01 / 21

Responses to Immigration
The Gilded Age

How Americans reacted to the massive wave of immigration between 1865 and 1900: from nativist backlash to settlement house reform.

AP U.S. History

The New Immigration

Between 1880 and 1920, over 20 million immigrants arrived in the United States. Unlike earlier waves dominated by Northern and Western Europeans, these "new immigrants" came largely from Southern and Eastern Europe: Italians, Poles, Russians, Greeks, and Eastern European Jews.

Push and Pull Factors

Push Factors
Religious persecution, political instability, crop failures, poverty, and mandatory military conscription drove millions to leave their homelands.
Pull Factors
Economic opportunity, cheap land, industrial jobs, religious freedom, and the promise of the "American Dream" attracted immigrants to the U.S.

Where Immigrants Settled

Most new immigrants settled in urban industrial centers in the Northeast and Midwest. They often clustered in ethnic enclaves: Little Italy, Chinatown, and Jewish neighborhoods on the Lower East Side of New York.

NYC Chicago Boston Pittsburgh Detroit Phila. Major Industrial Cities, 1880-1900

What Is Nativism?

Nativism is the political position of promoting the interests of native-born inhabitants against those of immigrants. In the Gilded Age, nativists argued that new immigrants threatened American culture, wages, and political institutions.

1
Cultural anxiety: New immigrants spoke different languages, practiced Catholicism, Judaism, or Orthodox Christianity, and had unfamiliar customs.
2
Economic competition: Native-born workers feared immigrants would accept lower wages and displace them from jobs.
3
Racial pseudo-science: Social Darwinists and eugenicists classified Southern and Eastern Europeans as racially inferior.

Nativist Organizations and Laws

1849
Know-Nothing Party
Anti-Catholic, anti-immigrant political movement that peaked in the 1850s and set the template for Gilded Age nativism.
1882
Chinese Exclusion Act
First federal law to restrict immigration based on nationality. Banned Chinese laborers for 10 years; renewed and expanded repeatedly.
1882
Immigration Act of 1882
Imposed a 50-cent head tax on immigrants and barred "lunatics, idiots, and persons likely to become public charges."
1887
American Protective Association
Anti-Catholic organization that sought to limit Catholic immigration and political influence; peaked at 2.5 million members in the 1890s.
1892
Ellis Island Opens
Federal immigration processing station in New York Harbor. Processed over 12 million immigrants between 1892 and 1954.
1894
Immigration Restriction League
Founded by Harvard graduates; lobbied for literacy tests to restrict "undesirable" immigrants from Southern and Eastern Europe.

The Chinese Exclusion Act (1882)

The Chinese Exclusion Act was a landmark in American immigration policy. It was the first law to ban an entire ethnic group from entering the United States and reflected intense anti-Chinese sentiment on the West Coast.

Cause
White laborers blamed Chinese workers for depressing wages, especially after the completion of the Transcontinental Railroad (1869).
Provision
Suspended immigration of Chinese laborers for 10 years. Chinese residents could not become naturalized citizens.
Legacy
Renewed in 1892 (Geary Act), made permanent in 1902. Not repealed until 1943 during WWII alliance with China.

Pro-Immigration Responses

Not all Americans were nativists. Many individuals and organizations welcomed immigrants and worked to help them integrate into American society. Their motivations ranged from humanitarian concern to economic pragmatism.

1
Settlement Houses: Jane Addams founded Hull House (1889) in Chicago to provide education, healthcare, and social services to immigrant communities.
2
Industrialists: Factory owners like Andrew Carnegie welcomed cheap immigrant labor, seeing it as essential to economic growth.
3
Ethnic mutual aid societies: Immigrant communities formed their own organizations to provide insurance, loans, and social support.
4
Political machines: Urban bosses like Tammany Hall's leaders traded services for immigrant votes, providing a path into American civic life.

