01 / 22

Election of 1860
and Secession

How a four-way presidential race shattered the last bonds of national unity and propelled eleven Southern states out of the Union.

AP U.S. History

A Nation at the Breaking Point

By 1860, decades of sectional tension over slavery's expansion had eroded every major political compromise. The Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854) destroyed the Whig Party, birthed the Republican Party, and turned Kansas into a bloody battleground. The Dred Scott decision (1857) further inflamed the North, while John Brown's raid at Harpers Ferry (1859) terrified the South.

Key Terms to Know

Secession
The formal withdrawal of a state from the Union, asserted as a constitutional right by Southern leaders.
Popular Sovereignty
The principle that settlers in a territory should decide whether to allow slavery by vote.
Free Soil
The political position opposing slavery's expansion into new territories, central to the Republican platform.

The Democratic Party Splits

The Democratic Party fractured along sectional lines at its 1860 conventions. Northern delegates supported Stephen Douglas and popular sovereignty, while Southern delegates demanded federal protection of slavery in all territories. When the party could not agree, it split into two:

Northern Democrats
Stephen Douglas of Illinois: championed popular sovereignty and preserving the Union.
Southern Democrats
John C. Breckinridge of Kentucky: demanded a federal slave code protecting slavery in territories.

The Four Candidates of 1860

Abraham Lincoln
Republican. Opposed slavery's expansion. Did not appear on ballots in most Southern states.
Stephen Douglas
Northern Democrat. Popular sovereignty. Campaigned nationwide, the only candidate to do so.
John C. Breckinridge
Southern Democrat. Federal protection of slavery. Strong support in the Deep South.
John Bell
Constitutional Union. Avoided slavery; appealed to border-state moderates seeking compromise.

Electoral Results: A Sectional Victory

Electoral Votes (152 needed to win) 0 152 Lincoln 180 Breckinridge 72 Bell 39 Douglas 12 Lincoln won with only ~40% of the popular vote

Why Lincoln Won

1
Democratic split. Douglas and Breckinridge divided the anti-Republican vote, preventing either from building a majority.
2
Northern population advantage. Free states held enough electoral votes to win outright, regardless of how the South voted.
3
Republican coalition. The party united former Whigs, Free Soilers, and abolitionists behind a platform of free labor, free soil, and protective tariffs.
4
Swing states won. Lincoln carried critical battlegrounds: Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Illinois.

Secession vs. Nullification

Secession Nullification
Definition A state formally leaves the Union A state voids a federal law within its borders
Scope Total separation from federal authority Rejection of a specific law or policy
Precedent 1860-1861: eleven Southern states 1832-1833: South Carolina Nullification Crisis
Outcome Civil War (1861-1865) Force Bill + compromise tariff resolved crisis
Legal Basis Claimed Compact theory: states joined voluntarily States' rights under the 10th Amendment

The Secession Timeline

Nov 6, 1860
Lincoln Elected
Wins without a single Southern electoral vote
Dec 20, 1860
South Carolina Secedes
First state to leave the Union, citing threats to slavery
Jan-Feb 1861
Six More States Follow
Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Texas secede
Feb 4, 1861
Confederate States Formed
CSA established in Montgomery, Alabama; Jefferson Davis elected president
Mar 4, 1861
Lincoln Inaugurated
Pledges to preserve the Union but not abolish slavery where it exists
Apr 12, 1861
Fort Sumter Attacked
Confederate forces fire on the federal fort; the Civil War begins
Apr-Jun 1861
Four More States Secede
Virginia, Arkansas, Tennessee, North Carolina join the Confederacy

Southern Justifications for Secession

1
States' rights. The Constitution was a compact of sovereign states; any state could leave voluntarily, just as it had joined.
2
Protection of slavery. Secession declarations explicitly cited threats to the institution of slavery as the primary cause.
3
Minority rule fear. A "sectional party" (the Republicans) now controlled the presidency without any Southern votes.
4
Economic anxiety. The Southern economy depended on enslaved labor; restricting slavery's expansion threatened its future.

Unionist Arguments Against Secession

1
Perpetual Union. The Constitution created a binding government, not a voluntary association states could exit at will.
2
Democratic legitimacy. Lincoln won a fair election under constitutional rules; secession rejected democracy itself.
3
No constitutional right. The Constitution contains no provision for secession; the Preamble speaks of a "more perfect Union."
4
Dangerous precedent. If any election could trigger disunion, no democracy could survive.

How to Analyze on the AP Exam

1
Identify the context. What long-term tensions (1820-1860) set the stage? Think: Missouri Compromise, Compromise of 1850, Kansas-Nebraska, Dred Scott.
2
Pinpoint the catalyst. Lincoln's election was the immediate trigger, but not the root cause.
3
Analyze arguments from both sides. Distinguish between stated reasons ("states' rights") and underlying motives (preservation of slavery).
4
Connect to consequences. How did secession lead to the Civil War, and how did the war transform the nation?
5
Use primary sources. Reference secession declarations, Lincoln's inaugural address, and party platforms as evidence.

Example: South Carolina's Declaration

1
Central grievance: Northern hostility toward slavery, not abstract states' rights.
2
Specific complaints: Northern states refused to enforce the Fugitive Slave Act and passed personal liberty laws.
3
AP takeaway: The document's own language shows that slavery was the primary cause of secession.

Example: Lincoln's First Inaugural

1
Conciliation. Lincoln tried to reassure the South that he would not touch slavery where it already existed.
2
Union above all. He declared secession legally void and pledged to enforce federal law.
3
AP takeaway: Lincoln's moderate stance shows the gap between Republican policy and Southern fears: the South seceded over potential future restrictions, not immediate abolition.

The Border States and Upper South

Not all slave states seceded immediately. The border states (Delaware, Maryland, Kentucky, Missouri) remained in the Union throughout the war. Four Upper South states (Virginia, Arkansas, Tennessee, North Carolina) only seceded after Fort Sumter, when Lincoln called for troops.

Border States
Stayed in the Union. Had slavery but stronger economic ties to the North. Lincoln handled them with extreme care.
Deep South
Seceded immediately (Dec 1860 – Feb 1861). Cotton economy, highest enslaved populations, strongest secessionist sentiment.
Upper South
Seceded only after Fort Sumter. More divided: Virginia's western counties broke away to form West Virginia.

Common Mistakes on the AP Exam

✕ "States' rights alone"
Claiming secession was only about states' rights without acknowledging that the specific right in question was the right to own enslaved people.
✕ Lincoln as abolitionist
Calling Lincoln an abolitionist in 1860. He opposed slavery's expansion but did not campaign on abolition.
✕ All Southern states left at once
Treating secession as a single event. The Deep South seceded before Lincoln's inauguration; the Upper South only after Fort Sumter.

Summary: Road to Secession

Factor Northern View Southern View
Slavery in territories Should be prohibited (Free Soil) Should be protected by federal law
Lincoln's election Legitimate democratic result Proof North could dominate without South
Constitution Creates a perpetual Union A compact states can voluntarily exit
Secession Illegal rebellion Legitimate right of sovereign states
Compromise No further concessions on slavery's expansion Compromise failed; separation was the only option

Question 1 of 5

Which factor most directly enabled Lincoln's victory in the 1860 presidential election?

Question 2 of 5

Which state was the first to secede from the Union after Lincoln's election?

Question 3 of 5

Based on this passage, what was the primary grievance cited by South Carolina for secession?

Question 4 of 5

How did border states like Kentucky and Missouri differ from Deep South states during the secession crisis?

Question 5 of 5

In his First Inaugural Address, Lincoln argued that secession was unconstitutional primarily because: