crisis: Post-war depression, heavy state taxes, and worthless Continental currency crushed small farmers.
2
Government paralysis: Congress could not raise an army. Massachusetts had to fund its own militia privately.
3
Wake-up call: George Washington and other leaders realized the Articles were too weak to preserve order or protect property.

Articles vs. Constitution

Articles of Confederation U.S. Constitution
Sovereignty States retain sovereignty Shared (federalism)
Legislature Unicameral Bicameral
Executive None President
Judiciary None Supreme Court
Taxation Cannot tax Can tax
Trade Cannot regulate Commerce Clause
Voting One state, one vote Proportional + equal
Amendment Unanimous (\(\frac{13}{13}\)) Supermajority (\(\frac{3}{4}\))

How to Analyze Articles Questions

1
Identify the weakness: Most AP questions connect a specific problem (debt, trade disputes, rebellion) to a structural flaw in the Articles.
2
Link cause to effect: Show how the weakness led to a concrete consequence. Example: no taxing power → war debts unpaid → economic instability.
3
Compare to the Constitution: Explain how the Constitution's corresponding provision fixed the problem. This is the most common essay structure.
4
Don't forget the successes: The AP exam tests nuance. Always mention the Northwest Ordinance and Treaty of Paris as genuine accomplishments.
5
Use specific evidence: Reference Shays' Rebellion, the Annapolis Convention, interstate tariff disputes, and the economic depression of the 1780s.

Example: Economic Weakness in Action

Scenario: After the Revolution, the U.S. owed approximately $40 million in war debts to foreign nations and domestic creditors. How did the Articles' structure make this problem unsolvable?

1
Identify the flaw: Congress had no power to tax. It could only request funds from states ("requisitions").
2
Trace the consequence: States routinely ignored requisitions. By 1786, Congress received only about \(\frac{1}{6}\) of what it requested.
3
Connect to bigger picture: Without revenue, the government couldn't pay soldiers, maintain diplomatic relations, or stabilize the economy.

Example: Interstate Commerce Chaos

NEW YORK Tariff on goods from NJ & CT NEW JERSEY Taxed NY lighthouse in retaliation CONNECTICUT Boycotted NY goods TRADE WAR Congress could do NOTHING to stop this

The Road to Philadelphia

The Annapolis Convention (1786) was called to address interstate trade disputes. Only 5 of 13 states sent delegates, but the meeting became the stepping stone to the Constitutional Convention.

1785
Mount Vernon Conference
Virginia and Maryland meet to resolve Potomac River navigation disputes
1786
Annapolis Convention
Only 5 states attend; Hamilton and Madison call for a broader convention
1786
Shays' Rebellion Erupts
Armed farmers in Massachusetts prove the urgency of reform
1787
Constitutional Convention
Delegates gather in Philadelphia to "revise" the Articles: they end up replacing them entirely

Common Mistakes on the AP Exam

✕ "The Articles were a total failure"
They successfully ended the war, negotiated the Treaty of Paris, and passed the Northwest Ordinance. The AP rewards nuance.
✕ Confusing the Articles with the Constitution
Students mix up which document had which feature. Remember: Articles = no executive, no judiciary, no taxing power.
✕ Ignoring Shays' Rebellion
This is the single most important catalyst for the Constitutional Convention. It appears on nearly every exam cycle.

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following was the primary reason the Articles of Confederation created such a weak central government?

Question 2 of 5

The Northwest Ordinance of 1787 was significant because it:

Question 3 of 5

The language of this article most directly reflects which of the following principles?

Question 4 of 5

Shays' Rebellion (1786-1787) most directly demonstrated which critical weakness of the Articles of Confederation?

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following best explains why the Articles of Confederation required unanimous consent of all thirteen states to amend?