Assimilation vs. Cultural Pluralism

Americans debated how immigrants should fit into society. Two major frameworks emerged:

Assimilation ("Melting Pot")
Immigrants should abandon their old cultures and fully adopt American language, customs, and values. Promoted through public schools, Americanization programs, and English-only requirements.
Cultural Pluralism
Immigrants can maintain their cultural identities while also participating in American civic life. America is a "salad bowl" rather than a "melting pot." Championed later by Horace Kallen (1915).

The Settlement House Movement

Hull House (1889) English Classes Language education Childcare Nurseries & kindergartens Healthcare Clinics & nutrition Job Training Vocational skills Civic Education Citizenship prep Cultural Arts Music, theater, art

Political Machines and Immigrants

Urban political machines played a complex role in immigrant life. Bosses like William "Boss" Tweed of Tammany Hall provided tangible services to immigrants in exchange for political loyalty.

Services Provided
Jobs, housing assistance, food baskets, help navigating courts, and fast-tracked naturalization papers.
Cost to Immigrants
Expected to vote for machine candidates, faced exploitation, and depended on a corrupt system rather than reforming it.

How to Analyze Immigration Responses

1
Identify the group responding: Is it nativists, industrialists, reformers, or the immigrants themselves?
2
Determine their motivation: Economic (wages, profits), cultural (religion, language), racial (pseudo-science), or humanitarian (moral duty)?
3
Examine the action taken: Legislation, organization, violence, or social services?
4
Assess the impact: How did this response affect immigrant communities? Did it restrict, assist, or transform their experience?
5
Connect to broader themes: How does this relate to American identity, democracy, capitalism, or constitutional principles?

Worked Example: Analyzing a Source

1
Group: Aldrich was an elite, native-born writer — a nativist voice.
2
Motivation: Cultural and racial anxiety — "degraded below our utmost conceptions" implies racial hierarchy.
3
Action: Lobbied for literacy tests and immigration restrictions through public persuasion.
4
Impact: Helped build public support for restriction, contributing to eventual passage of the Immigration Act of 1924.

Worked Example: Comparing Perspectives

Prompt: Compare the responses of nativists and settlement house reformers to Gilded Age immigration.

Nativists Reformers
View of Immigrants Threat to American culture People in need of assistance
Proposed Solution Restriction and exclusion Education and integration
Key Action Chinese Exclusion Act, literacy tests Hull House, civic education
Underlying Belief Anglo-Saxon racial superiority Universal human dignity
Long-term Legacy 1924 Immigration Act quotas Modern social work profession

Worked Example: Causation Argument

AP Prompt: Explain how economic factors caused changes in immigration policy during the Gilded Age.

1
Thesis: Economic competition between native-born workers and immigrants directly caused nativist legislation, particularly the Chinese Exclusion Act.
2
Evidence 1: The 1870s depression increased unemployment. White workers on the West Coast blamed Chinese laborers for accepting lower wages in mining and railroad work.
3
Evidence 2: Labor unions like the Knights of Labor supported Chinese exclusion, framing it as a workers' rights issue rather than pure racial prejudice.
4
Complexity: While economic anxiety was a cause, racial prejudice was a necessary condition — European immigrants who also worked cheaply were not excluded in the same way.

Common Mistakes on the AP Exam

✕ Treating all immigrants the same
Chinese, Irish, Italian, and Jewish immigrants faced different levels and types of discrimination. Avoid lumping them together.
✕ Ignoring immigrant agency
Immigrants were not passive victims. They formed mutual aid societies, started businesses, and organized politically. Show their active role.
✕ Oversimplifying nativism
Nativism was not just "racism." It combined economic, cultural, religious, and racial anxieties. AP essays reward nuanced analysis.

Question 1 of 5

The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was historically significant primarily because it:

Question 2 of 5

Jane Addams's Hull House is best described as an example of which response to immigration?

Question 3 of 5

Which of the following best describes the point of disagreement between Speaker A and Speaker B?

Question 4 of 5

The Immigration Restriction League (founded 1894) primarily advocated for which policy to limit immigration?

Question 5 of 5

Urban political machines during the Gilded Age are best understood as: