Comparison in
Period 7 (1890-1945)
Master the AP skill of historical comparison by analyzing the similarities and differences between major developments of the Progressive Era, WWI, the Roaring Twenties, the Great Depression, and WWII.
What Is Historical Comparison?
Historical comparison is the AP skill of identifying and explaining similarities and differences between two or more historical developments, processes, or events. It requires more than simply listing facts: you must analyze why those similarities and differences matter in context.
Why Period 7 Is Ideal for Comparison
Period 7 (1890-1945) contains recurring patterns: reform movements, wartime mobilization, debates over government power, and struggles for civil rights. These parallel developments invite natural comparisons.
Period 7 Timeline at a Glance
The Comparison Framework
Similarity vs. Difference
AP readers reward nuance. A similarity claim shows two developments share a feature; a difference claim shows how they diverge. Both require specific evidence and explanation.
How to Write a Strong Comparison
Example: Progressivism vs. New Deal
Example: WWI vs. WWII Mobilization
Both world wars required the U.S. government to mobilize the economy, but the scale and methods differed dramatically.
Civil Liberties in Wartime
| WWI | WWII | |
|---|---|---|
| Key Legislation | Espionage Act (1917), Sedition Act (1918) | Executive Order 9066 (1942) |
| Target Group | Anti-war dissenters, socialists, German Americans | Japanese Americans on the West Coast |
| Method | Prosecution and imprisonment | Mass internment in camps |
| Supreme Court | Schenck v. U.S.: "clear and present danger" | Korematsu v. U.S.: upheld internment |
| Scale | ~2,000 prosecutions | ~120,000 people interned |
The 1920s vs. the 1930s
These consecutive decades offer a sharp contrast in government philosophy and cultural mood.
Women's Roles Across Period 7
Comparing Reform Movements
| Progressivism | New Deal | |
|---|---|---|
| Time Period | 1890s-1920 | 1933-1939 |
| Primary Cause | Industrialization, urbanization | Great Depression |
| Government Role | Regulation and oversight | Direct intervention and relief |
| Key Methods | Legislation, amendments, muckraking | Alphabet agencies, deficit spending |
| Coalition | Middle-class reformers, journalists | Labor, minorities, Southern whites, urban poor |
| Legacy | Regulatory precedents (FDA, FTC) | Social safety net (Social Security, FDIC) |
Foreign Policy: Interventionism vs. Isolationism
Period 7 features a tug-of-war between interventionist and isolationist impulses. Understanding how and why the U.S. shifted between these positions is a core comparison skill.
Common Mistakes in Comparison Essays
Period 7 Comparison Summary
| Comparison Pair | Similarity | Key Difference |
|---|---|---|
| Progressivism vs. New Deal | Expanded federal power | Regulation vs. direct intervention |
| WWI vs. WWII mobilization | Gov't coordinated economy | Scale and duration far greater in WWII |
| WWI vs. WWII civil liberties | Wartime restrictions | Racial targeting in WWII (internment) |
| 1920s vs. 1930s | Cultural tension and change | Laissez-faire vs. interventionism |
| Women in WWI vs. WWII | Entered workforce during war | WWII was far larger in scale and visibility |
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following best describes a similarity between the Progressive Era and the New Deal?
Question 2 of 5
A key difference between civil liberties restrictions during WWI and WWII was that:
Question 3 of 5
Which factor best explains why the New Deal represented a greater expansion of federal power than the Progressive Era?
Question 4 of 5
Historian A: "The shift from the laissez-faire policies of the 1920s to the interventionist New Deal in the 1930s represents the most dramatic transformation in American governance in the twentieth century. The crash of 1929 shattered the ideological foundations of limited government."
Historian B: "While the New Deal certainly expanded federal power, it built upon Progressive Era precedents. The regulatory framework established by Roosevelt, Wilson, and other Progressives laid the groundwork that FDR's administration expanded during the Depression."
The historians above would most likely agree that:
Question 5 of 5
Which of the following is the best example of a well-constructed historical comparison for Period 7?