Failure of
Compromise
How the breakdown of political compromise in the 1850s made the Civil War increasingly unavoidable: from the Missouri Compromise to Bleeding Kansas.
What Is Political Compromise?
In the antebellum United States, compromise meant legislative deals that attempted to balance the interests of free states and slave states. Each side conceded something in order to preserve the Union and avoid armed conflict.
Why Compromise Mattered
The Constitution itself was a product of compromise: the Three-Fifths Compromise, the Fugitive Slave Clause, and the delayed ban on the slave trade. For decades, similar deals held the Union together.
The Arc of Compromise: 1820–1861
The Missouri Compromise (1820)
Compromise of 1850
Kansas-Nebraska Act: The Breaking Point
Senator Stephen A. Douglas proposed organizing Kansas and Nebraska territories using popular sovereignty, effectively repealing the Missouri Compromise's \(36^\circ 30'\) line. This opened land previously closed to slavery.
Bleeding Kansas: Violence Replaces Debate
Popular sovereignty in Kansas did not produce orderly democracy. Instead, pro-slavery "Border Ruffians" from Missouri flooded into Kansas to vote illegally, while Free-Soilers organized their own rival government. The result was guerrilla warfare.
Dred Scott & the Death of Legislative Compromise
In Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857), Chief Justice Roger Taney ruled that Congress had no power to ban slavery in any territory, and that African Americans were not citizens. This destroyed the legal foundation of every prior compromise.
Compromise vs. Appeasement
| Genuine Compromise | Appeasement | |
|---|---|---|
| Both sides concede | ✓ Yes | ✕ One side concedes repeatedly |
| Root cause addressed | ✓ Ideally yes | ✕ Problem deferred |
| Stability | Longer lasting | Temporary at best |
| Example | Missouri Compromise (1820) | Fugitive Slave Act (1850) |
Why Compromises Failed: Structural Causes
How to Analyze Compromise on the AP Exam
Example: Analyzing the Missouri Compromise
Example: The Compromise of 1850
Example: The Crittenden Compromise (1860–1861)
After Lincoln's election, Senator John J. Crittenden of Kentucky proposed a set of constitutional amendments to permanently protect slavery south of \(36^\circ 30'\) and guarantee it could never be abolished by amendment. It was the last attempt at compromise.
Common Mistakes
Question 1 of 5
Which provision of the Compromise of 1850 most directly angered Northerners and strengthened the abolitionist movement?
Question 2 of 5
The Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 was most significant because it:
Question 3 of 5
How did the Dred Scott decision (1857) affect the possibility of future legislative compromises over slavery?
Question 4 of 5
Speaker A: "The question of slavery in the territories can be settled peacefully through popular sovereignty. Let the people of each territory decide for themselves. This respects democratic principles and avoids federal overreach."
Speaker B: "Popular sovereignty is a fraud. It invites violence and ballot-stuffing, as we have seen in Kansas. The only honest course is to prohibit slavery's expansion entirely, as the founders intended."
The speakers disagree most directly over whether:
Question 5 of 5
Which of the following best explains why the Crittenden Compromise failed in 1860–1861?