01 / 21

Developing an
American Identity

Explore how the United States forged a unique national character through politics, culture, religion, and expansion in the early republic period.

AP U.S. History

What Is American Identity?

American identity refers to the shared beliefs, values, and cultural practices that distinguished the people of the United States from their European origins. It encompasses ideals of self-governance, individual liberty, religious pluralism, and a belief in westward expansion as national destiny.

Key Terms: Building Blocks of Identity

Republicanism
Civic virtue and citizen participation as the foundation of self-government
Manifest Destiny
Belief that American expansion across the continent was divinely ordained
Second Great Awakening
Religious revival that reshaped morality, reform movements, and democratic culture
Sectionalism
Regional loyalties (North, South, West) that competed with a unified national identity
Market Revolution
Economic transformation linking regions through canals, railroads, and factories

Why Does Identity Matter in APUSH?

The College Board's AP U.S. History framework identifies "American and National Identity" as one of seven key themes. Questions on the exam frequently ask you to analyze how and why definitions of American identity changed over time and who was included or excluded from that definition.

The Four Pillars of American Identity

American Identity Political Democracy, Rights, Constitution Cultural Art, Literature, Education Religious Revivals, Pluralism, Reform Economic Market Revolution, Expansion, Labor

Political Identity: Democracy and Expansion

1
Jeffersonian Democracy: The ideal of the yeoman farmer as the backbone of the republic, emphasizing agrarian virtue over urban commerce.
2
Jacksonian Democracy: Expanded suffrage for white men, the "common man" rhetoric, and the spoils system as democratic participation.
3
The Constitution as Symbol: Americans increasingly venerated the Constitution as a quasi-sacred document that set them apart from monarchies.

Jeffersonian vs. Jacksonian Visions

Jeffersonian Jacksonian
Era 1800s-1820s 1820s-1840s
Ideal Citizen Yeoman farmer Common white man
Suffrage Property-owning white men All white men (no property requirement)
Federal Power Limited, strict constructionism Strong executive, weak Congress/Bank
Economic Vision Agrarian, anti-manufacturing Laissez-faire, anti-monopoly
Native Policy Assimilation possible Forced removal

Cultural Identity: Art, Literature, and Reform

A distinctive American culture emerged in the early 19th century as writers, artists, and thinkers consciously broke from European models to celebrate American landscapes, democratic ideals, and spiritual independence.

Transcendentalism
Emerson and Thoreau championed individualism, self-reliance, and nature as spiritual truth
Hudson River School
Painters like Cole and Church depicted the American wilderness as sublime and uniquely national
Reform Movements
Abolition, temperance, women's rights, and utopian communities shaped moral identity

Timeline: Forging the American Identity

1803
Louisiana Purchase
Doubled the nation's size, tied identity to westward expansion
1815
Era of Good Feelings
Post-War of 1812 nationalism, one-party politics, and national pride
1820s
Second Great Awakening
Mass religious revivals fueled reform and reshaped moral culture
1830
Indian Removal Act
Defined American identity through the violent exclusion of Native peoples
1836
Emerson's Nature
Launched Transcendentalism as a distinctly American philosophical movement
1845
"Manifest Destiny" Coined
John O'Sullivan gave a name to the ideology of continental expansion
1848
Seneca Falls Convention
Women demanded inclusion in the American promise of equality

How to Analyze Identity on the AP Exam

1
Identify the period: Which era is the question focused on? Identity changed significantly between 1800 and 1848.
2
Name the pillar: Is the question about political, cultural, religious, or economic forces shaping identity?
3
Examine inclusion and exclusion: Who benefited from this vision of identity? Who was left out or harmed?
4
Connect cause and effect: What events, movements, or leaders drove the change in identity?
5
Use specific evidence: Name documents, laws, individuals, or movements. Avoid vague generalizations.

Example: The Monroe Doctrine (1823)

Prompt: "Explain how the Monroe Doctrine contributed to a developing American identity in the early 19th century."

Example: The Second Great Awakening

Prompt: "Analyze how the Second Great Awakening shaped American identity between 1800 and 1840."

1
Religious democratization: Camp meetings and circuit preachers made religion accessible to common people, reinforcing the ideal of spiritual equality as a core American value.
2
Reform impulse: The revival's emphasis on personal salvation fueled movements for abolition, temperance, and women's activism: expanding who could claim moral authority.
3
Sectional tension: In the South, revivals reinforced a paternalistic identity that justified slavery; in the North, they fueled abolitionism. The same movement produced competing identities.

Example: Manifest Destiny and Exclusion

INCLUDED White male settlers Protestant missionaries → EXPANSION WESTWARD EXCLUDED Native Americans Mexicans, enslaved people "Manifest Destiny" (1845) Westward expansion was divinely ordained but it required dispossession and conquest

The Market Revolution and Identity

The Market Revolution (1790s-1840s) transformed the U.S. economy from subsistence farming to a market-based system connected by canals, railroads, and factories. This reshaped how Americans understood themselves:

Northern Identity
Free labor, industrialization, and urban growth defined the North as progressive and modern
Southern Identity
Cotton economy, plantation slavery, and agrarian honor defined the South as traditional and distinct
Western Identity
Independence, opportunity, and rugged individualism defined the frontier as uniquely American

Common Mistakes on Identity Questions

✕ Treating Identity as Unified
There was never one "American identity." Always acknowledge competing visions based on region, race, gender, and class.
✕ Ignoring Exclusion
Students celebrate democratic expansion without noting who was excluded: enslaved people, Native Americans, women, immigrants.
✕ Vague Evidence
Saying "Americans felt patriotic" earns no points. Name specific laws, leaders, documents, or events as evidence.

Summary: Forces Shaping Identity

Force Expanded Identity Limited Identity
Jacksonian Democracy Suffrage for all white men Indian Removal, excluded women/Black people
2nd Great Awakening Spiritual equality, reform movements Pro-slavery theology in the South
Manifest Destiny National unity, continental vision Dispossession of Native and Mexican lands
Market Revolution Economic opportunity, mobility Deepened sectionalism, wage slavery
Transcendentalism Individualism, American intellectual independence Elitist, mostly white male movement

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best describes how Jacksonian Democracy contributed to developing an American identity?

Question 2 of 5

O'Sullivan's statement best reflects which aspect of developing an American identity?

Question 3 of 5

The Second Great Awakening most directly contributed to the development of American identity by:

Question 4 of 5

A historian arguing that the Market Revolution increased sectionalism rather than national unity would most likely cite which evidence?

Question 5 of 5

Emerson's philosophy best represents which force in the development of American identity?