01 / 20

Continuity and Change
in Period 6

Explore how industrialization, immigration, and westward expansion transformed American society from 1865 to 1898: what changed, what persisted, and why it matters for the AP exam.

AP U.S. History

What Is Period 6?

Period 6 spans 1865 to 1898, from the end of the Civil War through the dawn of American imperialism. It encompasses Reconstruction, the Gilded Age, and the early Progressive impulse. The AP framework asks you to trace how the nation was fundamentally reshaped while certain older patterns stubbornly persisted.

Defining Continuity and Change

Continuity
Patterns, institutions, beliefs, or power structures that persisted across the period despite new pressures.
Change
New developments: technologies, laws, migrations, or ideologies that fundamentally altered society, economics, or politics.

Key Events: 1865 to 1898

1865
13th Amendment
Abolished slavery: the most dramatic legal change of the era
1869
Transcontinental Railroad
Connected East and West, accelerated industrialization and migration
1877
End of Reconstruction
Compromise of 1877 withdrew federal troops, enabling Jim Crow continuities
1882
Chinese Exclusion Act
Continued nativist patterns despite massive immigration waves
1890
Wounded Knee / Census frontier "closed"
Marked end of westward expansion era and Native resistance
1898
Spanish-American War
Signaled a new chapter: American overseas imperialism

The Big Changes of Period 6

Industrialization
Steel, oil, and railroads created corporate giants and a new wage-labor economy.
Mass Immigration
Southern and Eastern Europeans flooded cities, reshaping demographics and culture.
Urbanization
The U.S. shifted from a rural, agrarian society to one dominated by sprawling cities.

The Key Continuities

Racial Hierarchy
Despite abolition, white supremacy persisted through Jim Crow laws, sharecropping, and violence.
Nativism
Anti-immigrant sentiment from earlier decades continued, now aimed at new groups.
Westward Expansion
The government continued displacing Native peoples through treaties, reservations, and force.

Continuity vs. Change: Side by Side

Theme Continuity Change
Race Relations White supremacy, Black codes, sharecropping 13th/14th/15th Amendments, brief political gains
Economy Laissez-faire ideology, wealth inequality Shift from agrarian to industrial capitalism
Immigration Nativist backlash against newcomers New source regions: S. and E. Europe, Asia
Government Role Limited federal regulation of business Interstate Commerce Act (1887), Sherman Antitrust (1890)
Native Policy Dispossession and forced assimilation Dawes Act (1887) replaced treaty system

The Analytical Framework

The AP exam rewards answers that go beyond simply stating facts. You must explain the relationship between what changed and what persisted. Use this mental model:

IDENTIFY What changed? What persisted? EVIDENCE Cite specific examples EXPLAIN Why did it change or persist? Example Application IDENTIFY: Racial hierarchy persisted EVIDENCE: Jim Crow laws, Plessy v. Ferguson EXPLAIN: Federal withdrawal from the South allowed states to reimpose control

How to Apply the Skill

1
Read the prompt carefully. Identify the time period and the specific theme (economic, political, social, cultural).
2
Brainstorm both sides. For every change you name, ask: what related pattern continued? For every continuity, ask: what pressure tried to break it?
3
Select specific evidence. Use names, dates, laws, and events: not vague generalizations.
4
Explain causation. Why did certain things change? Why did others resist change? Connect causes to effects.
5
Write a clear thesis. State both the continuity and the change, then identify which was more significant and why.

Worked Example: Race Relations

Prompt: "Evaluate the extent to which African American lives changed in the period 1865 to 1898."

Worked Example: The Economy

Prompt: "To what extent did the American economic system change in the Gilded Age?"

Changed
Massive industrial output, corporate consolidation (trusts, monopolies), new technologies (steel, electricity), rise of wage labor and factory work.
Persisted
Laissez-faire government, extreme wealth inequality, exploitation of labor (now factory workers instead of enslaved people), limited social safety net.

Worked Example: Immigration

Prompt: "Analyze continuities and changes in immigration patterns and responses from 1865 to 1898."

1
Change in source: Pre-war immigrants were largely from Northern and Western Europe; post-war waves came from Southern and Eastern Europe and East Asia.
2
Change in scale: Immigration surged dramatically: over 10 million newcomers arrived between 1860 and 1890.
3
Continuity in response: Nativist hostility continued: the Know-Nothings of the 1850s gave way to the American Protective Association of the 1890s. The Chinese Exclusion Act (1882) formalized racial exclusion.

The West: Transformation and Persistence

CHANGE Transcontinental Railroad (1869) Homestead Act settlers Mining booms (gold, silver) Dawes Act (1887): allotment Frontier declared "closed" (1890) New economies, technologies, and federal policies reshaped the West CONTINUITY Dispossession of Native lands Forced assimilation ideology Federal violence against Natives Resource extraction as motive Manifest Destiny ideology The underlying logic of expansion and exploitation continued

Government's Evolving Role

One of Period 6's most nuanced themes is the tension between laissez-faire ideology and growing federal power. The government both resisted and began regulating the new industrial economy.

1
Continuity: laissez-faire. Government largely favored business interests: protective tariffs, land grants to railroads, courts striking down labor regulations.
2
Change: first regulations. The Interstate Commerce Act (1887) and Sherman Antitrust Act (1890) marked the beginning of federal economic regulation, even though enforcement was weak.
3
Significance: These early, limited changes planted seeds for the Progressive Era's much more aggressive reforms in Period 7.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Only Listing Changes
Students often describe what changed without identifying what persisted. The AP rubric requires both for full credit.
✕ Vague Generalizations
"Things got better for some people" earns no points. Cite specific evidence: laws, events, people, dates.
✕ Confusing Form and Function
Slavery ended (form changed), but racial subjugation continued (function persisted). Saying "racism ended with the 13th Amendment" is historically inaccurate.

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best represents a continuity in American race relations from before the Civil War to the end of Period 6?

Question 2 of 5

The Compromise of 1877 is historically significant because it:

Question 3 of 5

Which pair best illustrates the concept of "form changed, function persisted" in Period 6?

Question 4 of 5

The fundamental disagreement between Historian A and Historian B concerns:

Question 5 of 5

A student writes: "The Dawes Act of 1887 was a major change because it replaced the treaty system with individual land allotments." To strengthen this analysis using the continuity-and-change skill, the student should add: