01 / 21

Failure of
Compromise

How the breakdown of political compromise in the 1850s made the Civil War increasingly unavoidable: from the Missouri Compromise to Bleeding Kansas.

AP U.S. History

What Is Political Compromise?

In the antebellum United States, compromise meant legislative deals that attempted to balance the interests of free states and slave states. Each side conceded something in order to preserve the Union and avoid armed conflict.

Concession
A point one side gives up in exchange for something else it values.
Sectional Balance
Equal representation of free and slave states in the U.S. Senate.
Popular Sovereignty
Letting settlers in a territory vote on whether to permit slavery.

Why Compromise Mattered

The Constitution itself was a product of compromise: the Three-Fifths Compromise, the Fugitive Slave Clause, and the delayed ban on the slave trade. For decades, similar deals held the Union together.

The Arc of Compromise: 1820–1861

1820
Missouri Compromise
Admitted Missouri as slave, Maine as free; drew \(36^\circ 30'\) line
1850
Compromise of 1850
California free; stricter Fugitive Slave Act; popular sovereignty in Utah/New Mexico
1854
Kansas-Nebraska Act
Repealed \(36^\circ 30'\) line; popular sovereignty unleashed violence
1857
Dred Scott Decision
Supreme Court ruled Congress could not ban slavery in territories
1861
Crittenden Compromise Fails
Last-ditch effort rejected; secession and war followed

The Missouri Compromise (1820)

\(36^\circ 30'\)
FREE TERRITORY SLAVE TERRITORY Missouri (Slave) Maine (Free)

Compromise of 1850

1
California admitted as a free state: tipped the Senate balance toward the North.
2
Popular sovereignty in Utah and New Mexico territories: let settlers decide the slavery question.
3
Stricter Fugitive Slave Act: required Northern citizens to help capture escaped enslaved people, enraging abolitionists.
4
Slave trade banned in Washington, D.C.: a symbolic concession, but slavery itself remained legal there.

Kansas-Nebraska Act: The Breaking Point

Senator Stephen A. Douglas proposed organizing Kansas and Nebraska territories using popular sovereignty, effectively repealing the Missouri Compromise's \(36^\circ 30'\) line. This opened land previously closed to slavery.

Before (1820)
Free above \(36^\circ 30'\)
Slave below \(36^\circ 30'\)
✓ (Clear boundary) After (1854) Popular sovereignty Popular sovereignty ✕ (No clear boundary)

Bleeding Kansas: Violence Replaces Debate

Popular sovereignty in Kansas did not produce orderly democracy. Instead, pro-slavery "Border Ruffians" from Missouri flooded into Kansas to vote illegally, while Free-Soilers organized their own rival government. The result was guerrilla warfare.

Sack of Lawrence
Pro-slavery forces destroyed the Free-Soil town of Lawrence in May 1856.
Pottawatomie Massacre
John Brown and followers killed five pro-slavery settlers in retaliation.
Caning of Sumner
Rep. Preston Brooks beat Sen. Charles Sumner on the Senate floor over Kansas.

Dred Scott & the Death of Legislative Compromise

In Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), Chief Justice Roger Taney ruled that Congress had no power to ban slavery in any territory, and that African Americans were not citizens. This destroyed the legal foundation of every prior compromise.

Compromise vs. Appeasement

Genuine Compromise Appeasement
Both sides concede ✓ Yes ✕ One side concedes repeatedly
Root cause addressed ✓ Ideally yes ✕ Problem deferred
Stability Longer lasting Temporary at best
Example Missouri Compromise (1820) Fugitive Slave Act (1850)

Why Compromises Failed: Structural Causes

1
Westward expansion: Each new territory reopened the slavery question, making old deals obsolete.
2
Moral absolutism: Abolitionists saw slavery as a sin; slaveholders saw it as a constitutional right. No middle ground existed.
3
Economic divergence: The industrializing North and the plantation South developed incompatible economic systems.
4
Political party collapse: The Whig Party disintegrated; the Republican Party formed on an anti-slavery platform, polarizing national politics.

How to Analyze Compromise on the AP Exam

1
Identify the context: What event or issue triggered the compromise? What was at stake?
2
Name the concessions: What did each side give up? What did each side gain?
3
Evaluate effectiveness: Did it resolve the root cause, or merely delay conflict? How long did it hold?
4
Connect to larger patterns: How does this compromise fit into the long arc of sectional tension leading to the Civil War?
5
Use specific evidence: Reference dates, names, and provisions to support your analysis in essays.

Example: Analyzing the Missouri Compromise

Context
Missouri applied for statehood in 1819, threatening the 11–11 balance of free and slave states in the Senate.
Concessions
North: Allowed Missouri as slave state. South: Accepted the \(36^\circ 30'\) line banning slavery in remaining territory.

Example: The Compromise of 1850

North Gained California free state D.C. slave trade banned Texas boundary settled +1 Free State Advantage South Gained Stronger Fugitive Slave Act Popular sovereignty in UT/NM Federal non-interference Northern Compliance Required

Example: The Crittenden Compromise (1860–1861)

After Lincoln's election, Senator John J. Crittenden of Kentucky proposed a set of constitutional amendments to permanently protect slavery south of \(36^\circ 30'\) and guarantee it could never be abolished by amendment. It was the last attempt at compromise.

The Proposal
Extend the \(36^\circ 30'\) line to the Pacific; protect slavery where it existed via unamendable amendments.
Why It Failed
Lincoln and Republicans refused: accepting it would validate the expansion of slavery and nullify the election results.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing Compromise Dates
Students mix up the Missouri Compromise (1820), Compromise of 1850, and Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854). Use the timeline to keep them straight.
✕ Ignoring the Fugitive Slave Act
The Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 was not a minor detail: it radicalized Northern moderates and was central to the compromise's failure.
✕ Treating Compromises as Successes
Compromises delayed war but did not resolve the issue. On the AP exam, emphasize their limitations, not just their existence.

Question 1 of 5

Which provision of the Compromise of 1850 most directly angered Northerners and strengthened the abolitionist movement?

Question 2 of 5

The Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 was most significant because it:

Question 3 of 5

How did the Dred Scott decision (1857) affect the possibility of future legislative compromises over slavery?

Question 4 of 5

The speakers disagree most directly over whether:

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following best explains why the Crittenden Compromise failed in 1860–1861?