01 / 21

Comparison in
Period 5

Master the AP skill of historical comparison by analyzing the similarities and differences among movements, events, and ideologies from 1844 to 1877.

AP U.S. History

What Is Historical Comparison?

Historical comparison is an AP reasoning skill that requires you to identify and explain similarities and differences between historical developments, events, policies, or movements. On the AP exam, comparison questions appear in both the multiple-choice section and the long essay question (LEQ).

Period 5: 1844 to 1877

Period 5 spans from westward expansion through Reconstruction. The central tension is the struggle over slavery and the meaning of American freedom, culminating in the Civil War and its aftermath.

1846
Mexican-American War
Territorial expansion reignites slavery debate
1850
Compromise of 1850
Temporary sectional compromise with Fugitive Slave Act
1854
Kansas-Nebraska Act
Popular sovereignty replaces Missouri Compromise line
1861
Civil War Begins
Secession and armed conflict over union and slavery
1865
13th Amendment
Abolition of slavery; Reconstruction begins
1877
End of Reconstruction
Compromise of 1877; federal troops withdraw from South

Key Comparison Categories in Period 5

Sectional Views
North vs. South on slavery, economy, and states' rights
Reform Movements
Abolitionism vs. women's rights: overlapping yet divergent goals
Reconstruction Plans
Presidential vs. Congressional approaches to rebuilding the South

The Comparison Framework

Topic A Unique features Topic B Unique features Similarities Shared causes, effects, or goals Historical Context: Why do these similarities and differences exist?

North vs. South: Sectional Tensions

North South
Economy Industrial, wage labor Agricultural, enslaved labor
View of Slavery Free soil / abolitionist Positive good / states' rights
Federal Power Supported tariffs, internal improvements Favored limited federal government
Expansion Free territories for free labor Expand slavery into new territories
Shared Value Both invoked the Constitution to justify their positions

Abolitionism vs. Women's Rights

Similarities
Both emerged from the Second Great Awakening. Both used moral persuasion and demanded equal rights under natural law. Many activists participated in both movements.
Differences
Abolitionists focused on ending slavery; women's rights advocates sought suffrage and legal equality. After the 15th Amendment, the movements split over whether to support Black male suffrage without women's suffrage.

How to Write a Strong Comparison

1
Identify the two topics. What exactly are you comparing? Be specific: not just "North and South" but "Northern and Southern views on westward expansion in the 1850s."
2
State a similarity. Use a clear topic sentence: "Both the North and South believed that westward expansion was essential to their economic futures."
3
State a difference. Explain what sets them apart: "However, they differed on whether new territories should permit slavery."
4
Explain the significance. Connect to historical context: "This disagreement intensified after the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 because..."
5
Use specific evidence. Name people, laws, dates, and events to support each claim.

Example: Compromise of 1850 vs. Kansas-Nebraska Act

Compromise of 1850 • CA admitted free • Fugitive Slave Act • Popular sovereignty in Utah/NM territories • Henry Clay / Daniel Webster brokered deal Goal: Preserve Union Kansas-Nebraska Act • Repealed MO Compromise • Popular sovereignty in Kansas and Nebraska • Led to "Bleeding Kansas" • Stephen Douglas pushed for transcontinental RR Result: Deepened division Both used popular sovereignty

Presidential vs. Congressional Reconstruction

Presidential Congressional
Leaders Lincoln, then Johnson Radical Republicans (Stevens, Sumner)
Approach Lenient: quick reunification Punitive: Southern states must meet conditions
Freedpeople Limited protections 14th & 15th Amendments; Freedmen's Bureau
Power Executive-led Legislative-led
Shared Goal Both aimed to reintegrate Southern states into the Union

Lincoln's Plan vs. Johnson's Plan

Lincoln (1863)
Ten Percent Plan: 10% of voters take loyalty oath. Lenient to speed reunification. Supported limited Black suffrage for educated men and veterans.
Johnson (1865)
Pardoned most Confederates. Required ratification of 13th Amendment but allowed Black Codes. Vetoed civil rights legislation.

Economic vs. Moral Arguments Against Slavery

Free Soil / Economic
Opposed slavery's expansion because it threatened white wage laborers. Did not necessarily advocate racial equality. Wanted western land for free white settlers.
Abolitionist / Moral
Condemned slavery as a moral evil. Frederick Douglass, William Lloyd Garrison, and Harriet Tubman demanded immediate emancipation and (for some) racial equality.

Visions of Manifest Destiny

Manifest Destiny Northern Vision Free labor, free soil Expand democracy Southern Vision Expand plantation slavery Maintain political balance Shared Belief American expansion was inevitable and divinely sanctioned

The Reconstruction Amendments

13th (1865)
Abolished slavery throughout the United States. Applied to private and public actors.
14th (1868)
Granted citizenship and equal protection under the law. Targeted state governments.
15th (1870)
Prohibited denying the vote based on race. Did not address literacy tests or poll taxes.

Common Mistakes in Period 5 Comparisons

✕ Listing Without Analyzing
Simply stating "the North was industrial and the South was agricultural" is description, not comparison. You must explain why this difference mattered.
✕ Ignoring Similarities
Students often focus only on differences. Strong essays also identify what two movements or policies shared in common.
✕ Vague Evidence
Saying "people disagreed about slavery" is too vague. Name specific events: the Dred Scott decision, Bleeding Kansas, the Compromise of 1850.

Period 5 Comparison Summary

Comparison Pair Key Similarity Key Difference
North vs. South Both valued expansion Free labor vs. slave labor
Abolitionists vs. Free Soil Opposed slavery's spread Moral vs. economic motives
Presidential vs. Congressional Reconstruction Restore the Union Lenient vs. punitive terms
Lincoln vs. Johnson Executive-led plans Evolving vs. hostile to Black rights
13th vs. 14th vs. 15th Amendments All expanded freedom Liberty vs. citizenship vs. suffrage

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best describes a similarity between the Compromise of 1850 and the Kansas-Nebraska Act?

Question 2 of 5

A key difference between Presidential Reconstruction and Congressional Reconstruction was that:

Question 3 of 5

The abolitionist and women's rights movements of the antebellum period were similar in that both:

Question 4 of 5

Which statement best captures the difference between the Free Soil movement and the abolitionist movement?

Question 5 of 5

Speakers A and B disagree most directly about: