01 / 21

Comparison in
Period 7 (1890-1945)

Master the AP skill of historical comparison by analyzing the similarities and differences between major developments of the Progressive Era, WWI, the Roaring Twenties, the Great Depression, and WWII.

AP U.S. History

What Is Historical Comparison?

Historical comparison is the AP skill of identifying and explaining similarities and differences between two or more historical developments, processes, or events. It requires more than simply listing facts: you must analyze why those similarities and differences matter in context.

Why Period 7 Is Ideal for Comparison

Period 7 (1890-1945) contains recurring patterns: reform movements, wartime mobilization, debates over government power, and struggles for civil rights. These parallel developments invite natural comparisons.

Reform Eras
Progressivism vs. the New Deal both expanded federal power to address economic inequality
War Mobilization
WWI and WWII both required massive government coordination of industry and labor
Civil Liberties
Both wars saw restrictions on civil liberties, from the Espionage Act to Japanese internment

Period 7 Timeline at a Glance

1890s
Progressive Era Begins
Reformers target corruption, monopolies, and urban poverty
1917-18
U.S. in World War I
Mobilization expands federal power; civil liberties restricted
1920s
The Roaring Twenties
Consumer culture booms; tensions between tradition and modernity
1929-39
Great Depression and New Deal
FDR's programs reshape the role of the federal government
1941-45
World War II
Total war transforms economy, society, and America's global role

The Comparison Framework

SIMILARITIES Shared causes Shared effects Shared context Development A Unique causes Unique effects Unique context Development B Unique causes Unique effects Unique context EXPLAIN what accounts for similarities and differences

Similarity vs. Difference

AP readers reward nuance. A similarity claim shows two developments share a feature; a difference claim shows how they diverge. Both require specific evidence and explanation.

Similarity
Both the Progressive Era and the New Deal expanded the federal government's role in regulating the economy, driven by public demand to address economic hardship.
Difference
Progressives focused on regulation and moral reform, while the New Deal emphasized direct relief and economic restructuring during an unprecedented crisis.

How to Write a Strong Comparison

1
Identify the category. What aspect are you comparing? (Causes, effects, methods, scope, participants)
2
State the claim. Use "Both... " for similarity or "While X..., Y..." for difference. Be direct.
3
Provide evidence for each side. Name specific laws, events, groups, or policies from both developments.
4
Explain what accounts for it. Why did this similarity or difference exist? Connect to historical context.

Example: Progressivism vs. New Deal

Progressive Era (1890s-1920) • Trust-busting (Sherman Act) • FDA, pure food laws • 16th-19th Amendments • Moral reform focus • State + local action Gradual, voluntary reform New Deal (1933-1939) • AAA, NIRA, Social Security • Direct relief (CCC, WPA) • Banking reform (FDIC) • Economic crisis response • Federal-level action Urgent, sweeping intervention SHARED Expanded federal power to address economic inequality

Example: WWI vs. WWII Mobilization

Both world wars required the U.S. government to mobilize the economy, but the scale and methods differed dramatically.

WWI (1917-18)
War Industries Board coordinated production; Food Administration encouraged voluntary conservation; propaganda via CPI; Espionage and Sedition Acts curtailed dissent
WWII (1941-45)
War Production Board oversaw massive conversion to war production; rationing enforced by OPA; Executive Order 9066 interned Japanese Americans; women and minorities entered workforce at unprecedented scale

Civil Liberties in Wartime

WWI WWII
Key Legislation Espionage Act (1917), Sedition Act (1918) Executive Order 9066 (1942)
Target Group Anti-war dissenters, socialists, German Americans Japanese Americans on the West Coast
Method Prosecution and imprisonment Mass internment in camps
Supreme Court Schenck v. U.S.: "clear and present danger" Korematsu v. U.S.: upheld internment
Scale ~2,000 prosecutions ~120,000 people interned

The 1920s vs. the 1930s

These consecutive decades offer a sharp contrast in government philosophy and cultural mood.

Roaring Twenties
Laissez-faire economics under Harding, Coolidge, Hoover; consumer boom; cultural modernism clashing with traditionalism (Scopes Trial, Prohibition, KKK revival)
Depression Thirties
FDR's interventionist New Deal; mass unemployment and poverty; cultural emphasis on social realism; new political coalition (New Deal Coalition) reshapes American politics

Women's Roles Across Period 7

1890s-1910s
Progressive Reformers
Women led settlement houses (Jane Addams), temperance movements, and the suffrage campaign
1917-18
WWI Workers
Women entered factories and offices, strengthening the case for the 19th Amendment (1920)
1920s
Flappers and New Freedoms
Cultural liberation in cities, but traditional roles persisted in rural America
1930s
New Deal Era
Eleanor Roosevelt expanded women's public role; Frances Perkins became first female cabinet member
1941-45
Rosie the Riveter
6 million women entered the workforce; gains were largely reversed after the war

Comparing Reform Movements

Progressivism New Deal
Time Period 1890s-1920 1933-1939
Primary Cause Industrialization, urbanization Great Depression
Government Role Regulation and oversight Direct intervention and relief
Key Methods Legislation, amendments, muckraking Alphabet agencies, deficit spending
Coalition Middle-class reformers, journalists Labor, minorities, Southern whites, urban poor
Legacy Regulatory precedents (FDA, FTC) Social safety net (Social Security, FDIC)

Foreign Policy: Interventionism vs. Isolationism

Period 7 features a tug-of-war between interventionist and isolationist impulses. Understanding how and why the U.S. shifted between these positions is a core comparison skill.

1
Spanish-American War (1898): The U.S. emerged as an imperial power, acquiring Philippines, Puerto Rico, Guam
2
WWI entry (1917): Wilson framed it as making the world "safe for democracy," but Senate rejected the League of Nations
3
Interwar isolationism (1920s-30s): Neutrality Acts sought to prevent entanglement; public wary of another war
4
WWII entry (1941): Pearl Harbor ended isolationism; U.S. became leader of Allied powers and postwar international order

Common Mistakes in Comparison Essays

✕ Listing Without Analyzing
Simply stating facts about each topic without explicitly comparing them. You must use language like "similarly," "in contrast," or "unlike."
✕ Vague Claims
Writing "they were different" without specifying how. Name the category of comparison and provide precise evidence.
✕ Missing the "Why"
Identifying a difference but never explaining what historical factors caused it. The explanation earns the analysis point on the rubric.

Period 7 Comparison Summary

Comparison Pair Similarity Key Difference
Progressivism vs. New Deal Expanded federal power Regulation vs. direct intervention
WWI vs. WWII mobilization Gov't coordinated economy Scale and duration far greater in WWII
WWI vs. WWII civil liberties Wartime restrictions Racial targeting in WWII (internment)
1920s vs. 1930s Cultural tension and change Laissez-faire vs. interventionism
Women in WWI vs. WWII Entered workforce during war WWII was far larger in scale and visibility

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best describes a similarity between the Progressive Era and the New Deal?

Question 2 of 5

A key difference between civil liberties restrictions during WWI and WWII was that:

Question 3 of 5

Which factor best explains why the New Deal represented a greater expansion of federal power than the Progressive Era?

Question 4 of 5

The historians above would most likely agree that:

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following is the best example of a well-constructed historical comparison for Period 7?